• Sectors we work in banner(2)

    Quick Reads

Retrospectively changing Indefinite Leave to Remain rules for those currently on the 5 year route to a 10 year route is unlawful and unfair

min read

This week has been mostly about reassuring clients that the Immigration White Paper is not yet law and we will have to wait and see what the proposed new rules will be. This has been particularly daunting for clients who may be applying for indefinite leave to remain in 2026 and are being told that the rug will be pulled from under their feet and they will have to wait until 2031. 

It seems from media responses from Government Ministers this week that memories are short on this settled issue. 

In 2006, the then UK government introduced changes to the rules for a now-defunct visa programme called the Highly Skilled Migrant Programme (HSMP). This affected the criteria for extending the visa and obtaining indefinite leave to remain. These changes were applied retrospectively to individuals already in the UK under the HSMP scheme, which led to significant concerns and challenges for those affected.

In the case of HSMP Forum Ltd, R (on the application of) v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2008] EWHC 664 (Admin) (08 April 2008), the High Court ruled that:

  • Retrospective Application: Applying the new rules retrospectively to individuals who had already been granted leave was unfair and unlawful.
  • Legitimate Expectation: The court recognised that migrants had a legitimate expectation that the rules under which they were initially granted leave would continue to apply to them.
  • Outcome: The High Court ruled in favour of the HSMP Forum, preventing the government from applying the new rules retrospectively to those already in the UK under the scheme. This decision ensured that affected individuals could continue to apply for indefinite leave to remain under the original terms of their entry.

The case was significant because it upheld the principle of legitimate expectation and fairness in immigration policy, ensuring that changes to immigration rules should not disadvantage those who had already made life-changing decisions based on the existing framework. It highlighted the importance of transparency and consistency in the application of immigration rules.

Should the current Government decide to go ahead with the proposed retrospective application of the 10-year route to those currently on the 5-year route, I strongly suspect there will be a U-turn once the Courts apply this 2008 judgment. 

UK immigration law is constantly changing. It is important to take timely legal advice to reduce the risk of friction at the border and to ensure compliance with the UK immigration rules. If you have immigration questions, please contact Paul McCarthy. 

We need a system that offers people a clear, affordable and compassionate pathway to settlement

Our thinking

  • Getting The Most From Your People

    Megan Paul

    Events

    min read
  • London Arbitration Week: ‘Building Data Centres Without Building Disputes’

    Gareth Mills

    Events

    min read
  • Construction Market Update: Looking Forward

    Michael O'Connor

    Events

  • Should You Even Bother? Making the Case for Bringing a Case

    Caroline Greenwell

    Events

    min read
  • Britain wants nuclear: Can we build it at pace?

    Kevin Gibbs

    Events

    min read
  • After the Confetti: Why the Real Work Begins the Day After Listing

    Greg Stonefield

    Insights

    min read
  • Investors’ Chronicle quotes Tamasin Perkins on how to avoid invalidating a will

    Tamasin Perkins

    In the Press

    min read
  • Ready for 2027: Legal Developments Shaping the Living Sector in England

    Mark White

    Insights

    min read
  • Q&A: Right to manage: can a landlord object on procedural grounds?

    Lauren Fraser

    Insights

    min read
  • Investing in London Real Estate Seminar

    Chiara Del Frate

    Events

    min read
  • Beds, Meds and Sheds: the beds haven’t gone – they’ve moved into houses

    Mark White

    Insights

    min read
  • Charles Russell Speechlys advises longstanding client SaxaVord Spaceport on its £30m investment from the UK government

    Charlie Ring

    News

    min read
  • Q&A: Recovering a freehold

    Sylwia Barchus

    Insights

    min read
  • The Swiss Lump Sum Tax Series: Part 4 - The Dos and Don’ts as a Swiss Lump Sum Taxpayer

    Frédéric Ney

    Insights

    min read
  • Evidencing oral agreements: the weight of words

    Ben Moore

    Insights

    min read
  • Budget 2026: what the energy measures mean for generators, industry and investors

    Kevin Gibbs

    Insights

    min read
  • Nicola Saccardo comments on Italy’s proposed exit tax regime for wealthy individuals in The Daily Telegraph

    Nicola Saccardo

    In the Press

    min read
  • Loss of bargain on contract cancellation: no repudiatory breach required

    Mary Barrett-Jones

    Insights

    min read
  • ICLG quotes Dewdney William Drew on the High Court’s PINK trade mark ruling

    Dewdney William Drew

    In the Press

    min read
  • Amy Shuttleworth and Nicholas Wyatt write in RICS Property Journal about electric vehicle charging point leases

    Amy Shuttleworth

    In the Press

    min read
Back to top