• news-banner

    Expert Insights

Playing Copycat – Why have M&S begun legal action against Aldi over Colin the Caterpillar?

Last week it was announced that retail giant Marks & Spencer had begun legal action against German supermarket Aldi, over its renowned Colin the Caterpillar cake. An intellectual property claim has been filed with the UK High Court, as M&S claim their product has been infringed and the similarities between the budget brand’s Cuthbert the Caterpillar cake has damaged M&S’s reputation.

M&S’s chocolate caterpillar was the first of its kind to land on our supermarket shelves, over 30 years ago. Therefore, it is no surprise that the company took steps to protect the identity of the cake, applying for UK trade marks in 2008 and more recently in 2020. Colin’s first application was successfully registered in April 2009, allowing M&S to bring an action for infringement against anyone else attempting to use the name ‘Colin the Caterpillar’ under class 30, relating to various food types. More recently, M&S took a significant step further and protected the packaging of the cake as a trade mark. By doing so they have protected the caterpillar cake even further and it will be interesting to see how much weight the High Court places on this mark.

Will M&S be successful?

Whilst the details are not public, it seems likely M&S will need to prove that Cuthbert the Caterpillar is so similar to Colin the Caterpillar that it creates a likelihood of confusion for consumers. Furthermore, the premium food supplier is likely concerned about having its product associated and confused with a budget brand, believing Aldi “rides on the coat-tails” of M&S’s reputation.

Arguably when looking at the two cakes side by side, the similarities are very apparent. The cake itself is nearly identical, featuring the same white chocolate face and multi-coloured chocolate toppings. The packaging features the same green colour scheme, with the only real difference being that Cuthbert is presented vertically, whilst Colin sits horizontally in its packaging. As with the name, both caterpillars sound very similar and could leave consumers confused, as to who is who.

Taking the above into account, it seems that M&S will try to rely on their registered trade marks in order to protect the caterpillar cake. Their registrations may be easier to enforce and rely upon, rather than the common law right of passing off, to protect their reputation in the cake.  To rely on the passing off argument, M&S will need to prove that Colin’s appearance is so renowned and commonly recognised that any consumers would identify the caterpillar as an M&S product, resulting in a misrepresentation or confusion in the marketplace.

Why Aldi?

Aldi is not the first and only supermarket to launch its take on Colin the Caterpillar. The first ‘copycat’ appeared on supermarket shelves back in 2011 and since then many other retailers have followed suit. Most similarly, we have Asda’s Clyde the Caterpillar, Tesco’s Curly the Caterpillar, Waitrose’s Cecil the Caterpillar, One Stop’s Clive the Caterpillar and the Co-op’s Curious Caterpillar. In addition, some supermarkets have opted for more distinctive caterpillars and have not taken on the alliterative name; examples include Sainsbury’s Wiggles the Caterpillar and Morrison’s Morris the Caterpillar. Given that so many other supermarkets have launched their own caterpillars, all of which bear very similar names, looks and packaging to that of Colin, this leads to one big question on everybody’s mind, why Aldi?

It is interesting to note that Aldi is the first supermarket to bring out a ‘look alike’ cake since M&S trade marked Colin’s figurative look in 2020. M&S may believe that having this additional mark under their belt will help them to achieve a successful claim against any further supermarkets trying to copy their cake, leading them to finally pursue action.

If the courts do find in M&S’s favour, this will set a precedent going forwards which the other supermarkets may feel the brunt of. Moreover, the case may set down a precedent that shapes intellectual property law more broadly in the future.

Social media war

The dispute quickly led to a social media war with the hashtags #SaveColin and #FreeCuthbert trending on Twitter. If anything, both retailers seem to be capitalising on the publicity by producing viral social media content, raising the profile of both cakes. Aldi appears to be taking the case on in good humour, mocking M&S with its tweet “This is not just any court case, this is… #FreeCuthbert.” The German retailer has even teased the launch of a limited edition caterpillar on their Twitter page, antagonising the case even further.

This is not the first time big brands have taken to social media in an attempt to produce ambush marketing. There are many parallels that can be drawn between the behaviours of M&S and Aldi, to even the sporting industry with the likes, to take just one example, of Paddy Power’s marking campaign in relation to the 2012 Olympic Games. The advertisement stated that they were the “Official Sponsor of the Largest Athletics Event in London this Year” with the betting brand explaining that they were referring to an egg and spoon race they were sponsoring in London, France. More recent examples include Ryanair’s humorous TikTok videos, mocking other airlines and generating themselves free publicity.

Concluding remarks

Colin the Caterpillar was the first of its kind and an original chocolate caterpillar to hit our shelves, leading to a UK favourite for birthday cakes and snacks. This will certainly put the cake in good stead and aid M&S’s case. The court will have to decide on whether Aldi is commercially benefiting from the introduction of Cuthbert by marketing such a similar product. The ultimate aim for M&S is to have the caterpillar removed from sale in all Aldi stores and have an agreement put in place that Aldi cannot sell anything similar In the future. In light of the dispute, Aldi has not stocked the cake since mid-February; leading to the ultimate question: “Will Cuthbert return”?

