British Gas at boiling point: ASA rules BOXT breached CAP codes with misleading price comparison claims
On 15 July 2020, the Advertising Standards Agency (“ASA”) published its ruling on BOXT’s advertising campaign following British Gas’ claim that the advert was misleading. Three issues were investigated; one of which was upheld.
The complaint related to two separate adverts: a video on YouTube; and a TV advertisement for the heating company BOXT. The advertisements were published in October and November 2019.
British Gas challenged both advertisements on the basis that a voiceover in the ads stated:
“Listen up, if you’re thinking of replacing your boiler with British Gas, you might want to come a bit closer. BOXT can install your boiler the next day and a boiler from BOXT costs on average … actually you may want to turn the sound up too … £1217 less than the same one from British Gas. BOXT are also rated Britain’s number one heating company on Trustpilot. So don’t buy a new boiler from anyone else until you’ve checked BOXT, you’d be a fool to yourselves. BOXT, faster, cheaper, trustier."
British Gas challenged whether the references to installation and price comparisons in the advert were misleading. A member of the public also challenged whether BOXT’s Trustpilot claim misleadingly implied a comparison against British Gas.
BOXT response and ASA decision
Regarding installation, BOXT said they guaranteed next-day installation if the purchase took place before the cut-off point of 3pm, which was highlighted in the footer of their website home page. They further stated that if their website showed no availability for next-day installation, customers could call them as they had many engineers on standby to ensure customers received next-day installation.
The ASA concluded that whilst next day installation was subject to availability the evidence demonstrated that BOXT had sufficient measures in place to ensure consumers that chose next day installation received it, therefore the claim against BOXT was not upheld.
With regards to pricing claims, BOXT commissioned a third party to carry out market research via a mystery shopping programme. From this, a spreadsheet was created showing an average saving of £1,217.73 compared to British Gas boilers. However, the ASA noted that the spreadsheet only contained one type of boiler and many others had not been included in the comparisons, so the evidence was insufficient to support the claim. They held the claim was misleading and breached CAP codes 3.1 and 3.3 (Misleading advertising), 3.7 (Substantiation), 3.33 (Comparisons with identifiable competitors) and 3.39 (Price comparisons).
In relation to the Trustpilot reviews, it was held that consumers would understand the claim as separate to the comparison claims made against British Gas, as there was no reference to the competitor in that segment of the advertisement. Furthermore, BOXT were the top-rated company under the category of ‘heating services’ on Trustpilot, so the claim was not misleading and not upheld.
As part of the ruling, the ASA warned BOXT that the adverts must not appear again in the form complained of.
The ASA’s ruling in this case highlights the importance for brands to ensure they do not make comparative pricing claims unless they have sound evidence to support those claims. The threshold of this evidence is considered to be high – as demonstrated in this case, an independent third-party research assessment was considered insufficient.
For more information, please contact Anna Rogers.
Fiona Edmond and Mark Smith write for Property Week on data centres as an infrastructure asset class
The complexity of operational issues is something those new to the sector may not anticipate and interest is likely to increase.
Charles Russell Speechlys advises discoverIE on its acquisition of Antenova
discoverIE is a leading international designer, manufacturer and supplier of customised electronics to industry.
Gareth Mills writes for Lexology Getting The Deal Through on technology disputes in Bahrain
The most common disputes occur following perceived or actual failures to deliver required technology services an lack of clarity.
Charles Russell Speechlys advises Acora on acquisition of Westgate IT
Westgate IT specialises in providing IT support to businesses in the South West.
Charles Russell Speechlys advises Appital Ltd on £2.5m Investment led by Frontline Ventures
Appital is an Equity Capital Marketplace which aims to bring innovation to Equity Capital Markets.
Mark Hill writes for In-House Community Magazine on solutions templating, a new priority for in-house legal teams
Removing the burden from legal teams, contract managers and administrators.
Charles Russell Speechlys advises Metier on US$39m investment into Africa Mobile Networks
AMN builds, owns, operates and maintains mobile network infrastructure in Africa.
The regulation of big tech: a changing tide?
Sonia takes a look at the two main areas where the UK is increasing the regulation of Big Tech in 2021
Top 7 Data Protection Tips for Employers
Here are our top 7 data protection tips for employers.
There has been an increase in online phising attacks over the past year - but why?
Charles Russell Speechlys advises IFS on acquisition of Axios Systems
Axios Systems PLC is a global provider of cloud-based Enterprise Service Management (ESM) software.
Charles Russell Speechlys advises Apollo Aerospace Components on acquisition of NYK Component Solutions
Apollo is an aerospace and defence supplier.
Charles Russell Speechlys proud to sponsor the ‘Outstanding Achievement’ award at the final Sunday Times Virgin Fast Track 100 awards
The awards celebrated the successes of Britain’s 100 private companies with the fastest-growing sales.
Use and Regulation of Renewable Energy Certificates in the UAE
The market for trading in renewable energy certificates is set to increase in both visibility and importance.
Charles Russell Speechlys advises shareholders of Modern Networks on sale to Horizon Capital
Modern Networks is a leading provider of IT support, broadband and telecoms managed services to the UK’s commercial property sector.
CIS General Insurance Limited v IBM United Kingdom Limited - An analysis
Slow and chaotic – lessons from a digital transformation disaster in CIS General Insurance Limited v IBM United Kingdom Limited.
Charles Russell Speechlys advises Content+Cloud on acquisition of Sipcom
The acquisition establishes Content+Cloud as a global service provider to UK businesses.
Michael Powner quoted by Bloomberg, PA Media and People Management on the Supreme Court's ruling on the employment status of Uber drivers
The Supreme Court unanimously found that Uber drivers are workers under UK law.
Tech Connect Newsletter - February 2021
Welcome to the February edition of our Tech Connect Newsletter.
Charles Russell Speechlys advises the founders of The People Development Team (PDT Global) on sale to LTG plc
The People Development Team is a leading provider of online diversity and inclusion training and consultancy services.