Louise Paterson comments on lab-grown diamonds and luxury asset ownership in TheWealthNet
min readLouise Paterson, Senior Associate in the UK Private Client team, has been quoted in TheWealthNet discussing the growing popularity of lab-grown diamonds and the potential implications for the wider luxury asset market.
In the article, Louise considers how the increasing availability of lab-grown diamonds could affect perceptions of scarcity and the value of natural diamonds. She also discusses the considerations for those purchasing jewellery for personal enjoyment, investment or to pass on to future generations.
"Lab-grown diamonds can look identical to natural diamonds, which are both a long-established tangible and relatively liquid investment class, and a ‘lifestyle’ purchase if worn in jewellery. However, lab-grown diamonds’ lack of re-sale value means they are fundamentally different to natural diamonds as an investment class.
"As lab-grown diamonds become more common, the perceived decrease in diamonds’ scarcity overall (given that lab-grown diamonds are not always immediately or easily distinguishable from natural diamonds) may have consequences for the market value of natural diamonds too. Women considering luxury purchases which combine personal enjoyment with investment might choose instead to focus on purchases with established historical, artistic or creative interest and an established (albeit potentially manufactured) supply ‘ceiling’ – for example, fine art or an Hermes Birkin handbag.
"For someone who intends never to sell their diamonds but instead to pass down sentimental items of jewellery to future generations, a lab-grown diamond might be a prudent choice. The corollary of its much more accessible price point is lower insurance premiums (if any) by reference to a lower replacement cost; minimal capital gains tax exposure on a lifetime gift; and minimal inheritance tax exposure on the owner’s death. At the same time, purchasers of lab-grown diamonds should be aware that the value of such jewellery is likely to be mainly emotional, since unlike natural diamonds they appear unlikely to offer any enduring financial legacy nor facilitate the generational transfer of material wealth."
Read the full article in TheWealthNet.