Equal pay claim based on differential pay distribution fails in Court of Appeal
The recent Court of Appeal decision in McNeil and ors v Commissioners for HM Revenue and Customs considered the issue of whether a clustering of men towards the upper end of a pay grade, and women towards the lower end established a ‘particular disadvantage’ for women, for the purposes of an equal pay claim. The Court of Appeal found that it did not.
The claims were brought by a group of female employees at HMRC. Jobs in HMRC below Senior Civil Service level are allocated to one of seven grades, each of which attracts its own “pay band”. The Claimants were employees in grades 6 and 7 (6 being the higher) whose salaries had, during the periods to which their claims related, been at the lower end of the pay band for their grade. It was common ground that the Claimants and their comparators did work rated as equivalent, for the purposes of the Equality Act 2010, and would be entitled to be paid the same as them unless HMRC could show a “material factor defence”.
The “factor” causing the pay differential was found to be use of a length of service criterion, as everyone joined the pay grade at the bottom of the pay band and generally increased annually until they reached the top of the band. The employment tribunal and the EAT both found that this factor did not put women generally at a disadvantage and therefore HMRC’s material factor defence was proved. The Claimants appealed.
The Court of Appeal upheld the decision. They rejected the Claimant’s argument that showing that proportionately more women are towards the bottom and, therefore, proportionately more men are towards the top of the pay grade would establish disadvantage in itself. The distribution of men and women within a pay band only means anything in so far as it represents what sums they are in fact paid. It necessarily follows that it is essential to take into account the actual amounts paid to each person in the group.
This rejection by the courts that clustering of men and women within pay grades necessarily puts women at a particular disadvantage without examining actual pay between the women and their comparators is helpful for employers in terms of gender pay reporting. If a picture emerges in the GPG report of women in lower quartiles and men in higher paid quartiles, this will not be sufficient information on which to base a claim alone – further details will be needed to establish the actual pay of Claimants and their comparators.
For more information, please contact Emma Bartlett.
COVID-19 Vaccination – can an employer make it compulsory for employees?
We review what legal issues to take into account when considering to make vaccination compulsory as an employer.
Linking ESG and Executive Pay
How does a business go about embedding a focus on strong ESG performance into the structures and culture of its organisation?
Amelia Goodwin and Georgina O'Sullivan write for Pharmacy Business on managing employee performance
Why contractors should prioritise performance management of employees as a regular feature of their business strategy.
The UK’s New Skilled Worker & Intra-Company Visa Routes: a closer look
Taking a closer look at the UK’s new visas to assist UK businesses.
Have your say: MAC call for evidence on Intra-Company Visa Route
The MAC, has launched a call for evidence on the Intra-Company Transfer (ICT) immigration route.
Sleep-in workers not entitled to NMW for entire shift
A unanimous ruling by The Supreme Court in the Royal Mencap v Tomlinson-Blake and another case.
Amelia Goodwin quoted by People Management, Home Care Insight and Care Home Management on the implications of the Supreme Court's ruling in Royal Mencap Society v Tomlinson-Blake
The court found that care providers do not have to pay the minimum wage to staff for time that they are asleep but on call during shifts.
It’s all about the data…why has the government delayed hospitality reopening again?
Michael Powner quoted by People Management on the implications of Uber's decision to pay drivers minimum wage
Uber’s rollout of living wage will put further pressure on other gig economy firms to follow suit.
Rose Carey, Kelvin Tanner and Kate Gamester write for Compliance & Risk on navigating the UK's new immigration system
The article highlights the compliance pitfalls and how organisations can adapt to avoid them.
The UK’s post-Brexit rules for skilled workers – Key implications for the construction industry
As a result of the new Points Based Immigration System , UK companies in the construction sector will not be able to sponsor labourers.
How to manage redundancies: employee rights on redundancy
What rights do employees have when a redundancy exercise is carried out?
Michael Powner quoted by Personnel Today on the implications of the Uber Supreme Court ruling on the gig economy
While the case is fact specific, the decision is likely to be a very persuasive authority for tribunals ruling on others in the gig economy.
Michael Powner quoted by Bloomberg, PA Media and People Management on the Supreme Court's ruling on the employment status of Uber drivers
The Supreme Court unanimously found that Uber drivers are workers under UK law.
Nick Hurley quoted by the Daily Mirror on 'no jab, no job' policies
'No jab, no job' may seem clear and concise, but mandatory policies requiring the Covid-19 vaccine are far from straightforward.
How to manage redundancies: practical steps
What are the practical considerations when carrying out a redundancy exercise?
EMI share options, Covid-19, and Brexit – where are we now?
What are the new measures to employers operating EMI schemes that have been affected by the pandemic?
How to manage redundancies: initial planning
What should employers consider when preparing for a redundancy situation?
Post-Brexit Implications for UK/EU Business Travel
How companies need to monitor the activities of their employees on business trips in a post-Brexit world.
Trevor Bettany quoted by People Management on the use of 'fire and rehire' tactics
Trevor Bettany considers questions around the legalities of ‘fire and rehire’ tactics.