Phillips’ patent for GPS enabled fitness tracker loses its way
Garmin has succeeded in largely revoking Phillips’ UK patent in relation to a GPS enabled athletic performance-monitoring device. The decision significantly reduces Garmin’s potential liability for infringing the patent and may help clear the way for others.
In October 2017, Garmin brought a claim in the High Court of England and Wales to invalidate Phillips’ patent for a GPS-based performance monitor. Phillips brought a counter-claim, alleging that 73 of Garmin’s products sold in the UK infringed the claims of the patent. The High Court handed down its decision at the end of January.
Over the past decade, wearable performance monitoring devices, including those that utilise GPS (either directly or via a smartphone) have become a commonplace sight, expanding rapidly from a fairly niche market of professional and amateur athletes. Phillips’ patent was granted, however, back in 1998. It claimed a device featuring a GPS receiver for acquiring position data of an athlete, and means for converting that data into athletic feedback data and presenting it to the athlete. It also claimed various types of product that developed on this key concept – such as a device also having an integrated audio entertainment system and a system for uploading data from the device to a website to allow for the comparison of the performance of different athletes.
Phillips originally argued that its invention was transformative in the field of technology. Undeterred, Garmin was able to point to a number of articles that pre-dated the patent and raised the possibility of using GPS in conjunction with devices for monitoring physical activity. In particular, Garmin referred to an article by Schutz and Chambaz entitled “Could a satellite-based navigation system (GPS) be used to assess the physical activity of individuals on earth?”, which was published in 1997. From this basis, Garmin argued that the inventions claimed in the patent were not new or would have been obvious to people working in the field of wearable technology in 1998.
The Judge largely agreed with Garmin. Although he considered that the “concept may be said to have given rise to a new industry”, he held that most of the claims of the patent related to ideas that were either not new or were obvious at the time the application was filed for the patent. The only claim of the patent that survived was for a GPS enabled device that features an integrated audio entertainment system for listening to music, where the volume of the music is reduced when data concerning performance is presented audibly to the athlete.
This is a feature found in a number of modern fitness trackers, which may still have infringed the patent (unless their manufacturers obtained a licence from Phillips). However, only a small number of the 73 Garmin products concerned were thought to fall within the surviving claim, so Garmin will have substantially reduced its potential liability to Phillips for infringement of the patent.
The judgment also potentially reduces the risk for other manufacturers’ in the field. Phillips’ UK patent expired in 2018, but it could still bring claims for infringement in relation to products sold in the UK prior to that date. Its ability to do so has now been significantly restricted.
The case has established that the core concept of a device featuring a GPS receiver to monitor physical performance is now in the public domain in the UK. However, future innovations in the technology will be capable of protection and, given the value of the market, it would be no surprise if more patent litigation followed.
For more information please contact David Fyfield on +44 (0)20 7203 5200 or at email@example.com.
Phone hacking: Charles Russell Speechlys achieves settlement for celebrity clients from Mirror Group Newspapers
Charles Russell Speechlys can today confirm the settlement of privacy claims for unlawful voicemail interception on behalf of six clients.
Leasehold Reform – The devil is in the detail
Taking a closer look at the Government's announcement in January that makes home purchase easier and cheaper for leaseholders.
Further extension to ban on residential evictions
There has been a further extension of the ban on enforcement of possession orders at residential dwellings in England until 31 March 2021 .
Grand designs – Who should take the design risk in an MMC project?
MMC have been touted as a way to tackle costs and inefficiencies within construction, but who takes responsibility for the design ?
Tech Connect Newsletter - February 2021
Welcome to the February edition of our Tech Connect Newsletter.
EMI share options, Covid-19, and Brexit – where are we now?
What are the new measures to employers operating EMI schemes that have been affected by the pandemic?
If you have nothing to hide you have nothing to fear: Why the Government is afraid of Judicial Review
Damages-based agreements: A positive step by the Court of Appeal
Spring Budget 2021 - predictions
Spring budget 2021 - what will the Chancellor do?
Noel Wardle quoted by Chemist and Druggist on the issues that need to be considered before pharmacies adopt a hub-and-spoke dispensing model
Under current legislation, the hub-and-spoke model can be carried out by pharmacies owned by the same legal entity.
Charles Russell Speechlys advises Exeter Property Group on its acquisition of two property SPVs from the Tritax group
Exeter Property Group is one of the largest real estate investment managers focused on acquiring, developing and managing properties.
A Cautionary Tale of a Brush Too Broad
Enforcing judgments in England and Switzerland post-Brexit
For the first time, there is no framework for the enforcement of Swiss judgments in the United Kingdom and vice versa.
Charles Russell Speechlys releases H2 2020 deal highlights
Our highlights over the past 6 months are now available.
Charles Russell Speechlys advises the founders of The People Development Team (PDT Global) on sale to LTG plc
The People Development Team is a leading provider of online diversity and inclusion training and consultancy services.
Building anxieties: The impact of a possible CGT rate rise on housebuilders
As the March 2021 budget approaches and a potential CGT rate rise, what does it mean for housebuilders?
Keeping Up With Construction: Pre-procurement - Practical Pointers
Successful procurement is more than the choice of the construction contract.
Property Patter: The “bubble wrap” option – FAQs on tenant administration
The team look at some key points on tenant administration.
Charles Russell Speechlys advises N+1 Singer on £10m return of capital
Zytronic plc is a UK-based manufacturer and developer of touch sensing overlay products.
Post-Brexit Implications for UK/EU Business Travel
How companies need to monitor the activities of their employees on business trips in a post-Brexit world.