Life after PFI – Future investment trends for infrastructure projects
In the autumn edition of Infra.Law, I suggested there were potentially three key impacts of Brexit on the construction industry, one of which was the UK’s approach on infrastructure investment following its likely changing relationship with the European Investment Bank.
Since that article, Brexit has continued to dominate the political landscape but there have been some recent announcements and developments by industry groups and the government which suggest that there is a recognition that infrastructure investment is at somewhat of a crossroads.
Infrastructure investment strategy
In conjunction with the Spring Statement, the government launched a consultation on private infrastructure investment. The consultation closes in June and, according to the consultation document, it is the government’s intention to publish a comprehensive National Infrastructure Strategy later this year. This strategy is said to be “the first of its kind” and despite the ‘Goodbye PFI’ announcement by the Chancellor in last year’s budget, private investment in alternative investment models will be key.
The Infrastructure Pipeline and new models
The Analysis of the National Infrastructure and Construction Pipeline, dated November 2018 by the Infrastructure and Projects Authority (IPA), identifies over £600 billion of projected public and private sector investment into UK infrastructure over the next 10 years. The report also confirms publication of the government’s National Infrastructure Strategy in 2019 and the need to keep pace with technological change to raise productivity and support long-term economic growth.
Contracts for Difference, the Regulated Asset Base Model, and the UK Guarantees Scheme are described by the IPA as tools for the delivery of projects through private investment, in lieu of PFI. Although these models are mentioned only in passing, the IPA states that the Regulated Asset Base Model (RAB) is being considered as the financing model for future new nuclear projects and some utilities. The Department for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy’s Policy Paper on Contracts for Difference (CfD), January 2019, describes CfD as the government’s main mechanism for supporting low-carbon electricity generation. Eligible UK renewable generators can apply for a CfD by competing for a contract based on a form of ‘sealed bid’. In contrast, the UK Guarantees scheme is not aimed at particular industries, but a wide range of infrastructure projects provided they meet the ‘nationally significant’ criterion.
Lucky number 13?
Project 13 is a procurement initiative that has been proposed as a solution by the Infrastructure Client Group (ICG), a forum for major infrastructure clients “to work collaboratively to understand best practice”. The Institution of Civil Engineers (ICE), who launched Project 13, describe it as a new, industry-led enterprise model that seeks to “boost certainty and productivity in delivery, improve whole life outcomes in operation and support a more sustainable, innovative, highly skilled industry.” The ICE cites projects such as the Anglian Water capital delivery alliances, Heathrow Airport expansion and National Grid’s London power tunnels as “early adopters beginning to implement the Project 13 approach”.
ICE’s P13 Blueprint sets out the roles and responsibilities of stakeholders in the model. Key suppliers and advisors have direct relationships with the owner, which is likely to push risk up, rather than down, as it places the owner in a central role. The owner engages an ‘Integrator’ who engages and integrates all the parties such that they work as a team with a common goal that jointly mitigates risk rather than transferring it. The team is driven by reward based on value added to project outcomes, rather than on day-to-day services provided and work performed.
Crucial to the success of this model is early engagement and design, and a holistic approach to construction combining a diverse range of skills and services. This ‘partnership’ approach is not partnering by another name. However, it is likely to work best where the parties can build trust based on longer-term relationships and benefit from the efficiencies of a 5-year framework versus a shorter one, for example.
By themselves, these investment models will not make the construction industry any more productive or address the potential skills shortage, which may hamper the success of future infrastructure projects. Investment by the private and public sector is also required in technology and new construction techniques.
The private sector has been making advances with investment into areas such as design for manufacture and assembly, drones, augmented and virtual reality. The Government’s announcement of a new £72million Core Innovation Hub, for investment into research and development for digital design, advanced manufacturing, robotics, drones and augmented and virtual reality, will build on the private sector’s investment in these areas.
The cost of investment in these new technologies is undoubtedly a hurdle, but they are also key to the success of infrastructure projects and investment models in the UK.
Practicalities in Cladding Claims
Insight into Issues with Cladding Claims
Client alert: Construction under competition law spotlight
We outline the three investigations which have either recently concluded or are ongoing together with what this means for businesses.
Case Study: One Blackfriars Limited
An informative and positive judgment for administrators selling high-value property in distressed and complex scenarios.
Keeping Up With Construction: Handover at Practical Completion - Practical Pointers
Practical tips for the handover of a successful project.
Steven Carey writes for Building on whether a company can provide expert services in claims for and against the same party
A recent appeal case looked at whether a company can provide expert services in claims for and against the same party.
InvestAfrica: Checking in or Checking out? Financing Africa’s Hotels in 2021
The discussion examined the strategies investors and financial institutions can implement to mitigate the effects of the pandemic.
Infra.law - Spring 2021
Click here to read the latest edition of our construction and infrastructure publication, Infra.Law.
Assignment, novation and construction contracts - What is your objective?
What are the terms of the contract under which the sub-contractor carries out the works for the employer?
Adjudication enforcement and exclusive jurisdiction clauses post-Brexit
Does an exclusive jurisdiction clause in favour of a foreign court preclude an English court from enforcing an adjudicator’s decision?
The UK’s post-Brexit rules for skilled workers – Key implications for the construction industry
As a result of the new Points Based Immigration System , UK companies in the construction sector will not be able to sponsor labourers.
Andrew Keeley writes for Building on the consequences of a liquidated damages clause being unenforceable
Parties often agree to predetermine the level of damages that an employer is entitled to claim in the event of late completion.
Grand designs – Who should take the design risk in an MMC project?
MMC have been touted as a way to tackle costs and inefficiencies within construction, but who takes responsibility for the design ?
David Savage quoted by Construction Law on the confusion over construction contract liabilities arising from Covid-19
An increase in construction disputes relating to time and cost impacts of Covid-19 related project impacts has been seen.
Keeping Up With Construction: Pre-procurement - Practical Pointers
Successful procurement is more than the choice of the construction contract.
Understanding Rules of Origin under the Brexit Agreement
The UK-EU TCA came into effect on 31st December 2020, what does it mean for importers and exporters? and what does Rules of Origin mean?
Haliburton v Chubb: The final say on an arbitrator’s duty of disclosure
We consider some of the key points when appointed arbitrators do not agree on the appointment of the third arbitrator as chairman.
‘Subject to contract’ – The effect of these words in settlement negotiations
The importance of the ‘subject to contract’ label during settlement negotiations and communications.
Conditional payment clauses in the UK and Middle East
Niel Coertse writes for Practical Law Construction on how conditional payment clauses help to prevent cash flow difficulties.
Niel Coertse writes for the Practical Law Construction Blog on conditional payment clauses in the UK and Middle East
Conditional payment provisions are prohibited in the UK, but in the Middle East, 'pay when paid' provisions play a significant role.
Changes to construction industry scheme rules from April 2021
Reviewing the main changes of the government's recently published draft legislation making changes to the Construction Industry Scheme.