• Sectors we work in banner(2)

    Quick Reads

Nowhere to go – Recent High Court case highlights roadblock to overcoming director deadlock

In the recent case of Rushbrooke UK Ltd v Designs Concept Ltd [2022] EWHC 1110 (Ch) Judge Paul Matthews held that a director (Director A, being one of two de jure directors) had no authority to instruct a firm of solicitors to act on behalf of a company in circumstances where the other director (Director B) did not consent to their appointment.

The case concerned an application made by Rushbrooke UK Ltd (Rushbrooke) for an injunction to restrain the presentation of a winding-up petition by the respondent company following service of a statutory demand. The application was brought in the name of Rushbrooke following instructions given by Director A to a firm of solicitors. Director B did not consent to the appointment of the solicitors; indeed, Directors A and B were in deadlock and Director B gave evidence in support of the winding-up petition. The question before the Court was whether Director A alone had authority to instruct solicitors on behalf of Rushbrooke.

The Judge held that Rushbrooke could only act by its directors in accordance with its articles of association which did not, in this case, permit such action to be taken by one director acting alone. The application was therefore struck out. The Judge did comment that in certain circumstances a company’s articles may allow for authority to be delegated to a managing director however this did not apply to the current case and, as such, Director A had no authority to give instructions nor make the application in Rushbrooke’s name.

Though the decision is unsurprising, it helpfully exposes the weaknesses in articles of association that make little or no provision for deadlock scenarios. In this case, the deadlock exposed Rushbrooke to legal action which it was unable to defend. 

Whilst this case focuses on an injunction to restrain a winding-up petition, the factual scenario is familiar to those in the restructuring space where board and shareholder deadlock is common. Insolvency practitioners instructed to act on behalf of a company must therefore satisfy themselves that the director(s) has the ability to give instructions on behalf of the company. Checking the company’s articles of association is critical and taking independent advice is recommended if in any doubt.

Our thinking

  • An introduction to the new Procurement Act 2023

    Jamie Cartwright

    Quick Reads

  • Mind the Gap Trade Mark

    Charlotte Duly

    Insights

  • A Closer Look at the Meaning of ‘Investor’ in Investment Treaty Arbitration

    Stephen Chan

    Insights

  • Shareholder Strategies: A practical guide to unfair prejudice petitions

    Emilie Brammer

    Insights

  • New food and drink ads regulation & impact on live sports broadcasts

    Sarah Johnson

    Insights

  • AML in decentralized finance and traditional finance

    Caroline Greenwell

    Insights

  • International Arbitration: 2024 in Review

    Thomas R. Snider

    Insights

  • Has the UAE recognised the principle of Without Prejudice Privilege?

    Maher Al Nashar

    Quick Reads

  • Appointment of company directors – who can do it and how?

    Stephen Burns

    Insights

  • Understanding Contempt of Court in Swiss Law: Key Provisions and Penalties

    Remo Wagner

    Insights

  • Howells v Newport City Council: beware not to lose the private key to your cryptocurrency wallet

    Sonia Kenawy

    Insights

  • Combatting Lookalikes Revisited - clouds lift for brand owners as Thatchers wins its appeal over Aldi copycat cider

    Mary Bagnall

    Insights

  • The Law Society Gazette quotes Mary Bagnall on Aldi’s infringement of Thatchers’ trademark

    Mary Bagnall

    In the Press

  • Justice for the Victims of Britain's Largest Ponzi Scheme?

    Caroline Greenwell

    Quick Reads

  • Understanding Civil and Criminal Remedies in France for Financial Crimes

    Frédéric Jeannin

    Insights

  • The Property (Digital Assets etc) Bill: A Wider Category of Assets for the Insolvent Estate?

    Cassidy Fan

    Insights

  • Why Man City took ‘Super “Dry”’ off its Training Kit

    Nick White

    Quick Reads

  • Abu Dhabi Global Market introduces new employment regulations in the financial free zone

    Peter Smith

    Quick Reads

  • Promoting certainty in international trade and investment: The 2005 Hague Convention and the enforcement of foreign judgments in the UK and Switzerland

    Michael Wells-Greco

    Insights

  • DIFC Courts reassert their jurisdiction to issue worldwide freezing orders in support of foreign proceedings

    Jinan Jawad

    Quick Reads

Back to top