TV ads: is it a qualification or is it a contradiction?
A recent decision by the ASA held that a gambling advertisement was misleading where a qualification to the offer was included on screen – the ASA found that the qualifying comment was actually contradictory to the main offer contained in the ad. A complaint against the ad was upheld even though the ad had been cleared by Clearcast, highlighting how the ASA may interpret the obligation not to mislead consumers in a stricter manner.
William Hill released a television ad on 15 September 2017 concerning a horseracing promotion. A voiceover promised “bet on any live ITV flat race and if your horse wins by 2 lengths or more you’ll get a 15% free bet bonus on your winnings” and that the offer was “available on all ITV flat races”.
On screen, the words “Free Bet Bonus” and “Live ITV Flat Races” flashed up when referenced in the voiceover. Meanwhile, at the bottom of the screen, small text stated “selected UK flat races. 6+ runners.”
The BCAP Code seeks to prevent broadcast advertising which may be misleading. According to rule 3.10 of the Code, advertisements must state significant limitations and qualifications; such qualifications may clarify but must not contradict the claims they qualify.
William Hill argued that the key terms of the promotion were highlighted that consumers still had the ability to make an informed choice on whether to participate. In any event, of the races in question, 97% were scheduled to have 6 or more runners. After non-runners and withdrawals, 95% of races would have been eligible for the offer, which is still a significant proportion.
Clearcast had reviewed the ad and said that William Hill often ran these kinds of ‘enhanced offers’ and for each one, they provided full and substantive details. They considered that the chance of dropouts leading to a race being ineligible for the promotion was rare, and they were therefore happy that the small print was a qualification, rather than a contradiction.
Despite the relatively minor effect of the ‘qualification’, the ASA still held that the limitation to races with 6+ runners was “a significant qualification that should have been prominently included in the main body of the ad.”
The small print and the voice-over (which referred to ‘any live ITV flat race’ and ‘all ITV flat races’) were considered by the ASA to be contradictory and the ASA held that the advert was misleading. It ruled that the ad must not appear again in its current form.
Effect of this Decision
The ASA’s decision here highlights that advertisers should be very careful when using qualifications. Despite the relatively minor effect of the qualification (excluding only 5% of races), and despite the fact that the ad had been cleared by Clearcast, the ASA has shown that it may have a different interpretation of when a qualification becomes a contradiction.
This article was written by Peter Byrd. For more information, please contact Peter on +44 (0)20 7427 6754 or at email@example.com.
To view the ASA ruling, click here.
Sports Business: Five Current Themes
Nick White goes early with his thoughts on this year's Sports Business themes.
Charles Russell Speechlys advises Puma Private Equity on their investment into Everpress
Puma Private Equity offers a wide range of award-winning investments that help to support investors.
Fairhurst v Woodard: Property audio and video surveillance system breached GDPR
A recent judgment from Oxford County Court raises significant questions about the increasing use of smart doorbells and cameras.
Will JP Morgan’s digital only Chase launch shake up the UK retail banking sector?
Chase is JP Morgan’s consumer brand and is one of the largest retail banks in the United States with over 4,700 branches.
Who? Where? What on earth is an “NFT”!?
An NFT is a “Non-Replaceable Token” meaning only one of its type can ever be created and recorded on the blockchain it is connected to.
How does the FCA Cryptoasset AML/CTF Regime affect UK cryptoasset businesses?
With the notable exception of security tokens, the majority of cryptoassets remain unregulated in the United Kingdom.
Closing the Cookie Jar
Opportunistic claims for misuse of online tracking cookies are on the rise. Proactively ensuring compliance is key to avoiding claims.
Regulating AI – the impact of two key recent proposals: the UK’s National AI Strategy and the EU’s proposed Artificial Intelligence Regulation
With the hype surrounding artificial intelligence continuing to gather pace, we pause and consider some of the proposed regulatory changes.
Review of the Department for Digital, Culture, Media & Sport consultation
On 10 September 2021 the Department of Digital, Cultural, Media and Sport (DCMS) published a consultation titled ‘Data: a new direction’.
China’s Personal Information Protection Law – keeping up with the Joneses or increased cyber-security?
Up until recently, China’s data protection rules could be found through a number of laws and guidelines
Charles Russell Speechlys advises shareholders of eCommonSense on sale to ECI Software Solutions
eCommonSense is a technology solutions provider focused on the construction and building materials supply sectors.
Resilience vs. Recovery - How the Facebook outage highlights important lessons
The recent Facebook outage disrupted all of its key global platforms, including Instagram and WhatsApp.
Property Patter: Dealing with Sporting Rights over Land
Sporting rights can cause issues particularly if they are granted over land which may be developed in the future.
Charles Russell Speechlys advises the founders of Compandben on the sale of the business to TopSource Worldwide
Compandben is one of the longest established international providers of employment solutions.
"The WinnerS Take It All"
In a sports setting, it is most unusual to see so many winners arising out of a decision by a rights holder to share rights.
Coded messages for landlords and tenants
“What does the code of practice mean for landlords and tenants? Read more here”
Jason Saiban writes for Food Manufacture on the food industry's climate change challenge
The key challenge will be how the environmental targets are actually met.
Grab the tail by the horns - Why is tail spend so critical in today’s outsourced portfolio?
It’s usually invisible, but in all likelihood, you’ve got tail spend.
Nick White writes for City AM on how City Football Group's multiple ownership model might give Man City an edge in the transfer market post-Brexit
Could a multiple ownership model give clubs an edge in the transfer market post-Brexit?
eCommerce and the Post-Brexit State of Play
Key UK and EU legislation governing how online platforms deal with consumers and their business users.