Holiday pay: series of deductions and back-pay
A recent case from the Court of Appeal in Northern Ireland Chief Constable of the Police Service of Northern Ireland and Northern Ireland Policing Board v Agnew and ors has considered a number of issues in relation to holiday pay including the meaning of “series of deductions” and whether annual leave under the Directive should be taken first. The case concerned an acknowledged failure to pay appropriate amounts of holiday pay, having paid basic pay rather than normal pay to include allowances and overtime, dating back to 23 November 1998 (when the Working Time Directive was implemented by the UK) or the start of employment if later.
The Court held that whether there is a series is a question of fact to be decided in each case. A “series” does not mean that each deduction occurs at exactly the same time interval and that provided it happens with sufficient frequency of repetition it can occur at different time intervals and for different amounts. The Court considered it was necessary to identify the alleged series and in this case it was a series of unlawful deductions in relation to holiday pay. Each unlawful deduction was factually linked to its predecessor by the common fault or unifying vice that holiday pay was calculated by reference to basic pay rather than normal pay. That factually linked all payments of holiday pay consistently since 23 November 1998.
The Court held that a series is not ended, as a matter of law, by a gap of more than 3 months between unlawful deductions or by a lawful payment i.e. where the claimants were paid appropriately while at work between the various holiday payments.
The Court also looked at whether annual leave should be taken in any particular sequence as suggested in Bear Scotland i.e. with the four weeks under the Directive to be taken first with the intention of increasing the chance of a gap of more than three months between the underpayments of holiday pay and a breach of a series. It disagreed with this reasoning and did not consider there was any requirement that leave from different sources is taken in a particular order.
Although this decision is not binding on the tribunals in Great Britain, it will be persuasive authority for any future appeal against the reasoning in the EAT’s decision in Bear Scotland. More concerning, is that if there is an appeal to the Supreme Court, which seems likely given the amounts involved, any decision will be binding on employers in Great Britain.
In Great Britain in July 2015 the government introduced a 2 year cap on backdated claims for unpaid holiday pay significantly limiting an employer’s liability. Northern Ireland did not introduce similar legislation and therefore the potential liability for backdated pay is much greater. The current estimate of the claims for the 3,700 police officers and civilian staff is £40million.
For more information, please contact Nick Hurley.
IBA Annual Conference
The IBA heads to Miami for its 2022 Annual Conference bringing together thousands hundreds of lawyers from around the world.
Swiss/UK secondments – the basics
A short guide to the key requirements to second workers from Switzerland to the UK and from the UK to Switzerland.
Back to the office or quietly quitting?
Quiet quitting is where employees choose to do the minimum amount of work.
FT Ignites Europe quotes Nick Hurley on quiet quitting in the asset management industry
"I cannot see any employers embracing quiet quitting as a concept. Most companies will see it as something to reduce or eliminate"
UK Employment Law – A Guide
Looking to learn more about employment law? Discover exactly how it protects you with our complete guide.
Lesley O'Leary writes for The Law Society Gazette on law firm strategy
‘You need to have a frank discussion about the things that matter to clients’
Megan Paul writes for People Management on how business can help stamp out modern slavery in its supply chains
Stamping out modern slavery: how can HR help?
The Times quotes Kelvin Tanner on new scale up visas
"It is difficult to see how the scale-up route would be a more attractive option for an employer than the skilled worker route.”
Clare Davis writes for Personnel Today on hot weather and employment law
Hot summers, hot desks – employment law advice on working through heatwaves
New industry group aims to build sustainability skills in the construction sector
Barrister with gender critical beliefs discriminated against by chambers
An employment tribunal has found that the barrister, Allison Bailey was discriminated against because of her gender critical beliefs.
Calculating holiday for Part-Year Workers - why the method matters
We summarise the methods of calculating holiday pay and a court decision.
The Guardian quotes Nick Hurley on the recent Supreme Court holiday pay ruling
"It is one of the few examples of a situation where a part time worker is treated more favourably than a full time worker..."
Part-year workers favoured in Supreme Court holiday pay ruling
The Supreme Court looks at how holiday pay should be calculated for someone who works part of the year but has a permanent contract.
Gender critical belief – finding of discrimination
We look at the contrasting outcomes of cases dealing with discrimination claims.
Protect your connections
In an employment context, employers in the life sciences sector can protect their businesses in a number of ways.
Could the UK’s Life Sciences Vision be restricted by its Immigration Policy?
We explore some of the visa options that may be open to businesses in the sector and their relative pros and cons.
AI and HR - How can employers reduce the risks associated with using artificial intelligence to help manage their workforce?
If they are not mindful of the risks associated with AI, employers may find themselves in breach of employment and data protection law.
Are workers entitled to the Bank Holiday off for the Queen’s Jubilee? Don’t bank on it!
Nick Hawkins writes for Employment Law Journal on demystifying employment contracts
Key considerations for drafting effective post- termination restrictions