Tackling Recruitment & Potential Racial Discrimination under the UK’s new Post-Brexit Immigration System
From 1 January 2021 free movement ends and the UK’s new Immigration System will apply to EU and non-EU nationals alike. Ahead of this the new Skilled Worker route launched on 1 December 2020 although EU, EEA & Swiss nationals do not become eligible until the end of free movement on 1 January.
The Skilled Worker route replaces Tier 2 General and it is different to its predecessor in a number of keys ways, which are both welcome to employers, but also potentially problematical at the same time.
Importantly, the Resident Labour Market Test (RLMT) has been abolished and the minimum overall skill level for roles eligible for sponsorship has been reduced from broadly degree level (RQF Level 6) to broadly A Level (RQF Level 3), thereby vastly increasing the number of roles in the UK that are now eligible for sponsorship.
The removal of the RLMT
The RLMT required employers to advertise a role in a strictly prescribed manner for a minimum of 28 days and, crucially, employers had to be able to show that no suitably qualified settled worker (UK, & EU nationals and those with permanent residency) could be found to fill the role at the end of the process, before sponsorship was possible. With the removal of the RLMT no such requirement to justify sponsorship now exists.
What this means for UK employers & their recruitment practices
From an employment perspective, the basic principles haven’t changed: all employers need to ensure that those they recruit have the right to work in the UK. The ECHR Statutory Code of Practice makes clear that right to work checks should be carried out in the final stages of the recruitment process, not at the outset. This is because a policy of excluding those for whom a visa application would need to be made is potentially indirect discrimination under the Equality Act 2010 (the Act).
A consequence of the changes to the immigration system however is that lower skilled workers are now eligible for work visas, as far more roles are now available for sponsorship than in the past. This, combined with the abolition of the RLMT (which, as explained above, means that employers are no longer required to recruit from the settled workforce if a candidate is available) and the fact that EU, EEA & Swiss nationals seeking to come to the UK for the first time from 1 January to work will require a visa, could result in employers seeing many more applications from applicants who do not have the right to work in the UK than ever before and who will require sponsorship under the skilled worker visa route.
For those employers looking to target highly skilled workers from all over the world, this will now be easier to do. However, for employers who have sought not to incur visa costs, it is no longer an option to justify this approach on the basis that they are able (and previously required) to recruit a suitable candidate who has the right to work in the UK already, assuming one was available. Employers who have previously relied on the RLMT specifically not to recruit those who require a visa will need to adopt a different approach. Employers who typically recruit for roles not previously eligible for sponsorship may also now be forced to consider it. Finally, for existing employees requesting sponsorship on the basis they are in the UK under different visa category but that category is no longer tenable (for example if they are on a spousal visa but the relationship has broken down), or if they want to switch to the Skilled Worker route as it is a category that provides a route to permanent residence, in these instances, again, it will no longer be possible to refuse sponsorship on the basis that a suitable candidate from within the UK could be found to fill the role instead.
Cost of sponsorship
Under the Act indirect discrimination claims can be defended if the policy adopted is objectively justified. Case law has established that costs alone will not be enough to justify such a policy, so the high visa and sponsorship costs alone, which can run into thousands of pounds, will not be a sufficient excuse. For some businesses however, there may be justification in assessing an annual total employment cost tipping point for the business. If the reason for limiting recruitment where visa costs will be incurred is to ensure the viability of the business, this may be permissible. Unfortunately it will not be clear where that tipping point is for a business and how extreme the consequences will need to be. Case law is likely to dictate how this area of law develops in the future.
What should employers be doing?
Key steps to take under the new immigration system are:
- Ensure right to work checks are made at the end of the recruitment process, and that there is no blanket approach to rejecting applications from those who require visas.
- Consider the salary on offer for the role. The overall minimum salary threshold under the Skilled Worker route is £25,600 (with some exceptions) and the salary must also meet the salary requirements or the ‘going rate’ for the relevant role, as specified by the Immigration Rules, if higher. If the minimum salary requirements aren’t met, then employers will not be able to/ need to consider sponsorship for that role.
