• news-banner

    Expert Insights

Coronavirus: The Premier League v the Broadcasters – a clash of titans?

As we all come to terms with the new working environments and lifestyles imposed on us by the Coronavirus pandemic, one question that continues to be asked is “will the 2019-20 Premier League season be completed?”

As we all come to terms with the new working environments and lifestyles imposed on us by the Coronavirus pandemic, one question that continues to be asked is “will the 2019-20 Premier League season be completed?”

As we all come to terms with the new working environments and lifestyles imposed on us by the Coronavirus pandemic, one question that continues to be asked is “will the 2019-20 Premier League season be completed?”

As we all come to terms with the new working environments and lifestyles imposed on us by the Coronavirus pandemic, one question that continues to be asked is “will the 2019-20 Premier League season be completed?”

Following the Premier League’s announcement last Friday that the season would only be completed if it is “safe and appropriate to do so” and that any return would only be with the “full support of the Government and when medical guidance allows,” the answer to this question still remains unclear.

Some argue that, given the circumstances, completing the season shouldn’t be a priority, and that the time, money and resources that would be necessary to complete the season would be better utilised elsewhere.

On the other hand, a return of Premier League football to our screens – even if the remaining games were to be played behind closed doors – would no doubt be a major boost to both the country’s morale and to the economy.

Background

The Premier League – and its clubs – have a separate interest in completing the season, and that is to avoid the financial liabilities to broadcasters that might be incurred if the season is not completed. Existing broadcasting rights deals see the Premier League receive around £5bn from domestic broadcasters Sky Sports and BT Sport, and around £4.35bn from international broadcasters. The Premier League then distributes the monies to clubs based on factors including each club’s number of TV appearances, their final positions, and fixed participation fees.  

The Premier League has already been paid the entirety of its broadcast money for the 2019/20 season – it receives its fees in two annual instalments, August and February – but it has been reported that broadcasters would seek to be paid back a total of £762 million should the remaining games not be played, as they would consider the Premier League and the clubs to have breached their contracts with them.

Force Majeure?

A force majeure clause, in England and Wales, is a clause that exists in commercial contracts whereby a party is freed from certain (or all) obligations under a contract if certain extraordinary events that are beyond the control of the parties occur.

Force majeure is not a concept under English law and therefore its applicability (to contracts governed by English law) is determined strictly by the terms of the contract. English courts construe force majeure clauses narrowly - i.e. if an event is not listed in the clause, it is unlikely to be considered as a force majeure event.

The Premier League and the clubs will likely be reviewing their contracts with broadcasters to see whether the force majeure clauses cover pandemics, to what extent they are covered, and whether they are subject to any mitigation clauses.

For example, if a force majeure clause does cover pandemics (which in itself is not a given and will depend on the drafting), but is also subject to a mitigation clause, the broadcasters may argue that measures to mitigate the effects of the pandemic – such as playing matches behind closed doors – could be taken, and that therefore the force majeure event hasn’t made fulfilling the obligation impossible.

On the flip side, French broadcaster Canal+ has informed the French professional football leagues that, invoking its force majeure rights, it will not be paying its next instalment of broadcasting monies, totalling 110 million euros.

In contrast to the position under English law where the applicability of force majeure is determined by the terms of each individual contract, in French law it is a defined concept. Article 1218 of the French Civil Code provides a specific criteria that defines a force majeure event. The occurrence of such an event justifies suspension or termination of a contract, even if the contract does not specifically include a force majeure provision.

Other jurisdictions will have different principles relating to force majeure, and so in addition to checking the material terms of their contracts, the Premier League, clubs, and broadcasters will also need to consider the governing law of each contract.

The Wider Effects

If the season is not able to be completed, then whether the Premier League and its clubs reach a settlement agreement with broadcasters or whether the dispute proceeds to litigation remains to be seen.

There is no doubt however that broadcasters will feel aggrieved that they had paid significant sums and not been able to broadcast any football. On the other hand, the Premier League’s statement last week confirmed that its priority was the health and wellbeing of the nation.

It is also clear that, in the interim, both sides of the dispute will have important commercial decisions to make.

Premier League clubs Tottenham Hotspur and Newcastle United have confirmed that they will be placing non-playing staff into furlough and seeking government assistance under the Coronavirus Job Retention Scheme in order to pay those staff. The decision taken by these clubs to request taxpayer funds to pay non-playing staff, whilst players may be earning up to £200,000 a week, has attracted criticism from both fans and MP’s.

Meanwhile, Sky Sports and BT Sports are suffering from both:

  1. loss of subscribers due to the lack of sports (and in particular, football) that they are able to show at the moment; and
  2. loss of advertising revenue due to the most lucrative advertising windows – those before, during and after Premier League games – currently not existing.

The loss of revenue that will arise from this may mean that their bids for future Premier League broadcasting rights will be reduced – which would ultimately mean less money for clubs to spend on high-profile players.

