The Effect of Contractor Insolvency on Construction Projects in the Middle East
Why are bankruptcy laws needed?
Over the past couple of years, there have been a wave of new insolvency and bankruptcy laws introduced in the GCC. With the exception of Qatar and Kuwait, all other GCC countries have now introduced new bankruptcy laws. As for Oman, its new bankruptcy law is due to come into effect on 1 July 2020.
One of the many reasons why updating the bankruptcy laws has become necessary, is the need for inward investment. Modern fit for purpose bankruptcy laws give investors confidence by providing mechanisms for distressed companies to reorganise their structure and repay creditors with the possibility of continuing to operate. As such, all of the new bankruptcy laws contain provisions allowing for restructuring.
The risk of insolvency is present at all stages during a construction project and can have a knock-on effect on the time and costs for completing the project.
Insolvency regimes in the Middle East
The UAE was the first of the jurisdictions to implement a new bankruptcy law implementing the UAE Bankruptcy Law in 2016. It applies to all commercial companies, excluding those registered in the DIFC and ADGM as they have their own comprehensive insolvency regimes.
The UAE Bankruptcy Law has three mains parts to it:
- protective/preventative settlement;
- insolvency with restructuring; and
- insolvency with liquidation.
Protective settlement allows debtors to reach an agreement with creditors with the assistance of the court for the settlement of its debts. This is available to businesses that are not yet insolvent but are facing financial difficulties and offers a positive opportunity to enable the company to return to being profitable.
In Saudi Arabia, the KSA Bankruptcy Law was introduced in 2018. Similar to the UAE Bankruptcy Law, it also allows for protective/preventative settlement and insolvency with restructuring or liquidation.
In Bahrain, the Bahrain Bankruptcy Law, also introduced in 2018, is similar to that of both the UAE and Saudi Arabia. It was enacted to focus on modern legal mechanisms to restructure a business in distress.
Oman’s current bankruptcy law only recognises one formal mechanism, being liquidation. However, Oman issued its new Bankruptcy Law in 2019. Whilst the Law will not come into effect until 1 July 2020, the structure of the New Oman Bankruptcy Law is similar to that of the UAE. This will be an improvement and can be seen as a positive step to encourage investment.
Effect of insolvency on construction projects
Contractor insolvency is a key risk in any construction project. Whilst it is usual for a construction contract to allow an employer to terminate the contract upon insolvency, bankruptcy, liquidation, receivership, administration or similar of the main contractor, such termination may not take into account the general effects of financial difficulties (not resulting in insolvency), nor the impact on the project as a whole.
A prevalent theme in construction projects is the scenario whereby a main contractor and/or subcontractor is endeavouring to progress works while also operating within a fragile financial environment. Often this is due to late payment, non-payment and/or cash flow restrictions on other projects.
Alternatively, the main contractor and/or subcontractor may come into the project with a healthy financial backdrop only to be hindered by events arising during the contract term. All too often, parties are permitted or compelled to carry on, neither of which is commercially conducive to a successful project.
Even though employers may be aware of a main contractor’s financial difficulties, the contractor is often permitted to carry on because employers do not know how to react in these types of situations, other than through the relatively drastic step of termination of the construction contract.
One of the main considerations an employer should take into account when deciding whether to terminate the main contractor’s employment on the grounds of potential insolvency is whether the time and cost of allowing the main contractor to continue outweighs the time and cost consequences of appointing a new contractor to complete the project. This may be possible where the contactor, although in financial difficulties, is not truly insolvent, but can continue to trade. Where the contractor is insolvent, the construction contract will need to be terminated and another contractor engaged.
Once prescribed bankruptcy proceedings have been issued under the relevant bankruptcy law, one of the options is to allow for a formal restructuring of the business in distress. Given that bankruptcy legislation has recently been put into place in many GCC countries, it will be interesting to see how each of the proceedings are brought forward and dealt with by each jurisdiction. Only one firm in the UAE has successfully restructured its debt under the UAE Bankruptcy Law to date. It is therefore a relatively unknown area and it is unclear as to precisely how successful any restructuring is likely to be.
