Effective recruitment – are unpaid work trials lawful?
Recruiting staff can be expensive and time consuming, particularly in sectors where there is high staff turnover. Trial work periods can be a good way both for prospective employers to assess if a candidate has the right skillset and for a candidate to see if they like the work in practice.
While it will always be appropriate for employers to pay those who “work” for them at least the national minimum wage or national living wage (as appropriate) (NMW / NLW), the Government has now issued some guidance on when employers may use unpaid work trial periods in their recruitment processes. This is of particular relevance to the retail and hospitality sectors.
While the guidance is not binding on HMRC Officers charged with enforcing national minimum wage laws or tribunals and courts, the guidance sets out factors that a court or tribunal would, in the Government’s view, be likely to consider and gives examples of when a worker is or is not likely to be entitled to NMW / NLW.
In the past, recruiters had to either take a commercial decision as to whether to rely on unpaid trial shifts to assess candidate suitability with potential NMW compliance risk or take a much more cautious approach where candidates could only perform a few practical tasks to demonstrate skills, but without those tasks reflecting the actual demands of the role. For example, a candidate seeking a position as a barista in a coffee shop might be asked to make a cappuccino for an existing staff member or as a complimentary drink for a customer, but would not be asked to perform the same task under customer and time pressure, which would be representative of a typical shift.
The guidance suggests that unpaid trial shifts can be used as part of a genuine recruitment process, provided candidates are observed and assessed during the shift; the duration of the trial shift is proportionate; and the “work” undertaken is representative of the role the candidate would perform if successful. These are the most pertinent points, but the guidance sets out further factors in greater detail:
- whether a “work trial” is genuinely for recruitment purposes (if it is not, it will generally be considered to be work and the individual will be eligible to be paid the NMW / NLW);
- whether the trial length exceeds the time that the employer would reasonably need to test the individual’s ability to carry out the job offered (in the Government’s view an individual conducting work in a trial lasting longer than one day is likely to be entitled to the NMW / NLW in all but very exceptional circumstances);
- the extent to which the individual is observed while carrying out the tasks;
- the nature of the tasks carried out by the individual and how closely these relate to the job offered (where the tasks are different from those which the job would involve, this may indicate that the employer is not genuinely looking to test the individual’s ability, but rather to get the tasks carried out);
- whether the tasks carried out have a value to the employer beyond testing the individual (where the tasks are carried out in a simulated rather than real environment, this will normally indicate that they do not have such a value and that the individual is not “working”);
- whether trial periods are important (aside from recruiting) to the way the employer runs its business (for example, where trial periods are being used by the employer as a means to reduce labour costs, this is likely to indicate that the individual is “working”).
We would always recommend employers have a consistent policy on trial shifts as part of their recruitment process to avoid discrimination claims. It is worth employers reviewing the HMRC guidance on unpaid work trial periods and the examples to ensure that how trial shifts are used in their business is appropriate.
The full guidance can be found here:
For more information please contact Clare Davis.
IBA Annual Conference
The IBA heads to Miami for its 2022 Annual Conference bringing together thousands hundreds of lawyers from around the world.
Joint Venture Opportunities
Join our panel where we will discuss various topics including Joint Venture structuring and Partner procurement.
Mind your business: Safeguarding your business against loss of mental capacity
Practical considerations to safeguard your business against loss of mental capacity.
FT Wealth quotes Sarah Anticoni on forum shopping
"Being the first to file for divorce is not a foolproof way of securing an English hearing"
What can UK investors interested in Life Sciences learn from their more experienced, including US, counterparts?
The recent tie-up between Canary Wharf and Kadans demonstrates the enthusiasm to access the lucrative UK life sciences market.
Helen Coward writes for Tax Journal on the main purpose test for SDLT group relief
Mainly ignored? The main purpose test for SDLT group relief
The Ayes have it - Collateral Warranties can be a ‘Construction Contract’
The Court of Appeal handed down its judgment in the case of Abbey Healthcare (Mill Hill) Limited v Simply Construct (UK) LLP
Charles Russell Speechlys advising Battery Ventures on the sale of SPT Labtech for £650 million.
Battery Ventures has raised over $9 billion to invest in software and services, enterprise infrastructure, and much more around the world.
Windrush Day 2022 – supporting access to justice
Charles Russell Speechlys is proud to continue supporting survivors of the Windrush scandal in their fight for justice.
The Leasehold Reform (Ground Rent) Act 2022: Landlords and developers beware serious sanctions for non-compliance
The Leasehold Reform (Ground Rent) Act 2022 received Royal Assent on 8 February 2022 and will come into force on 30 June 2022.
EG quotes Emma Preece on the Picturehouse and BNY Mellon rent arrears cases
“The case is being closely watched by landlords and tenants alike as the impact of the pandemic lives on in the commercial property sector”
Charles Russell Speechlys has advised long-standing client Stonegate on a series A investment into Peckwater Brands
Stonegate is one of the largest pub companies in the UK with a rich portfolio that covers over 4,500 sites.
Pro bono support for major office premises move for charity in Stoke-on-Trent
Emmaus entities provide safe homes, community support and meaningful work to formerly homeless people across the UK.
Financier Worldwide quotes Rachel Warren on the UK’s Economic Crime Act
Evaluating the UK’s Economic Crime Act
Julia Cox and Felicity Chapman write for International Adviser on the rise of pre-nups in the UK
Julia Cox and Felicity Chapman write for International Adviser on the rise of pre-nups
Property Patter: Reasonable Endeavours
What does it mean to use ‘best’, ‘all’ or ‘reasonable’ endeavours?
Could the UK’s Life Sciences Vision be restricted by its Immigration Policy?
We explore some of the visa options that may be open to businesses in the sector and their relative pros and cons.
Joshua Green writes for Spear's Magazine on Wagatha Christie’s lessons for HNWs
Wagatha Christie’s lessons for HNWs
Stephanie Bonnello writes for the Practical Law Dispute Resolution blog on witness evidence
When are witness summaries permitted instead of witness statements and when should material be struck out from a witness statement?
Hannah Turner writes for the EG Legal Q&A on the validity of a section 21 notice
Q&A: Tackling technicalities and typos