Our thinking

  • Trading insolvently or trading out of difficulty? Are we being naughty or did we have the best intentions? Part 3

    Claudine Morgan

    Insights

  • Ctrl + GCC: The Rise of e-Sports in the Gulf

    Mark Hill

    Quick Reads

  • Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Bill: Will new consumer protection rules restrict access to Gift Aid?

    Verity Heath

    Quick Reads

  • Radical reforms to fight economic crime: what should businesses do now?

    Rhys Novak

    Insights

  • Arbitration Rules – How Different Are They?

    Mazin Al Mardhi

    Insights

  • Caroline Swain writes for Startups Magazine on 'Green Claims'

    Caroline Swain

    In the Press

  • Caroline Swain writes for Fashion Capital on the EU’s new legal framework on textiles

    Caroline Swain

    In the Press

  • The End of the SAG-AFTRA Strike & What it Means for the Middle East

    Mark Hill

    Quick Reads

  • Tech Monitor quotes Gareth Mills on the CMA restricting Meta from using certain customer data

    Gareth Mills

    In the Press

  • UAE Strengthens its Position as Leading Destination for A.I.

    Mark Hill

    Quick Reads

  • Dubai Court of Cassation Extends Arbitration Agreement Across Subsequent Contracts

    Peter Smith

    Quick Reads

  • The rise in ESG reporting requirements for UK directors and of related shareholder activism

    Stephen Burns

    Insights

  • Top 5 tips for businesses to mitigate legal and regulatory risks associated with AI

    Janine Regan

    Insights

  • Private Mergers & Acquisitions in the United Arab Emirates

    William Reichert

    Insights

  • Jamie Cartwright writes for FoodBev Media on 'greedflation'

    Jamie Cartwright

    In the Press

  • UAE Polishes Federal Arbitration Law

    Peter Smith

    Quick Reads

  • Drone deliveries: Be Prepared

    Emma Humphreys

    Quick Reads

  • Charles Russell Speechlys expands commercial offering with the appointment of Rebecca Steer

    Rebecca Steer

    News

  • The Times quotes Gareth Mills on the CMA’s preliminary approval of the Activision Blizzard-Microsoft deal

    Gareth Mills

    In the Press

  • City AM quotes Gareth Mills on the CMA’s new set of principles for regulating AI

    Gareth Mills

    In the Press

  • Silicon quotes Gareth Mills on the UK consumer lawsuit against Google

    Gareth Mills

    In the Press

  • Bloomberg and The Washington Post quote Richard Davies on multiclub ownership in world sports

    Richard Davies

    In the Press

  • Product compliance and Brexit - UK Government concedes to CE markings indefinite recognition

    Jamie Cartwright

    Quick Reads

  • UAE and the Grey List: Brief Update

    Karl Masi

    Insights

  • A Summer of Sport - Top 5 Legal Considerations

    Anna Sowerby

    Insights

  • Has the Orpéa plan impaired shareholder's consent? - Le plan de sauvegarde d'Orpéa n'a-t-il pas vicié le consentement des actionnaires historiques ?

    Dimitri-André Sonier

    Quick Reads

  • The Express quotes Gareth Mills on the CMA’s report on competition in the groceries sector

    Gareth Mills

    In the Press

  • Reuters quotes Gareth Mills on the CMA’s deadline extension of the Microsoft Activision Blizzard deal

    Gareth Mills

    In the Press

  • Les défaillances en France proches de leur niveau de 2019 - French insolvencies close to 2019 levels

    Dimitri-André Sonier

    Quick Reads

  • Law.com International quotes Simon Ridpath on the use of AI in the legal sector

    Simon Ridpath

    In the Press

  • Casino Group: An agreement with investors and debt holders is expected at the end of July

    Dimitri-André Sonier

    Quick Reads

  • DIAC Issues First Annual Report

    Georgia Fullarton

    Quick Reads

  • One year on: "Influencer Culture: lights, camera, inaction" remains astonishingly accurate

    Caroline Swain

    Quick Reads

  • Saudi Center for Commercial Arbitration publishes new Arbitration Rules

    Peter Smith

    Quick Reads

  • WhatsAppGate - Should businesses be reviewing their social media policies?

    Anna Rogers

    Quick Reads

  • Dubai announces its plan to streamline the enforcement of civil judgments and arbitral awards

    Peter Smith

    Quick Reads

  • Sign of the times - the British record football transfer which very nearly didn't happen

    Pei Li Kew

    Quick Reads

  • No love (island) lost for the #muffboss – #ad is great but don’t forget the other ad rules

    Caroline Swain

    Quick Reads

  • Is it really against the law to share your Netflix password?

    Quick Reads

  • Omnichannel innovation essential in the face of outlet decline

    Caroline Swain

    Quick Reads

Back to top