Time given for negotiations before compulsory acquisition of rights to light
Having failed to negotiate the settlement of a rights to light dispute with the owner of neighbouring 1 Finsbury Circus, the developer of 120 Moorgate sought help from the City Corporation. The Planning Officer's report recommended the use of statutory powers to facilitate the development but the Planning and Transportation Committee appeared reluctant to approve their use. This article looks at the issues and asks the all-important question of where this leaves developers.
Planning permission was granted in 2011 for the proposed development of 120 Moorgate into almost 200,000 square feet of office and retail space. The scheme has been on hold since then due to a dispute with the owner of 1 Finsbury Circus over the likely loss of light to their building. During the five years since planning permission was granted, negotiations between the developer and the neighbouring owners have been very slow. In order to try and move the discussions forward the developer obtained permission in December 2015 for a revised 'cut-back' scheme reducing the loss of light. A report put before the City's Planning and Transportation Committee concluded that, notwithstanding all of the developer's efforts, a negotiated settlement was unlikely. Therefore, the recommendation was for the Committee to exercise its powers under Section 227 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 to acquire the development site for planning purposes and effectively allow them to override the neighbouring owner's rights under Section 237 of that Act.
Acquisition for planning purposes
Given the serious consequences of the operation of these powers, local authorities are reluctant to use them other than as a last resort. The last documented case where the City was asked to engage these powers was the Goldman Sachs headquarters. In that case two neighbouring owners had refused compensation payments of £1.3 million each and so Goldmans asked the City to step in and assist. As with 120 Moorgate, when the recommendation first came before the Committee it was postponed to allow time for further negotiation. The Goldman Sachs development amounts to almost one million square feet of office space to house one of the City's largest employers. It is easier to see the wider public benefit in that case, which is an important factor in the exercise of these powers.
Where now for 120 Moorgate?
The owners of 1 Finsbury Circus sent a last minute email to the City shortly before the meeting at which the recommendation was to be considered indicating they were prepared to negotiate. Whether this was a cynical ploy to buy further time remains to be seen. For now consideration has been postponed to the next meeting in March and it will be very interesting to see what happens should a settlement not be achieved by then.
Where does this leave developers?
The uncertainty surrounding the resolution of rights to light disputes remains a major factor on the developer's risk register. There is a real need for more certainty which could come in one of three possible ways:
- new laws enacted by Parliament;
- a decision of the higher courts;
- increased assistance from local authorities through the use of their statutory powers.
The Law Commission produced recommendations for change in December 2014 but there is no sign of those being advanced any time soon. The City's approach to 120 Moorgate shows that local authorities remain nervous about stepping in to assist. There is, however, a glimmer of hope from the courts in the shape of a case due before the Court of Appeal in July this year which may provide further guidance.
Paula Boast is interviewed by Construction Week on Bahrain's construction industry and how it is moving towards more functional and responsible building
Dissecting Bahrain's construction practices
Part 1: The Tip of the Triangle – Examining London’s Potential in the Life Sciences Sector
Construction News quotes David Savage on the slight rise in construction output in September
"It remains to be seen how the sector reacted in October amid the political turmoil"
Court of Appeal decides defective notice to quit not saved by 'Mannai' principles
The Court of Appeal handed down judgment in the second appeal in O G Thomas Amaethyddiath v Turner & Ors  EWCA Civ 1446.
Property Patter: Damages
Remedies are perhaps the main thing on a client’s mind when they start the process of litigation.
Q&A: Code rights queries answered
Samuel Lear and Jonathan Wills field Telecoms Code questions in the light of a recent Supreme Court decision.
Manoj Vaghela features in The Times: Lawyer of the Week and The Law Society Gazette: Lawyer in the news
Lawyer of the week: Manoj Vaghela, who acted for Greggs in landmark ruling triggered by Covid-19 crisis
Private Equity News quotes Darren Bailey on the Americanisation of UK football
“We’re seeing an Americanisation where the matchday is turning into much more of an entertainment beyond just the sporting spectacle”
HR Magazine quotes Anne-Marie Balfour on the importance of protecting employee data
Interserve handed £4 million fine after staff data breach
South China Morning Post quotes Simon Green on Hong Kong investment into UK property
“With the increase in energy prices in 2022, this will be something for buyers and homeowners to consider.”
Charles Russell Speechlys was delighted to advise Bellway Homes Kent on the purchase of the site, at Mill Lane, Hailsham
We are delighted to advise Bellway Homes Kent on the purchase of the site, at Mill Lane, Hailsham.
Charles Russell Speechlys features in the Financial Worldwide discussing sustainability in the retail industry
Our experts discuss the factors pushing sustainability up the agenda in the retail industry.
The future of investment zones
Charles Russell Speechlys advises Housebuilder Countryside in its partnership with Redbridge council to build up to 1,000 homes in east London centre
Charles Russell Speechlys has acted for Countryside for over 35 years.
People & Places – What will the next ten years of Health & Safety enforcement look like?
A deeper look into the next ten years of Health and Safety enforcement.
Roger Elford writes for EG on the UK restructuring regime
Is the UK restructuring regime fit for purpose?
Property Week quote Michael O’Connor and Carolyn Davies on what extended retrospective liability for defects under the Building Safety Act means for developers
Developers risk claims dating back 30 years under new act
Property Patter: Break options in renewal leases
How break rights work for business tenancies protected by the 1954 Act.
Top 10 Tips: The Registration Gap
The Land Registry is reporting its longest delays in registrations in years.
Charles Russell Speechlys advises Silbury Finance on a £59.3m facility to the Audley Group.
"We are delighted to have completed a second deal in a short period of time with Silbury." Jon Bond, Partner