Schweppes’ trade mark mixer: ECJ rules on trade mark exhaustion where ownership of the Schweppes mark was split between different countries
In Red Paralela and another v Orangina Schweppes Holding BV and others (Case C-291/16), 20 December 2017, the European Court of Justice has ruled that Schweppes cannot prevent the importation into Spain of Coca-Cola-manufactured Schweppes tonic from the UK.
Back in 1999, Cadbury Schweppes sold part of its portfolio of "Schweppes" marks in 13 European countries (including in the UK) to The Coca-Cola Company (Coca-Cola). It held on to its rights in Spain via its Spanish subsidiary, Schweppes SA. Then in 2014, Schweppes SA brought infringement proceedings against Red Paralela to try to prevent Red Paralela from importing bottles of Schweppes tonic water from the UK into Spain for sale. The tonic water had first been put on the market in the UK by Coca-Cola.
Red Paralela argued that Schweppes had consented to the importation and marketing because of its legal and economic links with Coca-Cola in the course of their common exploitation of the sign "Schweppes" as a global mark, whereas Schweppes claimed to have no connection with Coca-Cola.
The Spanish court stayed the proceedings and referred four questions to the ECJ relating to exhaustion of rights in the context of close commercial relationships such the one that existed between Coca-Cola and Schweppes. The questions focused around whether the owner of a trade mark provides consent to an assignee of a mark marketing goods bearing that mark in a territory in which rights in the mark are retained.
The ECJ found that by assigning part of a trade mark portfolio in respect of certain territories only, this can lead to exhaustion issues if the assignor and assignee agree to continue to promote the appearance of a single brand. The ECJ ruled that a proprietor cannot enforce its trade mark rights if, following the assignment, it has:
(i) actively and deliberately (acting alone or with the assignee) continued to promote the appearance of a single global trade mark (creating or exacerbating public confusion about commercial origin); or alternatively
(ii) continued to have economic links with the assignee which make it possible for the proprietor to determine both the goods to which the mark is affixed and the quality of those goods.
Previous case law had established that a proprietor’s consent includes situations in which the trademarks are held by ‘economically linked’ entities (IHT Internationale Heiztechnik). This shows that the ECJ has developed the principle of exhaustion from branded products whose trade marks are held by ‘economically linked’ entities to simply where entities have actively and deliberately continued to promote the appearance of a single global trade mark. This arguably could be seen as further erosion of international trade mark rights.
This article was written by Christina Fleming . For more information please contact on +44 (0)20 7427 1022 or at christina.fleming@crsblaw.com.
Our thinking
Pei Li Kew
Pei Li Kew writes for Pharmacy Business on the link between pharmacy and IP
Pei Li Kew writes for Pharmacy Business on the link between pharmacy and IP
Charlotte Duly
Charlotte Duly writes for CITMA Review on the China Tang trade mark infringement case
Charlotte Duly writes for CITMA Review on the China Tang trade mark infringement case
Jonathan McDonald
Jonathan McDonald provides comment for City AM on the Data Reform Bill announced in the Queen's Speech
Jonathan McDonald provides comment for City AM on the Data Reform Bill announced in the Queen's Speech
Nick White
Charles Russell Speechlys advises Symphony Holdings Limited on the sale of its PONY trade mark portfolio for USD $28 million
Charles Russell Speechlys advises Symphony Holdings Limited on the sale of its PONY trade mark portfolio for USD $28 million.
Hope Wilson
Hope Wilson writes for the EG Legal Q&A on qualifying criteria
Hope Wilson writes for the EG Legal Q&A on qualifying criteria
Simon Ridpath
Simon Ridpath featured in the Lawyer’s Hot 100 list
Simon Ridpath features in The Lawyer’s Hot 100 list
Natalie Batra
Patents and Peppa Pig: What is happening to intellectual property rights in Russia?
Certain Russian individuals and businesses can now use patents, utility models and industrial designs without obtaining prior permission.
Simon Green
International Bar Association quotes Simon Green on the future of the legal sector in Hong Kong
International Bar Association quote Simon Green on the future of Hong Kong's legal sector
Charlotte Duly
Charlotte Duly quoted in Retail Gazette on House of Zana trademark dispute
Charlotte Duly quoted in Retail Gazette on House of Zana trademark dispute
Durra Al Ali
Durra Al Ali and Simon Heatley write about disclosure duties for Thomson Reuters Practical Law
Disclosure duties for clients and their lawyers
Lesley O’Leary
Briefing publishes Lesley O’Leary 's comments on hybrid working and the impact on collaboration
Briefing publishes Lesley O’Leary 's comments on hybrid working and the impact on collaboration
Mark Hill
Mark Hill quoted in The Times on the Ed Sheeran High Court copyright case win
Mark Hill quoted in The Times on the Ed Sheeran High Court copyright case win
Caroline Greenwell
Nowhere to hide for greenwashing brands
In the UK, regulators are cracking down, with many companies now at risk of financial and other penalties.
Jamie Cartwright
Weighing up the Plastic Packaging Tax
The Plastic Packaging Tax came into force on 1 April 2022.
Jamie Cartwright
Crunching numbers - Mandatory calorie laws come into force
The Calorie Labelling (Out of Home Sector) (England) Regulations 2021 (the Regulations) are now in force.
Mark Hill
Mark Hill quoted in the Daily Mail discussing Ed Sheeran’s copyright court case win
Mark Hill quoted in the Daily Mail discussing Ed Sheeran’s copyright court case win
Jamie Cartwright
Jamie Cartwright comments on the potential impact of the plastic packaging tax
Jamie Cartwright comments on the potential impact of the plastic packaging tax
Jody MacDonald
Liverpool FC’s Hero Club and the current state of play with football NFTs
Liverpool’s Hero Club hit the headlines this week and serves as an interesting reflection of the current state of play.
Rachel Bell
Rachel Bell commented in IT Pro on the implications of the proposed EU’s Digital Markets Act
The proposed EU’s Digital Markets Act is set to require larger messaging platforms to interoperate with their smaller rivals.
Clare Davis
National Minimum Wage – At risk of committing a criminal offence?
To best prepare, you need to understand the nature of the risks involved and take steps to minimise them.