FCA’s Dear CEO letter to Wealth Managers – Focus on Best Execution
At the start of the summer, the FCA wrote to wealth managers (on 13 June) by way of a Dear CEO letter The letter highlighted the key risks that wealth management and stockbroking firms pose to their customers or the markets in which they operate. The FCA is asking firms to consider whether they present these risks and, if so, for them to consider ways to mitigate these. The letter forms part of a 2-year strategy (which began in April this year) - after which time, the FCA will write to firms with their updated view of the key sector risks and their updated supervisory focus. (https://www.fca.org.uk/publication/correspondence/portfolio-letter-wealth-managers-stockbrokers.pdf).
Key types of harm posed by wealth managers
- Clients having reduced levels of savings and investments due to fraud, investment scams and inadequate client money or asset controls
- Clients losing confidence in the industry’s ability to deliver their financial objectives due to mismanagement of conflicts of interest and market abuse
- Reduced levels of savings and investments due to order handling procedures and execution processes that do not deliver best outcomes
- Clients being unable to understand the costs of services provided by firms due to insufficient or inaccurate disclosure of costs and charges
Best execution concerns
As a reminder, under COBS 11.2 firms must take all sufficient steps to obtain the best possible result for its clients when executing client orders or passing them to other firms for execution.
The FCA’s Investment Platforms Market Study (published in March this year) highlighted specific issues and weaknesses in order handling procedures and best execution evaluations. The FCA were particularly concerned with the Retail Service Provider (RSP) trade execution system – through which only 80% of orders were found to receive a price at least as good as the best available – although the best execution requirement depends on a variety of execution factors (including price, costs, speed, likelihood of execution), the FCA’s primary concern is value for money for clients.
Requirements for wealth managers
The FCA has stated that firms are expected to have:
- Effective day to day execution processes;
- Contingent arrangements for periods of market distress; and
- Clear comprehensive and effective oversight and monitoring arrangements.
Firms need to consider their best execution arrangements (particularly if they rely on a single RSP or market maker) and have systems in place in times of market distress so that if their RSP system is unavailable, they have an alternative. Firms should have more than one means of executing or transmitting orders – for example, being able to move from electronic to voice broking when necessary may be appropriate for certain types of instrument.
The requirement to meet the level of having taken “all sufficient steps” to obtain the best possible result for clients requires, in the FCA’s view, robust monitoring.
As such, firms should consider who is monitoring whether best execution is being achieved – if it is a third party system – are they using adequate sample sizes? And how wide are their tolerances to price variation?
The FCA has warned that it may consider supervision work in this area.
Therefore, asset managers should be reviewing their best execution procedures and scrutinising their list of brokers on an annual basis. Have they always achieved the best price? If not, was there a reason for this – i.e. was another execution factor given more weight and was this decision justified? Have there been issues with filling orders? Monitoring should also be undertaken on an ongoing basis. If the firm has concerns with a particular broker, it should seriously consider changing brokers.
All monitoring should of course be recorded to demonstrate good governance.
Best execution has been a requirement on firms for many years but clearly the FCA is concerned that firms are still not managing to achieve best execution for their clients on a consistent basis. Firms should review their procedures in light of the letter and implement any changes necessary to put them in a good position should the FCA decide supervisory action is indeed required.
If you have any questions on the FCA’s Dear CEO letter and its implications for asset managers and their best execution requirements please contact Vanessa Walters in our Financial Services Regulatory Team on +44 (0)20 7427 6706 or vanessa.walters@crsblaw.com.
Our thinking
Sarah Rowley
Charity Training series: Session 2
Join us for the second session in our Charity Training series where we will cover training for Charity Trustees and Senior Executives.
Sarah Rowley
Charity Training series: Session 1
Join us for the first session in our Charity Training series where we will discuss ESG for Charities.
Charlotte Posnansky
VV v VV - Just 5 months of marriage and the most expensive train ticket ever?
Mark Howard
Charles Russell Speechlys advises Content+Cloud on the acquisition of award-winning service provider Azzure IT
Content+Cloud continues its growth journey, this is our 7th successful transaction for them.
Dominic Lawrance
Dominic Lawrance talks to Spear's Magazine about UK cryptocurrency tax
What HNWs should know about UK cryptocurrency tax
Sarah Keens
Being Green - The Struggle for Power
Everything you need to know about Green Leases
Rose Carey
Is the UK open for business? A discussion with the Home Office
We hosted an immigration webinar with the policymakers from the Home Office.
Louise Ward
Louise Ward writes for EG on what UK investors can gain from an overseas life sciences partner
What UK investors can gain from an overseas life sciences partner
Sonia Kenawy
Sonia Kenawy writes for New Law Journal on cryptocurrency and security for costs
Sonia Kenawy writes for New Law Journal on cryptocurrency and security for costs
David Haines
New Arbitration Scheme for Commercial Arrears goes live
Everything you need to know about the new Arbitration Scheme for Commercial Arrears
Pei Li Kew
Pei Li Kew writes for Pharmacy Business on the link between pharmacy and IP
Pei Li Kew writes for Pharmacy Business on the link between pharmacy and IP
Charlotte Duly
Charlotte Duly writes for CITMA Review on the China Tang trade mark infringement case
Charlotte Duly writes for CITMA Review on the China Tang trade mark infringement case
Mark Howard
Charles Russell Speechlys advises Acora on its acquisition of Secrutiny
Charles Russell Speechlys advises Acora on its acquisition of Secrutiny
Oliver Park
Building Safety Act 2022
Everything you need to know about the Building Safety Act 2022
Jonathan McDonald
Jonathan McDonald provides comment for City AM on the Data Reform Bill announced in the Queen's Speech
Jonathan McDonald provides comment for City AM on the Data Reform Bill announced in the Queen's Speech
Claire Fallows
CoStar quotes Claire Fallows on the new infrastructure levy announced in the Queen's Speech
CoStar quotes Claire Fallows on the new infrastructure levy announced in the Queen's Speech
Charlotte Posnansky
Depp v Heard - will transparency in the English family court increase public confidence or feed the insatiably prurient public appetite?
Nick White
Charles Russell Speechlys advises Symphony Holdings Limited on the sale of its PONY trade mark portfolio for USD $28 million
Charles Russell Speechlys advises Symphony Holdings Limited on the sale of its PONY trade mark portfolio for USD $28 million.
Hope Wilson
Hope Wilson writes for the EG Legal Q&A on qualifying criteria
Hope Wilson writes for the EG Legal Q&A on qualifying criteria
Simon Ridpath
Simon Ridpath featured in the Lawyer’s Hot 100 list
Simon Ridpath features in The Lawyer’s Hot 100 list