COVID-19: Cash conservation and dividend dilemmas
Cash conservation in what is now an uncertain economic environment has left some company directors with dilemmas over their expected or already announced dividend payments. ICSA has published a useful guidance note setting out options for directors to consider ahead of general meetings. We briefly discuss the ICSA note, the legal differences between interim and final dividends, and options for postponing, amending or cancelling dividends.
Directors’ duties and distributable reserves
Focus on cash conservation is leading many directors to reconsider their approaches to interim and final dividends and their company’s dividend policy. When recommending and paying a dividend, directors need to consider their general duties under the Companies Act 2006 (the Act), including the duty to “promote the success of the company”. Additionally, directors should remember that dividends may only be made lawfully out of distributable reserves, and directors should also consider the effect of the payment of any cash distribution on the company’s cash reserves. The impact of events, such as unexpected losses after the date of the relevant balance sheet for determining distributable reserves, must be considered before directors go ahead with dividend payments.
In general terms, it should be easier logistically for a board to cancel, change or delay an “interim” dividend than a “final” dividend. By way of reminder, final dividends, under the Act require shareholders’ approval, after they are recommended by the directors. Once approved by shareholders at a general meeting of a public company, or by way of shareholder meeting or a written shareholder resolution for a private company, the dividend becomes a debt due. This debt is then enforceable by the shareholders against the company. By contrast, interim dividends are declared by the directors and, unless also approved by shareholders, do not constitute a debt until paid.
In principle, a company may pay a smaller interim dividend and then a larger final dividend, a series of interim dividends or a combination of final and interim dividends - more than one final or interim dividend can be paid. In each case, the directors should consult the company’s articles of association (the Articles) to check any particular requirements relating to dividends.
Withdrawing directors’ support
Directors can still change dividend plans after an interim dividend is announced to shareholders and/or a final dividend resolution is included in a notice of a general meeting. From a legal perspective, the directors may remove their recommendation in relation to an announced interim dividend and update the market accordingly of a delay to the dividend payment, a reduction in the amount to be paid or a complete cancellation of the interim dividend. Alternatively, if the resolution for a final dividend has already been included in a notice of a general meeting, the directors may update the market that they no longer support the resolution and that it will not be put to the vote at the general meeting. In each case, the directors should explain to the shareholders the reasons for the withdrawal of the directors’ support for the particular dividend in the announcement to the market.
Returning to shareholders
If the shareholders have already approved the dividend, subject to the Articles, the directors may still be able to stop the dividend payment. As noted by ICSA, companies “cannot withdraw or amend final dividends after they have been declared by shareholders”. We would however, encourage directors to seek advice at this stage as to whether delaying the dividend payment and seeking shareholder approval to cancel the dividend would be feasible. If such an approach was determined by the board to “promote the success of the company”, another shareholder meeting could, in principle, be called.
Proxy voting considerations
A company may have to determine how to deal with proxy votes submitted prior to resolutions being amended or withdrawn. A person appointed as a proxy has an obligation under the Act to follow the instructions of the appointing shareholder. As such, the appointing shareholder could provide the proxy (potentially the chairman given the wider COVID-19 related restrictions on meetings) with updated instructions prior to the general meeting. In the absence of updated instructions, we together with ICSA would expect the proxy to vote on any amended resolution, in line with the original instructions.
Implications for MAR and the equity story
For a listed company, a change to an announced dividend or a dividend policy, already communicated to the market is likely to constitute inside information from a Market Abuse Regulation (MAR) perspective. Advisers should be consulted on any MAR considerations, even if the decision is not to propose to pay a dividend rather than to cancel one already announced. Additionally, the dividend policy may be an important part of the equity story. We would recommend that the “messaging” around delaying, reducing or even cancelling a proposed dividend is discussed with the company’s financial advisers to avoid the longer-term equity story of the company being undermined.
For more information, please contact Andrew Collins.
The Art Net quotes Petra Warrington on how the Charities Act will impact restitution cases
A new law will give national museums significantly more power to deaccession works and make progress on restitution cases.
Swiss/UK secondments – the basics
A short guide to the key requirements to second workers from Switzerland to the UK and from the UK to Switzerland.
The Mail Online quotes David Gregory on the mini budget and changes to the real estate industry
"This is a step in the right direction, but further support for existing occupiers may be needed..."
The Financial Times quotes Paul Stone on Ofcom's probe into competition and big tech in the cloud market
"The probe may act as a catalyst for a full-blown market investigation..."
Back to the office or quietly quitting?
Quiet quitting is where employees choose to do the minimum amount of work.
Limitation & the worthwhile test
When does time start to run for deliberate concealment claims? An insight into a Court of Appeal ruling which answers this question.
Charles Russell Speechlys advises Biolog-id on the execution of a Business Combination Agreement for proposed $312 million merger
Charles Russell Speechlys advises Biolog-id on the execution of a Business Combination Agreement for the proposed $312 million merger.
Paul Stone provides comment for City AM on the record fine against Google over Android phones
"This decision is a symbolic victory”
City AM quotes Paul Stone on the lawsuit facing Google re: anticompetitive conduct in the digital advertising market
"the lawsuits are a 'mirror image' of ongoing investigations by the CMA..."
FT Ignites Europe quotes Nick Hurley on quiet quitting in the asset management industry
"I cannot see any employers embracing quiet quitting as a concept. Most companies will see it as something to reduce or eliminate"
Jonathan Morley discusses the 'huge growth' in Gloucestershire driven by private capital for SoGlos
"Private investors are watching Gloucestershire closely and willing to invest in its businesses..."
Charles Russell Speechlys shortlisted for FT Innovative Lawyers Europe 2022 Award
Charles Russell Speechlys shortlisted for FT Innovative Lawyers Europe 2022 Award
The Grocer quotes Jamie Cartwright on the Celia Marsh inquest and allergen action
“Natasha’s Law responded to a perceived lack of accessible information on ingredients for consumers on the product itself..."
London’s role in the growing UK Life Sciences sector
Mark Kildea, Howard de Walden’s Chief Executive and Cara Imrailo discuss Life Sciences opportunities in London
Property Patter: The Notorious ESG?
ESG is everywhere.
Lesley O'Leary writes for The Law Society Gazette on law firm strategy
‘You need to have a frank discussion about the things that matter to clients’
Melanie Tomlin explains the measure of damages recoverable in defects claims for Building Magazine
Essential law: Defects, part four
The Energy Savings Opportunity Scheme
The aim of the scheme is to help organisations identify energy efficiency savings, to support and increase good energy management.
Aidan Welton writes for P3 Pharmacy on property considerations before selling a pharmacy business
There’s lots to consider ahead of time if you’re planning the sale of your pharmacy business...
Matt Foster and Dhara Shah write for Family Law Journal on child abduction: theory versus reality
Child abduction: theory versus reality