A Brave New World: Economic Substance
With offices in London, Geneva and Zurich, we are well placed to provide integrated advice on the Economic Substance Laws.
The Economic Substance Laws
The Economic Substance Laws are regulations which require ‘Relevant Entities’ carrying on ‘Relevant Activities’ to show economic substance in their jurisdiction of incorporation.
The aim is to counteract the effects of zero tax and preferential tax regimes. The local tax authorities can impose significant fines and the eventual sanction of strike off if a company that is caught by the laws fails to comply.
Who needs to be aware of these laws?
The EU Council’s list of jurisdictions required to introduce substance laws are Anguilla, the Bahamas, Bahrain, Bermuda, the British Virgin Islands (BVI), the Cayman Islands, Guernsey, the Isle of Man, Jersey, the Marshall Islands, Turks and Caicos, the United Arab Emirates, and Vanuatu.
Most entities in these jurisdictions will be caught by the regulations, and have a low-level notification requirement. The more significant obligations arise if the entity is carrying on a ‘Relevant Activity’. The activities are fund management, banking, insurance, finance and leasing, distribution and service centre business, headquarters business, intellectual property business, shipping, and holding company business.
The implications within Switzerland and the UK are particularly important in relation to offshore trust and corporate structures. Trusts are not caught by the regulations, and our view is that Private Trust Companies (PTCs) would not be conducting a Relevant Activity. However, this does not mean that a PTC would not be affected by the legislation; the underlying companies within PTC structures are likely to be caught.
The economic substance laws went through a period of rapid development. As a result, it is very easy to be left behind as amendments are made, new guidance is released, and industry perspectives change. Some of the key issues include:
- The application of the Holding Company Business definition, and the differences in approach across the jurisdictions.
- How the legislation will apply in the long-term to investment funds in the different jurisdictions, in particular Cayman.
- What options are available to entities incorporated in these jurisdictions.
- Whether there will be more changes, how wide ranging these will be, and what the approach will be for entities relying on guidance that was published at the time of their reporting.
How can we help?
- Advising on the differences between the jurisdictions. Careful consideration of the comparisons between jurisdictions can help to establish a sustainable position in your jurisdiction.
- Helping clients to take a position on the benefits of incorporation in one jurisdiction as opposed to another. We are particularly well placed to advise on these cross jurisdictional issues, with our foreign reach and spread of international offices.
- Advising as to the classification of a company, providing an analysis and producing reports which apply the legislation to specific entities.
- Providing guidance on how a relevant entity can comply with the regulations, including advice on obligations and deadlines.
- Identifying practical solutions for relevant entities that need to comply with economic substance tests.
Piers Master named in eprivateclient’s 50 Most Influential 2022
We are delighted to announce that Piers Master, Head of Private Wealth, has been included in eprivateclient’s 50 Most Influential.
Environmental Land Management: Whose carbon is it anyway?
Everything you need to know about Environmental Land Management Schemes.
Philanthropy Insights – A discussion with John Pepin and Rennie Hoare of Philanthropy Impact
Join us as we discuss the current landscape of philanthropy in the UK and current trends, priorities and concerns amongst philanthropists.
Asian Legal Business, eprivateclient and Legal Monitor report on the firm's appointment of a new Family team in Hong Kong
The firm has added a new family team in Hong Kong, including the hire of Lisa Wong as Partner.
Charles Russell Speechlys welcomes new Family team in Hong Kong
We are delighted to welcome a new Family team in Hong Kong, including the hire of Lisa Wong as Partner.
Top 4 thoughts on Family Law in retrospect for 2021 and in prospect for 2022
“You have a reason to leave this place, but I don’t.” – Ji-Yeong, Squid Game
In Hong Kong, the law protects parents who find themselves in a similar situation to Gi-Hun in the Netflix popular series, Squid Game.
What artists need to know about law
What should artists consider when entering contracts, whether with galleries, museums or other parties?
Does Adultery Affect Divorce in Hong Kong?
In Hong Kong, divorce proceedings may proceed as long as the petitioner proves that their marriage has irretrievably broken down.
Stéphane de Lassus
Stéphane de Lassus interviewed by Le Figaro on the Paris office's ability to advise on both private and professional assets
Le Figaro featured an interview with Stéphane de Lassus titled “The entrepreneur for DNA” in a special wealth management edition.
eprivateclient and Circle2Success report on Felicity Chapman’s relocation to the Cheltenham office to expand the firm’s Family law offering
Felicity Chapman has relocated to the firm's Cheltenham office to deal with increased client demand.
The digital marketplace - an art law briefing
Has the digital art market grown up in the past 18 months?
Ingrid Saffin writes for eprivateclient on private capital, responsible business, and investing in the high street
The end of the moratorium could bring new gaps in retail space. But could this ultimately be good news?
What lessons can we take from the Britney Spears conservatorship case?
Rethinking Museum Governance
What are the legal responsibilities of museum trustees?
Family offices lead the way in engaging new generations
Charles Russell Speechlys advises FairXchange on investment from United Fintech
FairXchange was founded in 2016, to bring clarity and transparency to execution performance through the provision of independent data.
Sarah Jane Boon
Sarah Jane Boon writes for the Financial Times' Your Questions on whether financial claims can be pursued after an ex-spouse's death
Can financial claims be pursued after the death of an ex-spouse?