Think of the Children – ASA Showcases New Approach to Online Protection of Minors
Late last week, the Advertising Standards Authority published the results of an investigation into online advertising on platforms frequented by children, seeking to ascertain whether advertisers are complying with the CAP code as it relates to the protection of young audiences. By monitoring a sample of websites and YouTube channels with significant child viewership, the ASA has produced an indicative account of which restricted subjects advertisers are most often placing on platforms with high youth viewership. It intends to repeat the exercise throughout the year to produce quarterly reports and ensure enforcement against repeat offenders.
What were the ASA looking for and why?
The investigation focussed on particular products considered harmful to young audiences, rather than inappropriate materials (e.g. violent imagery) or prohibited methods (e.g. directly encouraging children to make purchases). The ASA was concerned to know whether enough care is taken to ensure that adverts for age-restricted products are placed on platforms with appropriately aged audience demographics. The criteria focussed on unhealthy or dangerous diet and lifestyle products to which younger audiences are considered particularly vulnerable – namely advertising for alcohol, gambling, tobacco/e-cigarette products, weight loss products and HFSS (High Fat, Salt or Sugar) foods.
What did they find?
The bare results suggest that HFSS foods were by far the least carefully placed adverts in the context of child protection. However, the ASA noted that the majority of these breaches related to products which are not likely to appeal to children – citing butter, nuts and cooking sauces as examples – and were thus only technical breaches of the code. The most significant results were the findings that one (as yet unnamed) brand placed 10 alcohol adverts on the same website with a high child user rate, whilst 4 (unnamed) gambling companies placed 70 such ads across 8 platforms between them.
Where will they go from here?
The ASA has promised publicly reported compliance action against repeat offenders. As such, this first report can be regarded as a warning shot from the regulator, with those contacted about their non-compliance remaining anonymous and unsanctioned for now. Should relevant businesses continue to misplace their adverts, enforcement action and public exposure may well follow.
Commentary
This monitoring exercise represents a proactive and technologically astute step for the ASA in clamping down on the exposure of children to potentially harmful behaviour. Younger audiences today are highly tech-literate and access a wide variety of online material. Consequently, it is insufficient to define the regulatory boundaries of online material by reference to its target group – effective enforcement requires analysis of the demographic actually accessing material. However, advertisers will be pleased to note that the ASA appears prepared to take a reasonable line regarding inadvertent or inconsequential breaches. Their decision not to punish offenders on first warning is indicative of an understanding that identifying an online audience is a more complex matter than, for example, identifying the target market of print media. Equally, their acknowledgment that many HFSS food adverts were mere ‘technical breaches’ sounds a welcome tone of restraint, suggestive that the authority will not take action for breaches which do not relate to the purpose or spirit of the regulations.
Our thinking
Lee Medlock
Charles Russell Speechlys advises TDR Capital LLP and the Issa brothers on the real estate aspects of ASDA acquisition
TDR Capital LLP and the Issa brothers have completed their acquisition of a majority stake in ASDA from Walmart.
Paul Stone
Focus Antitrust - 24 February 2021
Our weekly competition update.
Freddie Law
Advertising Standards: An Update
An update on advertising standards.
Lauren Fraser
Leasehold Reform – The devil is in the detail
Taking a closer look at the Government's announcement in January that makes home purchase easier and cheaper for leaseholders.
Lauren Fraser
Further extension to ban on residential evictions
There has been a further extension of the ban on enforcement of possession orders at residential dwellings in England until 31 March 2021 .
Michael Powner
Michael Powner quoted by Bloomberg, PA Media and People Management on the Supreme Court's ruling on the employment status of Uber drivers
The Supreme Court unanimously found that Uber drivers are workers under UK law.
Carolyn Davies
Grand designs – Who should take the design risk in an MMC project?
MMC have been touted as a way to tackle costs and inefficiencies within construction, but who takes responsibility for the design ?
Chris Ingram
Tech Connect Newsletter - February 2021
Welcome to the February edition of our Tech Connect Newsletter.
Elliot Michaelson
EMI share options, Covid-19, and Brexit – where are we now?
What are the new measures to employers operating EMI schemes that have been affected by the pandemic?
Paul Stone
Focus Antitrust - 17 February 2021
Focus Antitrust - 17 February 2021
Millie Parrott
Read all about it: UK launch of Google News Showcase
UK launch of Google New Showcase
Harman Bains
Spring Budget 2021 - predictions
Spring budget 2021 - what will the Chancellor do?
David Coates
Charles Russell Speechlys advises Exeter Property Group on its acquisition of two property SPVs from the Tritax group
Exeter Property Group is one of the largest real estate investment managers focused on acquiring, developing and managing properties.
Tanya Wilkie
Next Generation Cloud for Europe
Next Generation Cloud for Europe
David Coates
Charles Russell Speechlys releases H2 2020 deal highlights
Our highlights over the past 6 months are now available.
David Coates
Charles Russell Speechlys advises the founders of The People Development Team (PDT Global) on sale to LTG plc
The People Development Team is a leading provider of online diversity and inclusion training and consultancy services.
Focus Antitrust - 10 February 2021
This week's Focus Antitrust update.
Helen Coward
Building anxieties: The impact of a possible CGT rate rise on housebuilders
As the March 2021 budget approaches and a potential CGT rate rise, what does it mean for housebuilders?
Fiona Edmond
Keeping Up With Construction: Pre-procurement - Practical Pointers
Successful procurement is more than the choice of the construction contract.
Laura Sheftel
Cladding/EWS1 Form – What’s it all about?
It is good news that the housing market can continue to operate, with appropriate safeguards, throughout this third national lockdown.