Recent case highlights the importance of correctly declaring dividends
A recent case, Re BM Electrical Solutions Ltd, has found a director-shareholder liable to repay sums which were held to be director loans despite having been recorded as dividends in the company’s accounting software package.
For tax saving reasons, the director-shareholder had agreed to a very low salary (net £11,702) on the basis that he could claim other monies as dividends.
After falling into financial difficulty, the company was wound up on 3 August 2015. Upon his appointment, the liquidator identified that transfers of approximately £220,000 had been made to the director-shareholder over a three and a half year period. The liquidator accepted that credit should be given to the director for his salary but claimed that the balance should be treated as loans from the company to the director, which should be repaid.
At trial, the director stated that a small proportion of the sums paid to him were his salary, whilst the rest of the payments were entered onto the accounting software package under a code for ‘dividends’. This was claimed to be a tax efficiency measure.
However, after the first year of trading, the director did not cause any further accounts to be prepared, meaning that the company only ever filed one set of accounts (for the period to 31 January 2012, filed on 11 August 2012).
Judge Lance Ashworth QC held that the sums paid to the director-shareholder were to be treated as director loans made with the expectation that there would be sufficient profits each year to pay them off. The reasons for this were two-fold.
For a dividend to become payable, it must be declared. As the director could not show that he had made such a declaration, he could not argue that the payments received should be treated as dividends.
Notwithstanding the above, a declaration (and subsequent payment) of dividends must be conducted in accordance with Part 23 of the Companies Act 2006. Under Part 23, a company may only pay dividends out of profits available for the purpose and those profits are to be determined by reference to profits, losses, assets and liabilities ‘as stated in the relevant accounts’ (s830 and s836). Those relevant accounts are the last annual accounts or interim accounts if the distribution would otherwise contravene Part 23. Given that no accounts had been drawn up since 2012, even if the payments were considered to be distributions, they would still be considered unlawful as the formalities in Part 23 CA 2006 had not been compiled with.
Accordingly, the director was required to repay the sums to the company (s847 CA 2006).
This case highlights the importance of correctly declaring shareholder dividends. Directors should ensure that dividends are formally and correctly declared in accordance with Part 23, otherwise there will be no liability on the company to pay it.
The judgement also provides a reminder of the risk to director-shareholders who agree to accept a nominal salary on the basis of being able to draw further funds as dividends.
The clarity given by this judgment will be welcomed by officeholders seeking to recover purported dividend payments made to director-shareholders in excess of their salary.
Case Study: One Blackfriars Limited
An informative and positive judgment for administrators selling high-value property in distressed and complex scenarios.
Warranties on an indemnity basis: a question of damages
John and Simon take an in-depth look at warranties on an indemnity basis
Property Patter: The trendy option – FAQs on tenant CVAs
Listen in for the answers to FAQs on tenant Company Voluntary Arrangements
Disclosure and documents referenced in expert reports: a level playing field?
Sonia looks at the impact of the recent High Court decision in Zverev v Ace Group International Ltd
Property Patter: The “bubble wrap” option – FAQs on tenant administration
The team look at some key points on tenant administration.
Court clarifies the meaning of “value” within the context of s284 Insolvency Act 1986
Roger and Jess explore the meaning of “value” within the context of s284 of the Insolvency Act 1986 following recent clarification.
Dimitri A. Sonier
Charles Russell Speechlys successfully advises Europlasma on its restructuring plan
Paris restructuring and insolvency team help their client reduce net debt by 95%.
Durra Al Ali
“Subject to contract” wording in settlement negotiations: a label that sticks
Durra looks at the term “subject to contract” and how it was put to the test in Joanne Properties Ltd v Moneything Capital Ltd and another.
Patrick Gearon FCIArb
Patrick Gearon and Roger Elford write for Global Restructuring Review on the latest restructuring developments in the Gulf region
Dimitri A. Sonier
The French Government extends exceptional insolvency measures related to the COVID-19 crisis up to the 31st December 2021
Many of the measures of the French Ordinance No. 2020-596 were due to expire on 31 December 2020.
James Riby and Melania Constable write for Lexis PSL on insolvency and divorce in the time of coronavirus
Construction & Insolvency webinar
Our webinar gives insight into how Covid impacts termination of contracts and insolvency of a member of the supply chain.
Corporate Governance and Insolvency Act 2020
Aid provided under the Act to companies holding shareholder meetings during the pandemic was extended to 30 December 2020, but what next?
Public Company Update - November 2020
The November 2020 edition of our biannual Public Company Update.
Privilege and Fraud – when can the iniquity exception override legal professional privilege?
Jason and Heidi look at when the can iniquity exception override legal professional privilege
Adjudicating Construction Disputes and Enforcement – Practical Tips for Insolvency Practitioners
Jason looks at adjudicating construction disputes and enforcement and offers practical tips for Insolvency Practitioners
Dimitri A. Sonier
Global Restructuring Review, Décideurs Magazine, Le Monde du Droit and La Lettre des Jursites d'Affaires cover the hire of Dimitri Sonier in our Paris office
Dimitri A. Sonier
Charles Russell Speechlys expands Paris offering with hire of restructuring and insolvency specialist
Dimitri Sonier joins the Paris office with immediate effect.
Nic Couchman and Roger Elford quoted by Sport Business on building a bridge to a sustainable future for the English Football League
Safeguarding search orders and the role of public interest: lessons to be learned from recent case law
Caroline looks at lessons to be learned from the recent decision in Calor Gas Ltd v Chorley Bottle Gas Ltd and others