Holiday pay: series of deductions and back-pay
A recent case from the Court of Appeal in Northern Ireland Chief Constable of the Police Service of Northern Ireland and Northern Ireland Policing Board v Agnew and ors has considered a number of issues in relation to holiday pay including the meaning of “series of deductions” and whether annual leave under the Directive should be taken first. The case concerned an acknowledged failure to pay appropriate amounts of holiday pay, having paid basic pay rather than normal pay to include allowances and overtime, dating back to 23 November 1998 (when the Working Time Directive was implemented by the UK) or the start of employment if later.
The Court held that whether there is a series is a question of fact to be decided in each case. A “series” does not mean that each deduction occurs at exactly the same time interval and that provided it happens with sufficient frequency of repetition it can occur at different time intervals and for different amounts. The Court considered it was necessary to identify the alleged series and in this case it was a series of unlawful deductions in relation to holiday pay. Each unlawful deduction was factually linked to its predecessor by the common fault or unifying vice that holiday pay was calculated by reference to basic pay rather than normal pay. That factually linked all payments of holiday pay consistently since 23 November 1998.
The Court held that a series is not ended, as a matter of law, by a gap of more than 3 months between unlawful deductions or by a lawful payment i.e. where the claimants were paid appropriately while at work between the various holiday payments.
The Court also looked at whether annual leave should be taken in any particular sequence as suggested in Bear Scotland i.e. with the four weeks under the Directive to be taken first with the intention of increasing the chance of a gap of more than three months between the underpayments of holiday pay and a breach of a series. It disagreed with this reasoning and did not consider there was any requirement that leave from different sources is taken in a particular order.
Although this decision is not binding on the tribunals in Great Britain, it will be persuasive authority for any future appeal against the reasoning in the EAT’s decision in Bear Scotland. More concerning, is that if there is an appeal to the Supreme Court, which seems likely given the amounts involved, any decision will be binding on employers in Great Britain.
In Great Britain in July 2015 the government introduced a 2 year cap on backdated claims for unpaid holiday pay significantly limiting an employer’s liability. Northern Ireland did not introduce similar legislation and therefore the potential liability for backdated pay is much greater. The current estimate of the claims for the 3,700 police officers and civilian staff is £40million.
For more information, please contact Nick Hurley.
Our thinking
Is the UK open for business? A discussion with the Home Office
Join our Immigration team for a live webinar with policymakers from the Home Office.
Rose Carey
Relocating to the UK – Post Tier 1 (Investor)
The UK government closed the Tier 1 Investor visa route with immediate effect on 17 February 2022.
Lesley O’Leary
Briefing publishes Lesley O’Leary 's comments on hybrid working and the impact on collaboration
Briefing publishes Lesley O’Leary 's comments on hybrid working and the impact on collaboration
Emily Chalkley
How to tackle a large Gender Pay Gap
Nick Hawkins
Nick Hawkins writes for Employment Law Journal on demystifying employment contracts
Nick Hawkins explains the key legal principles that govern contracts of employment.
Michael Powner
Michael Powner and Emily Chalkley write for People Management on who pays the price for vicarious liability
Michael Powner and Emily Chalkley explain whether an employer should ever be liable for wrongdoing committed by their employees.
Katherine Dennis
New Global Mobility visa route – coming Spring 2022
A new Global Business Mobility visa route is launching in the Spring of 2022.
Clare Davis
National Minimum Wage – At risk of committing a criminal offence?
To best prepare, you need to understand the nature of the risks involved and take steps to minimise them.
Rose Carey
Summary of corporate immigration changes 2022
The Home Office has announced a raft of business immigration changes which will affect employers and workers alike.
Becky Lawton
New family-friendly rights – but will they be implemented in 2022?
The government has committed to introducing several new family rights following a number of consultations over the last couple of years.
Becky Lawton
The talent gap, recruitment and retention issues
Employers continue to struggle attracting and retaining talent in a market rife with labour shortages and widely-reported pay pressures.
Paul McCarthy
New Employer and Landlord Digital ID Checks – A Good IDea?
Becky Lawton
Becky Lawton writes for Employee Benefits on whether new staff family rights come into force in 2022
The government has committed to introducing several new family rights following a number of consultations over the last couple of years.
Nick Hurley
Nick Hurley appears on the Oven-Ready HR Podcast to discuss the latest developments in the world of employment law
Nick discusses the 2022 employment law landscape on the Oven-Ready HR podcast.
Mark Hill
UAE Labour Law Update – The five big changes to note…
Federal Decree Law No. 33 of 2021 - The five big changes to note
Rose Carey
The UK's Immigration System Opens Up to Overseas Care Workers
Employers will be able to sponsor care workers and home carers under the Skilled Worker (Health and Care visa) category.
Becky Lawton
Dismissal for refusing vaccination found to be fair
An employment tribunal found that the summary dismissal of a care assistant who refused to be vaccinated, was fair.
Sam Lawn
Out of Office – 5 tips for employers considering a more flexible approach to where we work
Briony Richards
AI and HR - How can employers reduce the risks associated with using artificial intelligence to help manage their workforce?
Nick Hurley
Nick Hurley quoted by People Management on whether employers can reduce sick pay for unvaccinated staff
Nick comments on the legal risks for companies opting not to provide company sick pay to isolating unjabbed workers.