Furlough and administration – the cases of Carluccio’s and Debenhams
We take a look at two recent High Court decisions on the impact of the government’s Coronavirus Job Retention Scheme on companies in administration.
Carluccio’s – Administrators placing employees on furlough
The High Court in Re Carluccio's Ltd (in administration) held that the employment contracts of Carluccio’s employees had been validly varied when they agreed to the administrators’ proposal to furlough them under the government's Coronavirus Job Retention Scheme (the Scheme). Under the furlough agreement, they were to be paid at the rates under the Scheme and limited to what was recoverable.
The administrators applied to the Court as they were concerned that any monies would be paid to them (rather than directly to the employees) and would therefore constitute assets of the administration. The Court held that when the administrators made the claim under the Scheme, or made any payment under a varied contract, the effect was that they had “adopted” the contract of employment under insolvency law. The effect of this was to give the employees super-priority ahead of payment of the administrators’ fees and expenses, floating charge creditors and unsecured creditors. Therefore on receipt of the grant under the Scheme, payment could be made to the employees.
Although almost all the employees had agreed to be furloughed, there was a small group who had not replied to the administrator’s furlough proposal. The Court held that there had not been sufficient time for there to be consent by conduct in this particular case. If those employees did subsequently agree, they would be in the same position as those who had already agreed. However, the unvaried contracts of employees who did not reply would not be considered to be “adopted” with the result that the administrators did not need to dismiss them in order to avoid incurring super-priority liability in respect of them.
Debenhams – Employees placed on furlough before administration
The High Court in Re Debenhams Retail Ltd considered how the Scheme may be implemented by administrators where the company had furloughed employees before the start of the administration.
The directors of Debenhams had placed its employees on furlough on the basis that the Scheme would apply to them and that their wages or salary would be payable only to the extent reimbursable under the Scheme. The directors did not ask the employees to consent to the arrangements.
When administrators were subsequently appointed they were concerned that they would be deemed to have adopted the contracts of employment and that the super-priority accorded to the payments due to the employees would catch not only the amounts recoverable under the Scheme but also other amounts, such as additional wages or salary, sick pay and holiday pay. The administrators sought the express consent of employees to arrangements that capped their entitlement to wages or salary at the amount the company was able to claim from the Scheme and a large number of employees consented.
The administrator sought directions as to whether they could continue with the Scheme arrangements in relation to the employees without being deemed to have adopted the contracts of employment. In line with the Carluccio’s decision, the court held that the administrators would be deemed to adopt the contracts of employment when they made a claim under the Scheme or when they paid wages to furloughed employees. Although the decision exposes the administrators to priority liabilities, the fact that the vast majority of the employees consented to a cap on their entitlements had in fact largely mitigated the exposure before the case was heard. This shows the importance of the administrators taking action to try to limit exposure to what is recoverable under the Scheme.
For more infomration, please contact Emma Bartlett.
Our thinking
IBA Annual Conference
The IBA heads to Miami for its 2022 Annual Conference bringing together thousands hundreds of lawyers from around the world.
Martin Wright
Joint Venture Opportunities
Join our panel where we will discuss various topics including Joint Venture structuring and Partner procurement.
Sarah Anticoni
FT Wealth quotes Sarah Anticoni on forum shopping
"Being the first to file for divorce is not a foolproof way of securing an English hearing"
Louise Ward
What can UK investors interested in Life Sciences learn from their more experienced, including US, counterparts?
The recent tie-up between Canary Wharf and Kadans demonstrates the enthusiasm to access the lucrative UK life sciences market.
Helen Coward
Helen Coward writes for Tax Journal on the main purpose test for SDLT group relief
Mainly ignored? The main purpose test for SDLT group relief
Patricia Nathan-Amissah
The Ayes have it - Collateral Warranties can be a ‘Construction Contract’
The Court of Appeal handed down its judgment in the case of Abbey Healthcare (Mill Hill) Limited v Simply Construct (UK) LLP
Jonathan Morley
Charles Russell Speechlys advising Battery Ventures on the sale of SPT Labtech for £650 million.
Battery Ventures has raised over $9 billion to invest in software and services, enterprise infrastructure, and much more around the world.
Sarah Farrelly
Windrush Day 2022 – supporting access to justice
Charles Russell Speechlys is proud to continue supporting survivors of the Windrush scandal in their fight for justice.
Laura Bushaway
The Leasehold Reform (Ground Rent) Act 2022: Landlords and developers beware serious sanctions for non-compliance
The Leasehold Reform (Ground Rent) Act 2022 received Royal Assent on 8 February 2022 and will come into force on 30 June 2022.
David Coates
Charles Russell Speechlys has advised long-standing client Stonegate on a series A investment into Peckwater Brands
Stonegate is one of the largest pub companies in the UK with a rich portfolio that covers over 4,500 sites.
Sarah Farrelly
Pro bono support for major office premises move for charity in Stoke-on-Trent
Emmaus entities provide safe homes, community support and meaningful work to formerly homeless people across the UK.
Rachel Warren
Financier Worldwide quotes Rachel Warren on the UK’s Economic Crime Act
Evaluating the UK’s Economic Crime Act
Samuel Lear
Property Patter: Reasonable Endeavours
What does it mean to use ‘best’, ‘all’ or ‘reasonable’ endeavours?
Rose Carey
Could the UK’s Life Sciences Vision be restricted by its Immigration Policy?
We explore some of the visa options that may be open to businesses in the sector and their relative pros and cons.
Joshua Green
Joshua Green writes for Spear's Magazine on Wagatha Christie’s lessons for HNWs
Wagatha Christie’s lessons for HNWs
Stephanie Bonnello
Stephanie Bonnello writes for the Practical Law Dispute Resolution blog on witness evidence
When are witness summaries permitted instead of witness statements and when should material be struck out from a witness statement?
Emma Humphreys
Emma Humphreys and Paul McCarthy write for Property Week on the new landlord digital ID checks
Emma Humphreys and Paul McCarthy write for Property Week on new landlord digital ID checks
Carolyn Davies
Carolyn Davies and Oliver Park write for Property Week on the key property points in the Building Safety Act
The key property points in the Building Safety Act
Oliver Auld
Unexplained Wealth Orders & Trustees
Learn about Unexplained Wealth Orders, what they are, who can obtain them and the implications that exist for trustees.
Louise Paterson
Artnet quotes Louise Paterson on the Ivory Act
UK’s Ivory Act comes into force