Gender critical belief – finding of discrimination
Last year, the Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT) found in the case of Forstater v CGD that “gender critical” beliefs are capable of protection under the Equality Act 2010. The EAT was only deciding on that aspect of the case, not on the merits of the claim. The question that followed this finding was how courts would, in practice, protect these rights whilst not infringing the rights of others in what is a very emotive area. We now have an indication of the approach the courts will take as the Forstater case returned to the Employment Tribunal (ET) earlier this year for a hearing on the merits and the decision was handed down this week. Additionally, the EAT handed down a judgement recently in a case dealing with similar beliefs, and we look at the contrasting outcomes.
Maya Forstater did not have her contract renewed at the think tank centre for Global Development in 2019 after she had posted a series of tweets which demonstrated that she believed sex to be immutable and should not be conflated with gender identity. She believes that trans women are transwomen, not women. The ET considered whether the tweets were a manifestation of her belief to which objection could reasonably be taken or an inappropriate manner of manifesting her belief. Having considered several of her tweets, they found they were not objectively unreasonable. The ET, therefore, found she had been discriminated against because of her beliefs in that she had not had her Visiting Fellowship renewed, nor been offered an employment contract.
In Mackereth v DWP, Mr Mackereth, a Christian doctor, asserted a biblical belief that people are created either male or female and cannot change their sex/gender at will. He also asserted a lack of belief in transgenderism. His role with the DWP was as a disabilities assessor of benefits claimants. As part of the induction process, he was told that he should use the preferred pronouns of transgender service users. He said he would not and resigned. His discrimination claims were dismissed by both the ET and EAT on the basis that whilst he was disadvantaged by having to use preferred pronouns because of his beliefs, this was a necessary and proportionate way of the DWP achieving its’ legitimate aims which were to ensure transgender service users are treated with respect and to provide a service that promotes equal opportunities.
What these cases demonstrate is that in a pluralist democratic society the protection of both minority and majority beliefs is important, even where some of those views may offend others. How individuals manifest those beliefs will be key in determining disputes going forward.
TL4 Fire Starters
Join us for a Festive FIRE Starters evening ahead of FIRE Starters Global Summit with our expert panellists.
Women in Chancery Christmas Celebration
Join us to celebrate the festive season and discuss the busy year we have had.
The Metro quotes Paul Stone on Elon Musk's feud with Apple over Twitter advertising
Musk feuds with Apple over Twitter advertising
Disclosing Third-Party Funding in International Arbitration: Where Are We Now?
What is third-party funding and what further developments can we expect in this fast-moving area?
Rose Carey quoted in The Evening Standard on visitor visa applications
“Family visas are currently taking up to six months to process and with no priority service available...”
Charles Russell Speechlys advises Guildford Games Developer Community on the launch of Guildford.Games Ltd
Charles Russell Speechlys has advised the Guildford.Games committee, a not-for-profit initiative, on the formation of Guildford.Games Ltd
Alexia Egger Castillo
Inheritance contracts: An unknown planning tool for Brits with assets in Switzerland?
How you choose to dispose of your estate after death requires careful consideration, especially where assets are in multiple jurisdictions
FT Ignites Europe quotes William Garner on the FCA's approach to founder-led firms
"Taking a very strict line on founder-led firms risks undermining the FCA's competition mandate..."
HR Magazine quotes Nick Hurley on redundancy and employee rights
"Unfortunately the legal remedies for employees in companies that become insolvent are very limited"
Unknown future claims cannot be settled
The EAT has confirmed that provisions in the Equality Act 2010 mean that unknown future claims cannot be compromised.
Construction News quotes David Savage on the slight rise in construction output in September
"It remains to be seen how the sector reacted in October amid the political turmoil"
How final is a Final Certificate?
A recent Scottish case grappled with the complexities of a smash and grab adjudication.
HR Magazine quotes Nick Hawkins on a pregnancy discrimination case and what companies need to be mindful of
Pregnant worker given parenting tips before sacking wins tribunal case
Court of Appeal decides defective notice to quit not saved by 'Mannai' principles
The Court of Appeal handed down judgment in the second appeal in O G Thomas Amaethyddiath v Turner & Ors  EWCA Civ 1446.
Charles Russell Speechlys wins Best Legal Services: Private Equity – Pan – Africa at the AGF Service Providers Awards 2022
Best Legal Services: Private Equity – Pan – Africa at the AGF Service Providers Awards 2022
“Truss me, I quit!” - 5 Tips to Handle Unexpected Resignations and Post-employment Grievances
Read our guidance for employers on dealing with unexpected and “heat of the moment” resignations
Sarah Jane Boon
The Independent quotes Sarah Jane Boon on the 9.6% divorce increase in 2021
ONS statistics - Divorces in England and Wales: 2021
JCT v NEC: Which contract is right for your project?
Unsure of what building contact to use. Learn the difference between NEC and JCT contracts with our guide.
Tristram van Lawick
Land Manager Collaboration for Environmental Delivery
Explore the different ways land managers can work together to engage with environmental markets.
South China Morning Post quotes Simon Green on Hong Kong investment into UK property
“With the increase in energy prices in 2022, this will be something for buyers and homeowners to consider.”