If a main contractor is successfully restructured following such proceedings, it could potentially continue on site to work towards finishing the project. However, a restructuring process is likely to take considerable time and, as such, an employer may prefer to terminate the main contractor’s employment if there is an alternative contractor available who would be able to successfully complete the project.
This article was written by Partner Paula Boast and Associate Jodie Martyndale-Howard. For more information please get in touch at email@example.com or on +973 17 133212 or Jodie at firstname.lastname@example.org or on +973 17 133213.
The Future of Property Careers
Join to our panel discussion and Q&A with industry leaders on the range of opportunities within the property and construction sector.
LIDW21: A view from London and India - How dispute avoidance can keep construction and infrastructure plans on track
Join us as we discuss the challenges of the possible rise in disputes in the construction and infrastructure sector in India
ICC 2021 Rules
The ICC has recently updated its rules for arbitration: the new rules entered into force on 1 January 2021 (the “2021 Rules”).
Use and Regulation of Renewable Energy Certificates in the UAE
The market for trading in renewable energy certificates is set to increase in both visibility and importance.
Patrick Gearon FCIArb
Insolvency Legislation in the GCC
The interesting times of the last 14 months were preceded by the interesting times of the financial crisis of 2008/2009.
Client alert: Construction under competition law spotlight
We outline the three investigations which have either recently concluded or are ongoing together with what this means for businesses.
Case Study: One Blackfriars Limited
An informative and positive judgment for administrators selling high-value property in distressed and complex scenarios.
Keeping Up With Construction: Handover at Practical Completion - Practical Pointers
Practical tips for the handover of a successful project.
Steven Carey writes for Building on whether a company can provide expert services in claims for and against the same party
A recent appeal case looked at whether a company can provide expert services in claims for and against the same party.
InvestAfrica: Checking in or Checking out? Financing Africa’s Hotels in 2021
The discussion examined the strategies investors and financial institutions can implement to mitigate the effects of the pandemic.
Infra.law - Spring 2021
Click here to read the latest edition of our construction and infrastructure publication, Infra.Law.
Assignment, novation and construction contracts - What is your objective?
What are the terms of the contract under which the sub-contractor carries out the works for the employer?
Adjudication enforcement and exclusive jurisdiction clauses post-Brexit
Does an exclusive jurisdiction clause in favour of a foreign court preclude an English court from enforcing an adjudicator’s decision?
Ghassan El Daye
Ghassan El Daye quoted by The National on the Dubai courts rejection of Dh1.3m rent refund claim
A convenience shop in Dubai lost its claim to a rent refund of Dh1.3 million from its landlord on grounds of lost revenue during lockdown.
Ghassan El Daye
Ghassan El Daye quoted by The National on legal reform in the United Arab Emirates
Once a law change has been made and is effective, a court of law is obliged to follow the new rule and issue its verdicts based in it.
The UK’s post-Brexit rules for skilled workers – Key implications for the construction industry
As a result of the new Points Based Immigration System , UK companies in the construction sector will not be able to sponsor labourers.
Andrew Keeley writes for Building on the consequences of a liquidated damages clause being unenforceable
Parties often agree to predetermine the level of damages that an employer is entitled to claim in the event of late completion.
Ghassan El Daye
Ghassan El Daye quoted by The National on the Federal National Council's proposals to unify legal fees
The Federal National Council is calling for legal fees to be unified.
Grand designs – Who should take the design risk in an MMC project?
MMC have been touted as a way to tackle costs and inefficiencies within construction, but who takes responsibility for the design ?
David Savage quoted by Construction Law on the confusion over construction contract liabilities arising from Covid-19
An increase in construction disputes relating to time and cost impacts of Covid-19 related project impacts has been seen.