It goes without saying that these are unprecedented and strange times. However, we are continuing business as usual, and both our Commercial and Commercial Disputes teams are on hand to assist with any issues that clients in the Sports, Retail and Technology sectors may be facing.  

Our thinking

  • IBA Annual Conference 2023

    Charlotte Ford

    Events

  • Doing business in the UAE & Israel

    William Reichert

    Events

  • New Hong Kong crypto regime: trading platforms falling foul already?

    Patrick Chan

    Insights

  • What next for HS2?

    Richard Flenley

    Quick Reads

  • Charles Russell Speechlys expands commercial offering with the appointment of Rebecca Steer

    Rebecca Steer

    News

  • The Times quotes Gareth Mills on the CMA’s preliminary approval of the Activision Blizzard-Microsoft deal

    Gareth Mills

    In the Press

  • Mediation as a pillar of dispute resolution: it’s happening, embrace it

    Jamie Cartwright

    Quick Reads

  • The misapplication of sports law and regulation in Spanish football

    Darren Bailey

    Quick Reads

  • Hong Kong’s top court makes declaration in favour of same-sex partnerships

    Lisa Wong

    Insights

  • City AM quotes Gareth Mills on the CMA’s new set of principles for regulating AI

    Gareth Mills

    In the Press

  • A warning to all businesses: significant fine underscores the importance of maintaining workplace Health & Safety

    Rory Partridge

    Quick Reads

  • Silicon quotes Gareth Mills on the UK consumer lawsuit against Google

    Gareth Mills

    In the Press

  • Common construction claims in Bahrain

    Mazin Al Mardhi

    Insights

  • Enforcement of Foreign Judgments - UAE: DIFC

    Patrick Gearon FCIArb

    Insights

  • Financial Reporter quotes Rhys Novak on a new FCA review into the treatment of PEPs

    Rhys Novak

    In the Press

  • Enforcement of Judgments

    Patrick Gearon FCIArb

    Insights

  • Football Insider quotes Kelvin Tanner and Owen Chan on how the ESC Endorsement Path could affect scouting and transfers

    Kelvin Tanner

    In the Press

  • The Supreme Court's decision in PACCAR: litigation funding stopped in its trucks?

    Hanh Nguyen

    Insights

  • Football Insider quotes Kelvin Tanner and Owen Chan on the FA's new ESC Endorsement Path

    Kelvin Tanner

    In the Press

  • Investigating fraud: an expansion of legal professional privilege?

    Simon Heatley

    Insights

  • Bloomberg and The Washington Post quote Richard Davies on multiclub ownership in world sports

    Richard Davies

    In the Press

  • Product compliance and Brexit - UK Government concedes to CE markings indefinite recognition

    Jamie Cartwright

    Quick Reads

  • Recognising financial abuse in a relationship

    Vanessa Duff

    Quick Reads

  • Million Dollar Footballer With No Assets?

    David Carver

    Quick Reads

  • Trading insolvently or trading out of difficulty? Are we being naughty or did we have the best intentions? Part 2

    Claudine Morgan

    Insights

  • Conflicts of Interest in International Commercial Arbitration

    Dalal Alhouti

    Insights

  • UAE and the Grey List: Brief Update

    Karl Masi

    Insights

  • Has the Orpéa plan impaired shareholder's consent? - Le plan de sauvegarde d'Orpéa n'a-t-il pas vicié le consentement des actionnaires historiques ?

    Dimitri-André Sonier

    Quick Reads

  • Don’t push it… Quincecare duty clarified

    Caroline Greenwell

    Quick Reads

  • Will the downturn in the Paris region property market lead property companies to turn to ad hoc proceedings, as they did in the 1990s?

    Dimitri-André Sonier

    Quick Reads

  • Pandora Papers: HMRC nudge taxpayers to come out of their box

    Hugh Gunson

    Quick Reads

  • Les défaillances en France proches de leur niveau de 2019 - French insolvencies close to 2019 levels

    Dimitri-André Sonier

    Quick Reads

  • Casino Group: An agreement with investors and debt holders is expected at the end of July

    Dimitri-André Sonier

    Quick Reads

  • DIAC Issues First Annual Report

    Georgia Fullarton

    Quick Reads

  • Dispute Resolution: The Case for Mediation

    Marjan Mirrezaei

    Quick Reads

  • Machinery Regulations respond to the rise of AI

    Jamie Cartwright

    Quick Reads

  • Delay could bar your probate claim

    Katelyn Silver

    Quick Reads

  • One year on: "Influencer Culture: lights, camera, inaction" remains astonishingly accurate

    Caroline Swain

    Quick Reads

  • Saudi Center for Commercial Arbitration publishes new Arbitration Rules

    Peter Smith

    Quick Reads

  • From Farm to Fork: The Vital Role of Traceability in Meeting the UK's Sustainable Food Demands and Fighting Food Fraud

    Jamie Cartwright

    Quick Reads

Back to top