Georgina Muskett and Sylwia Barchus examine the strategic use of settlement offers in property disputes, writing in Solicitors Journal
min readThe costs judgment arising from the Bankside rights of light dispute demonstrates that successfully resisting an injunction does not necessarily make a developer the successful party for costs purposes. Because liability remained contested, the claimants were treated as successful overall, although their costs recovery reflected their mixed success.
The decision also illustrates the importance of structuring Part 36 offers carefully. Offers covering several claims, parcels of land or additional rights may be valid, but their costs protection can be weakened if the court cannot determine whether the eventual judgment has beaten the relevant part of the offer.
Settlement positions should be kept under review as evidence and litigation risks develop. Realistic, clearly reasoned offers, supported by a documented assessment of damages and costs exposure, can strengthen a party’s position if the dispute proceeds to trial.
Georgina Muskett, Senior Associate, and Sylwia Barchus, Associate, both in our Real Estate Disputes team, write in Solicitors Journal:
Settlement strategy is an important part of any litigator’s arsenal but in real estate litigation, Part 36 does not neatly fit with the types of disputes that pass across our desks. The costs judgment in Cooper & others v Ludgate House Limited (2025) (the Bankside Decision), is a salient reminder of the potential pitfalls of using Part 36 in property disputes.
Read the full article in Solicitors Journal here.