- For existing employees needing to be sponsored in order for their employment to be able to continue, consider if there are any other reasons to justify not sponsoring, such as poor performance.
This article was written by Emma Bartlett and Rose Carey. For more information, please contact Emma on +44 (0)20 7427 6450 or at emma.bartlett@crsblaw.com or Rose on +44 (0)20 7427 6524 or at rose.carey@crsblaw.com.
Our thinking
Carolyn Davies
New industry group aims to build sustainability skills in the construction sector
Hope Barton
Q&A: The qualifying criteria explained
What do landlords need to prove to satisfy ground (g) of section 30(1) of the 1954 Act for the purposes of a new tenancy?
Michael Lingens
Charles Russell Speechlys has advised the owners of The Centre for Reproductive and Genetic Health (CRGH) on its sale to FutureLife
CRGH is the largest private fertility clinic in the London IVF market.
Naomi Heathcote
Green leases crucial to achieving net zero in the built environment
‘Net zero’ requires emissions to be reduced as far as possible, and for the remaining (or ‘residual’) emissions to be removed or captured.
Samuel Lear
Samuel Lear answers the EG Legal Q&A on code rights
Q&A: Code rights queries answered
Charlotte Duly
Retail Bulletin quotes Charlotte Duly on the House of Zana trademark row with Zara
"In this battle of David and Goliath, the little guy has come out on top."
David Coates
Charles Russell Speechlys advises Puma Private Equity on its investment into MUSO
We have advised long-term client Puma Private Equity on its investment into MUSO TNT Limited.
Helen Coward
FT Ignites Europe quotes Helen Coward on portfolio manager bonuses
"HMRC has had asset managers in their spotlight for some time now"
Melania Constable
Melania Constable and Jessica Williams write for Pharmacy Business on what the collapse of Testerworld means for community pharmacies
What does the collapse of Testerworld mean for community pharmacies?
Mark Howard
IT Pro quotes Mark Howard on investment in UK tech start-ups
"The UK has the strongest venture and growth capital funding ecosystem in Europe.”
Christopher Hadnutt
Chris Hadnutt writes for Building Magazine on construction project defects
Chris Hadnutt writes for Building Magazine on construction project defects
Tristram van Lawick
The Sunday Times quotes Tristram van Lawick on investment into country estates
“For overseas buyers the security of the UK property market is seen as a safe investment compared with other parts of the world"
Nicola Saccardo
Charles Russell Speechlys welcomes Partner Nicola Saccardo to the Firm’s London office
Charles Russell Speechlys welcomes Partner Nicola Saccardo
Simon Ridpath
Charles Russell Speechlys announces 24% international revenue growth
Charles Russell Speechlys announces 24% international revenue growth
Michael Powner
Barrister with gender critical beliefs discriminated against by chambers
An employment tribunal has found that the barrister, Allison Bailey was discriminated against because of her gender critical beliefs.
Sarah Morley
The new UK register of overseas entities – the impact on property transactions
The Economic Crime Act establishes a new register of beneficial ownership of overseas entities, read the implications here.
Piers Master
Register of Overseas Entities: What are the deadlines for trust structures holding UK real estate?
The ROE is intended to launch on 1 August 2022 - read more about the deadlines trust structures holding UK real estate will be facing
Emma Preece
EG quotes Emma Preece on the Cine-UK and Cineworld Court of Appeal Covid rent arrears ruling
“This appeal was always going to be an uphill battle for the tenants.”
David Savage
Construction News quotes David Savage on a recent fire safety ruling and the implications of this
"Although clearly fact-specific as any case is, this is an interesting and important case..."
Sally Ashford
Changing an Enduring Power of Attorney
Learn what you need to know about changing an Enduring Power of Attorney to a Lasting Power of Attorney.