Covert monitoring employees by CCTV did not violate right to privacy
Employers will be relieved by the recent European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR) decision that covert CCTV monitoring by a Spanish supermarket in the case of suspected theft was not in breach of the employees’ Convention right to privacy (article 8) and right to a fair trial (article 6).
The supermarket had noticed a number of discrepancies between actual and expected stock levels with losses of up to 20,000 euros per month. It installed hidden cameras in the cashier area for 10 days and did not tell employees. The footage showed employees stealing and 5 were dismissed. They brought claims of unfair dismissal on the basis that the use of hidden cameras was unlawful. These were unsuccessful and they brought claims against Spain in the ECtHR on the basis that use of footage in unfair dismissal proceedings was in breach of their right to privacy and that its use as evidence had violated their right to a fair trial.
The ECtHR found there was no breach of either Convention right as the use of CCTV was proportionate and necessary: the area monitored was public, surveillance was for a short amount of time (10 days), the filming was stopped when they caught the suspects, and as suspected criminal activity was involved, it would have defeated the purpose of installing the cameras to inform the employees about them. Significantly, none of the employees had challenged authenticity or accuracy of the footage and it was not the only evidence; the court had taken into account the employees’ own statements, statements of other witnesses and an expert’s report comparing the footage to the till receipts.
This decision does not give employers carte blanche to use covert surveillance to monitor employees. The ICO’s Employment Practices Code confirms it is rare for covert monitoring to be justified and it should only be used in exceptional circumstances following an impact assessment to decide whether the benefits justify the adverse impact. If an employer decides to go ahead with covert monitoring it should take account of the safeguards outlined in the Code which include ensuring no monitoring takes place where there is an expectation of privacy, such as a toilet or cloakroom, it lasts no longer than necessary, it is only used where there is no less intrusive way of dealing with the issue concerned, it should only be authorised by senior management and should affect as few people as possible. Employers should also consider the Surveillance Camera Code of Practice on covert monitoring which sets out 12 guiding principles. It should be noted that both the ICO Codes are due to be updated following the introduction of GDPR.
This article was written by Nick Hurley. For more information please contact Nick on +44 (0)20 7203 5039 or at nick.hurley@crsblaw.com
Our thinking
Mark Howard
Charles Russell Speechlys advises Content+Cloud on the acquisition of award-winning service provider Azzure IT
Content+Cloud continues its growth journey, this is our 7th successful transaction for them.
Rose Carey
Is the UK open for business? A discussion with the Home Office
We hosted an immigration webinar with the policymakers from the Home Office.
Pei Li Kew
Pei Li Kew writes for Pharmacy Business on the link between pharmacy and IP
Pei Li Kew writes for Pharmacy Business on the link between pharmacy and IP
Mark Howard
Charles Russell Speechlys advises Acora on its acquisition of Secrutiny
Charles Russell Speechlys advises Acora on its acquisition of Secrutiny
Is the UK open for business? A discussion with the Home Office
Join our Immigration team for a live webinar with policymakers from the Home Office.
Nick White
Charles Russell Speechlys advises Symphony Holdings Limited on the sale of its PONY trade mark portfolio for USD $28 million
Charles Russell Speechlys advises Symphony Holdings Limited on the sale of its PONY trade mark portfolio for USD $28 million.
Simon Ridpath
Simon Ridpath featured in the Lawyer’s Hot 100 list
Simon Ridpath features in The Lawyer’s Hot 100 list
Mark Howard
Charles Russell Speechlys advises Europa Oil & Gas (Holdings) plc on its £7m equity fundraising
Europa Oil and Gas is a renewable energy, oil and gas development and production company.
Simon Green
International Bar Association quotes Simon Green on the future of the legal sector in Hong Kong
International Bar Association quote Simon Green on the future of Hong Kong's legal sector
Rose Carey
Relocating to the UK – Post Tier 1 (Investor)
The UK government closed the Tier 1 Investor visa route with immediate effect on 17 February 2022.
Lesley O’Leary
Briefing publishes Lesley O’Leary 's comments on hybrid working and the impact on collaboration
Briefing publishes Lesley O’Leary 's comments on hybrid working and the impact on collaboration
Emily Chalkley
How to tackle a large Gender Pay Gap
Patrick Chan
Corporate Treasurer publishes Patrick Chan's comments regarding the No Consent Regime
Corporate Treasurer publishes Patrick Chan's comments on the No Consent Regime
Jamie Cartwright
Jamie Cartwright comments on the potential impact of the plastic packaging tax
Jamie Cartwright comments on the potential impact of the plastic packaging tax
Nick Hawkins
Nick Hawkins writes for Employment Law Journal on demystifying employment contracts
Nick Hawkins explains the key legal principles that govern contracts of employment.
Rebecca Burford
Charles Russell Speechlys partners with the Crafty Counsel community
Crafty Counsel brings together in-house legal professionals to share their experiences.
Michael Powner
Michael Powner and Emily Chalkley write for People Management on who pays the price for vicarious liability
Michael Powner and Emily Chalkley explain whether an employer should ever be liable for wrongdoing committed by their employees.
Jonathan Morley
International Business Reports reported on the firm’s involvement advising Battery Ventures on the sale of Forterro to Partners Group for €1 billion
The firm has advised global, technology-focused investment firm Battery Ventures on the sale of Forterro to Partners Group for €1 billion.
David Hicks
David Hicks quoted by FT Adviser on why Succession sold up to Aviva
David Hicks explains that private equity backers have a time horizon for their investments.
Sarah Wigington
How will the new Economic Crime Levy impact residential development joint ventures?
The Economic Crime (Transparency and Enforcement) Bill is being created through Parliament this month.