• insights-banner

    In the Press

Andrew Ross and Laura Bushaway write for Property Week on a Supreme Court judgment relating to nuisance

min read

In the landmark judgment of Fearn v board of trustees of the Tate Gallery, the Supreme Court held by a majority that visual intrusion is capable of being an actionable nuisance.

A recent High Court decision in Nicholas v Thomas provides an example of a successful claim for nuisance based on visual intrusion in very different circumstances to Fearn and demonstrates the continuing evolution of the law of nuisance.

The claimants were brothers who ran a successful falcon breeding business and brought a claim against their neighbouring owner Barnes Thomas, who ran a scaffolding business from neighbouring land. There was an acrimonious dispute between the parties, culminating in claims for nuisance alleging that Thomas’s activities on his land had directly caused the death of three gyrfalcons. These included, among other allegations, that Thomas had operated a scaffolding business in a way that generated excessive noise in the aviary and operated a 10m-high truck-mounted crane that broke the sight line of the falcons, constituting a visual threat.

The claim for damages in nuisance and negligence succeeded in the sum of £258,500, which comprised the following heads of loss: £13,500 for eggs lost; £200,000 for the loss of three falcons; and £45,000 for lost chicks that would have hatched.

All other claims and counterclaims were dismissed, including a claim for injunctive relief to restrain Thomas from causing excessive noise during certain future months of the falcons’ breeding season.

Andrew Ross, Partner, and Laura Bushaway, Knwoledge Development Lawyer, both in our Real Estate Disputes team, write on the judgment for Property Week. They explain:

Fundamentally, this case is about how the law of nuisance balances competing land uses, particularly where harm is occurring to sensitive operations on land. The key is considering the type of property and the use of the land within the surrounding neighbourhood. It also demonstrates the court’s approach to nuisance resulting from visual intrusion and how the law of nuisance continues to evolve following Fearn.

Read the full article in Property Week here.

Our thinking

  • London Arbitration Week: ‘Building Data Centres Without Building Disputes’

    Gareth Mills

    Events

    min read
  • Construction Market Update: Looking Forward

    Michael O'Connor

    Events

  • Should You Even Bother? Making the Case for Bringing a Case

    Caroline Greenwell

    Events

    min read
  • Getting The Most From Your People

    Megan Paul

    Events

    min read
  • Britain wants nuclear: Can we build it at pace?

    Kevin Gibbs

    Events

    min read
  • Investing in London Real Estate Seminar

    Chiara Del Frate

    Events

    min read
  • ICLG quotes Dewdney William Drew

    Dewdney William Drew

    In the Press

    min read
  • Amy Shuttleworth and Nicholas Wyatt write in RICS Property Journal about electric vehicle charging point leases

    Amy Shuttleworth

    In the Press

    min read
  • CC/Devas v India: English Court of Appeal confirms that ratification of the New York Convention does not amount to a waiver of state immunity

    Thomas R. Snider

    Insights

    min read
  • Charles Russell Speechlys advises the SURE Residential Fund in first of its kind examination of Building Safety Act remediation contribution orders

    James Worthington

    News

    min read
  • Can the SRA demand privileged documents?

    Alex Legard

    Insights

    min read
  • Nicola Thorpe is featured in the latest Law UK Power List, and comments on family offices, private capital, and the importance of relationship building

    Nicola Thorpe

    In the Press

    min read
  • High Value Council Tax Surcharge: what the Government’s Budget Day response and subsequent first draft Finance Bill tells us

    Katie Talbot

    Insights

    min read
  • New Data Centre Covenant: power for promises

    Antony Vundi

    Insights

    min read
  • One-Sided, Still Binding: London Court Upholds Unilateral Arbitration Clause

    William Payne

    Insights

    min read
  • Charles Russell Speechlys shortlisted for Law.com International Leadership in Law ‘Justice for All’ Accolade

    Debbie Watson

    News

    min read
  • Italy’s proposed Exit Tax

    Nicola Saccardo

    Insights

    min read
  • Judgement Needs a Map: What Nomads and Sponsors Need to Know About Advising Family and Trust-Held Issuers

    Greg Stonefield

    Insights

    min read
  • Leasehold and Freehold Reform Act 2024 service charge reforms: Government confirms when the new regime will take effect

    Georgina Muskett

    Insights

    min read
  • Accelerating Safety: The Building Safety (Remediation of Unsafe Cladding etc) Bill

    Sylwia Barchus

    Insights

    min read
Back to top