Does Brexit cause frustration?
The European Medicines Agency (“EMA”) has been taken to court by its UK landlord, Canary Wharf Group, which wants the EMA to keep paying a rent bill estimated to be around £500 million for the remainder of its 25 year lease. The lease of the EMA’s premises in London’s Canary Wharf district was signed in 2014, but the EMA argues that, as Brexit forces it to leave the UK, the lease has been “frustrated” and so it should not be liable to pay the sums due under the remainder of the lease. Although this litigation relates to a lease of land the decision – which is due later this year – is likely to provide useful guidance as to how the English courts will treat all allegations of frustration connected with Brexit.
What is frustration?
Frustration is a principle of English law which allows for a contract to be discharged when an unforeseen event occurs after the formation of the contract which renders it (i) physically or commercially impossible to fulfil the contract, or (ii) transforms the obligations to be performed under the contract into radically different obligations from those undertaken at the moment the contract was entered into by the parties. If a contract is frustrated then both parties are excused from their future obligations under it.
However, frustration is a hard argument to win. The burden of proof is high and it often turns on the facts of the case, as in order for an event to be deemed “frustrating” it must:
- have occurred after the contract has been formed;
- be fundamental to the contract;
- not be due to the fault of either party;
- be entirely beyond what was contemplated by the parties when they entered into the contract; and
- render performance of the contract impossible, illegal or radically different from that contemplated by the parties at the time of the contract.
Is “Brexit” a frustrating event?
With the above in mind, whether or not Brexit is deemed to have frustrated the EMA’s lease is likely to hinge on whether or not Brexit was entirely beyond what was contemplated by the EMA and Canary Wharf Group at the time they entered into the lease. Given that Brexit has been part of the political discourse for several years, it will be interesting to see whether the EMA’s argument of frustration will be upheld by the court. Furthermore, there may be a policy decision to be made by the court as, if the EMA succeeds, the decision could open the “floodgates” for thousands more similar challenges.
In any event, and regardless of the court’s decision, we would advise that all organisations try and pre-empt any scenario where they would seek to rely on Brexit causing frustration by amending their contracts to explicitly deal with Brexit. Whilst including explicit provisions in a contract to accommodate for Brexit is a complex task, it will provide more commercial certainty than any attempt to rely on allegations of frustration.
For more information about how to amend your contracts in light of Brexit see here.
The Future of Property Careers
Join to our panel discussion and Q&A with industry leaders on the range of opportunities within the property and construction sector.
Q&A: Talking the telecoms talk
Georgina Muskett and Jonathan Wills answer queries on Electronic Communications Code agreement.
Property Patter: Navigating the complexities of Pharmacy Property
Pharmacy property is a specialist area which contains many traps for the unwary.
COVID-19 Vaccination – can an employer make it compulsory for employees?
We review what legal issues to take into account when considering to make vaccination compulsory as an employer.
Music to our ears? Well, perhaps not for Apple.
A feud first began when the music streaming giant, Spotify, filed a complaint against music streaming provide rand competitor, Apple Inc.
Linking ESG and Executive Pay
How does a business go about embedding a focus on strong ESG performance into the structures and culture of its organisation?
National Security and Investment Act granted Royal Assent
The Act establishes a new regime for the review of mergers, acquisitions and other transactions that could threaten national security.
Recent Trends In Firewall Legislation: BVI, Bermuda And Gibraltar
Charles Russell Speechlys advises Waverton on acquisition of Cornerstone Asset Management
Established in July 2010 and with offices in Edinburgh and Glasgow, Cornerstone offers wealth management and financial planning advice.
What do the new Debt Respite Scheme Regulations mean for Landlords and Tenants?
This will provide legal protection from creditors in the form of either a breathing space or a mental health crisis moratorium.
Charles Russell Speechlys promotes five to Partner
The promotions are effective 1 May 2021 and are accompanied by one Legal Director and 15 Senior Associate promotions.
Risk allocation in commercial leases: the High Court considers rent suspension, insurance and frustration arguments
Read our summary of the full judgement on the latest Covid arrears case.
Charles Russell Speechlys boosts private wealth offering with the hire of an international tax team
Robert Reymond will be joined at the firm by Leigh Nicoll, Emma Tyrrell and Oliver Cooper.
Proposed Takeover Code Amendments – Key Changes
The Consultation Paper has now been followed by a corresponding response paper which made certain modifications to the initial proposals.
Competition and Markets Authority announces review of the EU vertical agreements block exemption
The UK Competition and Markets Authority is reviewing the future application of the EU vertical agreements block exemption in the UK.
Playing Copycat – Why have M&S begun legal action against Aldi over Colin the Caterpillar?
M&S’s chocolate caterpillar was the first of its kind to land on our supermarket shelves, over 30 years ago.
Building Back Better: Future Gazing
What’s next for the hospitality industry post-pandemic?
Building Back Better: Re-examining your proposition
Why hospitality businesses should re-examine their proposition now
Building Back Better: Real Estate and Restructuring
How and why should hospitality businesses re-structure post pandemic?
Charles Russell Speechlys advises Fudco Partnership on sale to Exponent-backed Vibrant Foods
Fudco is a family-owned business selling South Asian ethnic foods in UK and Europe.