2018: a question of governance in sport
The last 12 months have seen a continuation of the explosive growth and commercialisation of the sports sector. As sport and business go increasingly hand-in-hand, controversies over governance and accountability of those running sports organisations are increasing. As such, 2018 is likely to see a marked focus on governance in sport.
Recently, sports governing bodies have begun to analyse their governance structures with a view to modernising them. As the market in which they operate changes, so too does the realisation that often the structures that are in place are not fit for purpose. Furthermore, privately held sports organisations are often run without input from the multitude of stakeholders that may hold an interest.
Regulatory, commercial and public pressures are changing the landscape and leading to reform. This article looks at some of the drivers of change and the likely impact in 2018.
Pressure from sponsors
As sport becomes increasingly commercialised, the sponsors investing their money and reputation in the sector are becoming more demanding of the organisations they partner with. Sponsors demand greater transparency prior to entering into arrangements and may exercise termination rights in event of high profile governance failures.
Recourse to the law
Three recent cases highlight how legal action has been taken in an attempt to remedy purported governance deficiencies in sports organisations:
- In November 2017, a minority shareholder in Blackpool Football Club was successful in bringing an unfair prejudice action and obtaining a court order that required the majority shareholder to buy him out. The case related to the majority shareholder ignoring decision-making structures and declaring dividends that did not benefit the club.
- Swansea footballer Wilfried Bony is engaged in an ongoing legal dispute with two former agents who used to represent him. Bony is alleging that undisclosed commission was paid to the agents. Swansea (who Bony re-joined in August 2017) were originally part of the action, but the claim against Swansea was settled. The case highlights the increasing pressure on clubs in relation to payments made to agents. If Bony is successful in court, further actions of this kind may follow in 2018.
- Cyclist Jess Varnish is involved in an on-going legal battle with British Cycling and UK Sport relating to her treatment whilst on the elite performance program. An independent review, published in June of last year, reported that good governance was lacking in the sport. 2018 is likely to see other sports governing bodies assess their own governance structures in light of this, and other, reports on the topic. However 2018 will likely see further controversy and legal cases in this area.
Code for Sports Governance
In October 2016, UK Sport and Sport England published the “Code for Sports Governance”, which creates binding governance requirements for all sports organisations from elite to grass roots, including performance programs for Olympic sports, that want to receive UK Sport or Sport England funding. For bodies receiving funding over multiple years and in excess of £1m, the requirements included the following (non-exhaustive):
- Maximum periods of tenure for board directors;
- 25% of board members needing to be independent;
- To have non-executive directors; and
- To target and take appropriate action to encourage a minimum of 30% of each gender on boards.
During 2017 many organisations took steps to amend constitutions and processes to become ‘code compliant’ ahead of the soft deadline of October 2017. This process was often fraught and involved curtailing the historic power of membership councils. Table Tennis England saw its funding briefly suspended in July when its members rejected the necessary reform package (a decision which was subsequently reversed). 2018 will see the further implementation of the reforms, with many board members being required to step down due to tenure limits expiring and new independent, non-executive director positions being filled.
Internal standards
Many sports organisations recognise the reputational and commercial risks where governance concerns arise and are proactively reviewing procedures.
For example, the Football Association recently ended its sponsorship arrangement with Ladbrokes due to the perceived conflict of interest with the FA’s role as the enforcer of Rules prohibiting footballers from gambling. Additionally, in December 2017 World Rugby announced it will undertake a review of its process for awarding World Cup tournaments, after its members rejected the recommendation of an independent evaluation in a secret ballot when awarding the 2023 tournament to France.
The increasing frequency of affected persons challenging decisions of sports bodies (typically through internal appeals procedures) is continuing to influence standards in governance. Requirements of transparency and accountability are becoming embedded in updated policies and procedures.
Summary
The numerous regulatory and commercial drivers will ensure that governance continues to be a major focus for the sports sector in the 12 months ahead.
For more information, please contact Richard Davies on +44 (0)20 7427 6732 or at Richard.Davies@crsblaw.com.
Our thinking
Natalie Batra
ITV takes the plunge and “couples up” with Ebay to dress love island contestants in pre-loved clothing
Pierre Bydzovsky
Update on FIFA-related proceedings in Switzerland
An update on the TV rights appeal trial for the World Cups and the on-going trial against former FIFA president and former UEFA president.
Grégoire Uldry
New Swiss succession law on the transfer of businesses
On 10 June 2022, the Federal Council adopted its Message amending the Civil Code on the transfer of businesses by succession.
Louise Paterson
Artnet quotes Louise Paterson on the Ivory Act
UK’s Ivory Act comes into force
Simone Sancandi
Sports Arbitration Rules and Roster of Dedicated Arbitrators
The Bahrain Chamber of Disputes Resolution publishes a brand-new set of Sports Arbitration Rules.
Pei Li Kew
Pei Li Kew writes for Pharmacy Business on the link between pharmacy and IP
Pei Li Kew writes for Pharmacy Business on the link between pharmacy and IP
Jonathan McDonald
Jonathan McDonald provides comment for City AM on the Data Reform Bill announced in the Queen's Speech
Jonathan McDonald provides comment for City AM on the Data Reform Bill announced in the Queen's Speech
Nick White
Charles Russell Speechlys advises Symphony Holdings Limited on the sale of its PONY trade mark portfolio for USD $28 million
Charles Russell Speechlys advises Symphony Holdings Limited on the sale of its PONY trade mark portfolio for USD $28 million.
Simon Ridpath
Simon Ridpath featured in the Lawyer’s Hot 100 list
Simon Ridpath features in The Lawyer’s Hot 100 list
Natalie Batra
Patents and Peppa Pig: What is happening to intellectual property rights in Russia?
Certain Russian individuals and businesses can now use patents, utility models and industrial designs without obtaining prior permission.
Simon Green
International Bar Association quotes Simon Green on the future of the legal sector in Hong Kong
International Bar Association quote Simon Green on the future of Hong Kong's legal sector
Zoe Bowler
“Nobody puts Baby in the corner…”
Charlotte Duly
Charlotte Duly quoted in Retail Gazette on House of Zana trademark dispute
Charlotte Duly quoted in Retail Gazette on House of Zana trademark dispute
Keir Gordon
Charles Russell Speechlys celebrates this year’s Sports Technology Awards finalists
The Sports Technology Awards celebrates tech-led innovation in sports, globally.
Caroline Greenwell
Nowhere to hide for greenwashing brands
In the UK, regulators are cracking down, with many companies now at risk of financial and other penalties.
Jamie Cartwright
Weighing up the Plastic Packaging Tax
The Plastic Packaging Tax came into force on 1 April 2022.
Jamie Cartwright
Crunching numbers - Mandatory calorie laws come into force
The Calorie Labelling (Out of Home Sector) (England) Regulations 2021 (the Regulations) are now in force.
Jody MacDonald
Liverpool FC’s Hero Club and the current state of play with football NFTs
Liverpool’s Hero Club hit the headlines this week and serves as an interesting reflection of the current state of play.
Rachel Bell
Rachel Bell commented in IT Pro on the implications of the proposed EU’s Digital Markets Act
The proposed EU’s Digital Markets Act is set to require larger messaging platforms to interoperate with their smaller rivals.