Beanz and gone (twice)
Advertising Standards Authority throws out Heinz Beanz advert for the second time due to nutritional claims.
‘Protein’ is an inescapable buzzword within the food and nutrition industry. For years, brands have cashed in on the nation’s interest with products such as protein bars, protein shakes, protein coffee and now even protein beer. Marketing and labelling a product as ‘high in protein’ is a widespread tactic being employed to encourage sales.
Twentieth century staples are being displaced by these products but often the nutritional values are no better. This was the message that Heinz was trying to convey in their advert – don’t write off the old fashioned humble baked bean.
The advert showed a man explaining his new fitness regime to his family whereby he took a protein shake out of the fridge and stated “This is the last P: Protein, with high fibre and minimal fat.”
The woman then responded to the man’s statement by saying “Right. We’re just having some beans.”
Directly after the woman’s response a tag appeared on the screen stating “High in protein. High in Fibre. Low in Fat.”
The Advertising Standards Authority (ASA) considered the context of the woman’s statement and tag line and found that viewers would interpret this to mean that beans had as much protein, fibre and fat as the protein shake that had been displayed.
In its ruling the ASA makes it clear - Heinz did not actually state that Heinz Beanz contained as much protein, fibre and fat as a typical protein shake. But it was sufficient for the ASA that viewers of the advert would interpret it as meaning Heinz Beanz were a tastier and more appetising, but nutritionally equivalent, alternative to a protein shake.
The crux of the issue is that Heinz made a comparison to another food. Under the UK Code of Broadcast Advertising (BCAP Code) 13.4, marketers are only allowed to make nutritional claims that are listed in the updated Annex of the EU Regulation (EC) No1924/2006. For example:
‘Cow’s Milk products help support dental health and support the normal and healthy development of teeth’
is a permitted health claim listed in the Annex. If a nutritional claim is made then it must be listed in the Annex or the ASA can ban the advert.
The case outline above was not permitted as Heinz attempted to claim that one food has “as much” of a nutrient as another food. This claim is not one which is listed in the Annex and therefore the ASA found the advert to contravene BCAP 13.4 and issued a ban.
The commercial had originally been barred in 2017 for the same reason after the woman responded using the word “Same”. Heinz believed that by replacing the word ‘same’ with ‘right’ it removed the comparison and the advert would be permitted.
The ASA has shown here that it will not permit adverts that compare nutritional values and their key concern is the interpretation of the advert and how it will be perceived by the general public rather than matter-of-fact linguistics.
A spokesman for Heinz stated that the advert “simply aimed to be a memory jogger about the goodness of beans in a humorous way”. The fact Heinz pitted it against a 21st century newcomer proved to be their downfall.
Is the question going around your head right now: “Does a tin of Heinz Beanz actually have the same nutritional content as a protein shake?”
To answer your question, the nutritional content of the pair are as follows:
Tin of Heinz baked beans (415g):
- 19.4g of protein
- 15.4g of fibre
- 0.86 of fat
Pre-mixed protein shake*: *Leading brand, 500ml
- 50g of protein
- 12.5g of fibre
- 1.5g of fat
This article was written by Harry Taylor. For more information please contact Harry on or at email@example.com.
Fiona Edmond and Mark Smith write for Property Week on data centres as an infrastructure asset class
The complexity of operational issues is something those new to the sector may not anticipate and interest is likely to increase.
Charles Russell Speechlys advises discoverIE on its acquisition of Antenova
discoverIE is a leading international designer, manufacturer and supplier of customised electronics to industry.
Coded messages for landlords and tenants
“What does the code of practice mean for landlords and tenants? Read more here”
Gareth Mills writes for Lexology Getting The Deal Through on technology disputes in Bahrain
The most common disputes occur following perceived or actual failures to deliver required technology services an lack of clarity.
Charles Russell Speechlys advises Acora on acquisition of Westgate IT
Westgate IT specialises in providing IT support to businesses in the South West.
Jason Saiban writes for Food Manufacture on the food industry's climate change challenge
The key challenge will be how the environmental targets are actually met.
Grab the tail by the horns - Why is tail spend so critical in today’s outsourced portfolio?
It’s usually invisible, but in all likelihood, you’ve got tail spend.
Olivia Crane writes for The Grocer on the importance of robust data protection policies for checkout-less stores
The ‘personal data footprint’ created by this type of service and technology isn’t something that should be overlooked.
Consumers’ unwitting assumptions: A [wh]iskey business in brand competition
Olivia and Anna look at the Liverpool Gin Distillery Ltd v Sazerac Brands LLC case and the question of 'indirect confusion'
Charles Russell Speechlys advises Appital Ltd on £2.5m Investment led by Frontline Ventures
Appital is an Equity Capital Marketplace which aims to bring innovation to Equity Capital Markets.
Mark Hill writes for In-House Community Magazine on solutions templating, a new priority for in-house legal teams
Removing the burden from legal teams, contract managers and administrators.
Charles Russell Speechlys advises Metier on US$39m investment into Africa Mobile Networks
AMN builds, owns, operates and maintains mobile network infrastructure in Africa.
Olivia Crane quoted by SoGlos on the increasing issue of cyber fraud being faced by businesses in Gloucestershire
Cyber fraud has cost Gloucestershire businesses around £369,800 in the last 13 months.
Tattoos, athletes and image rights
Campaigns featuring athletes often include visible tattoos and a number of recent legal cases demonstrate the issues that may arise.
Blue Sky Linking
Daniel looks at Sky's recent success in obtaining interim protection from infringement of their broadcast rights
Charles Russell Speechlys advises on the sale of No.1 Lounges Ltd to SwissportALD
SwissportALD will run nine No.1 Lounge properties at the UK’s London Heathrow, London Gatwick, and Birmingham airports.
The regulation of big tech: a changing tide?
Sonia takes a look at the two main areas where the UK is increasing the regulation of Big Tech in 2021
Don’t Gamble on Bingo Ads, Warns ASA
The ASA has issued a reminder to advertisers that bingo adverts will be treated as gambling ads for the purpose of standards regulation.
Recording Phone Calls: Don’t take Consent for Granted
What if an interviewee who is being called and interviewed “live” does not actually know he/she is on live television?
eCommerce and the Post-Brexit State of Play
Key UK and EU legislation governing how online platforms deal with consumers and their business users.