Recording Phone Calls: Don’t take Consent for Granted
“Live” interviews have long been an authentic and personable way for journalists, whether from traditional media platforms such as television networks to influencers with a social media following, to gain an inside track on the latest news scoop “from the horse’s mouth”. The rise of social media and the instantaneous means in which news can go ‘viral’ through a multitude of sources, not all of whom are credible, has only exacerbated this need to obtain information from the actual source. Yet, what if an interviewee who is being called and interviewed “live” does not actually know he/she is on live television?
Shannon Sharpe’s Interview with NFL star wide-receiver Julio Jones
Across the pond in the US, this was the dilemma facing Fox Sports chiefs when Shannon Sharpe of sports debate show, Undisputed, called National Football League (NFL) star wide receiver Julio Jones to discuss Jones’ future with his then team, the Atlanta Falcons. Jones, apparently unaware that he was being filmed on live television, told Sharpe that he was “outta there, man”, only increasing trade speculation surrounding his future with the Falcons.
While Sharpe may have obtained the latest scoop on one of the NFL’s hottest talking points at the time, his stunt left Fox Sports with a massive headache on its hands. Unsurprisingly, the Falcons were unamused with the incident due to fears that their negotiating position to trade Jones had been compromised. From a commercial standpoint, NFL teams and the NFL may scrutinise their relationships with Fox Sports in light of Sharpe’s actions and limit media access due to issues of professionalism and trust.
From a legal standpoint, Sharpe may have breached Californian law under the Penal Code if Jones was indeed unaware that he was being filmed. Undisputed is produced in Los Angeles, California, which requires two-party consent to record phone calls. Under section 632 of the Penal Code, Sharpe could face a fine of up to $2,500 or imprisonment not exceeding one year or both for recording a conversation in which one party had an objectively reasonable expectation that they were not recorded. While there are few signs that Jones will press charges against Sharpe, this incident certainly shines a light on the need to be aware of a country or state’s privacy laws when conducting such live interviews.
Is this applicable in the UK?
The Regulation of Investigatory Powers Act 2000 (RIPA) underlines that individuals can record conversations without consent. This includes telephone conversations provided the recording is for their own personal use. Should the individual who has obtained the information choose to share the information with third parties without the consent of the individual whom they recorded, they will be in breach of the RIPA.
For business phone calls, the Investigatory Powers Act 2016 states that the monitoring of phone calls is allowed either if the company has obtained the customer’s consent or if the monitoring is permitted under the Investigatory Powers (Interception by Businesses etc. for Monitoring and Record-keeping Purposes) Regulations 2018. Relevant circumstances that allow for the monitoring and recording of phone calls include the need to keep a record of instructions in order to establish and obtain information relevant to the business, and to prevent crime. Data protection laws may be involved as personal data may be collected during this process. If so, the UK GDPR and Data Protection Act 2018 will apply.
In summary, individuals and businesses alike should always request consent before recording telephone calls. Businesses should ensure that staff members undergo regular training and make readily available an up-to-date staff handbook to ensure that gaffes like the one Sharpe committed are minimised.
China’s Personal Information Protection Law – keeping up with the Joneses or increased cyber-security?
Up until recently, China’s data protection rules could be found through a number of laws and guidelines
Charles Russell Speechlys advises shareholders of eCommonSense on sale to ECI Software Solutions
eCommonSense is a technology solutions provider focused on the construction and building materials supply sectors.
Resilience vs. Recovery - How the Facebook outage highlights important lessons
The recent Facebook outage disrupted all of its key global platforms, including Instagram and WhatsApp.
The United Arab Emirates Joins the Madrid System
Charles Russell Speechlys advises the founders of Compandben on the sale of the business to TopSource Worldwide
Compandben is one of the longest established international providers of employment solutions.
Supply chain going flat
2020: Influencer, 2021: Creative Director – what could go wrong?
Coded messages for landlords and tenants
“What does the code of practice mean for landlords and tenants? Read more here”
Jason Saiban writes for Food Manufacture on the food industry's climate change challenge
The key challenge will be how the environmental targets are actually met.
Grab the tail by the horns - Why is tail spend so critical in today’s outsourced portfolio?
It’s usually invisible, but in all likelihood, you’ve got tail spend.
Mark Hill writes for In-House Community Magazine on solutions templating, a new priority for in-house legal teams
Removing the burden from legal teams, contract managers and administrators.
Olivia Crane quoted by SoGlos on the increasing issue of cyber fraud being faced by businesses in Gloucestershire
Cyber fraud has cost Gloucestershire businesses around £369,800 in the last 13 months.
Tattoos, athletes and image rights
Campaigns featuring athletes often include visible tattoos and a number of recent legal cases demonstrate the issues that may arise.
Food Sector steps up on climate goals
Blue Sky Linking
Daniel looks at Sky's recent success in obtaining interim protection from infringement of their broadcast rights
Don’t Gamble on Bingo Ads, Warns ASA
The ASA has issued a reminder to advertisers that bingo adverts will be treated as gambling ads for the purpose of standards regulation.
Continuing Progress in the Sphere of Inclusive and Non-Discriminatory Advertising
The latest developments from the ASA, CAP and BCAP relating to the advertising regulators’ attempts to tackle discrimination in advertising.
eCommerce and the Post-Brexit State of Play
Key UK and EU legislation governing how online platforms deal with consumers and their business users.
UK and EU launch two-pronged attack into whether Facebook is abusing a dominant market position
The CMA and the European Commission have said that they intend to work together closely as their respective investigations develop.
Jason Saiban and Caroline Swain among contributors to the ICLG Guide on Digital Business Laws and Regulations in the UK
An overview of the laws and regulations for digital businesses operating in the UK.