• Sectors we work in banner(2)

    Quick Reads

A Cautionary Tale of a Brush Too Broad

min read

In a time where there seems to be a constant search for good news, we were delighted this week to be able to deliver a genuine good news outcome for our client, wagamama; a result which freed them from a scheme in Eastbourne, East Sussex and saved them from incurring substantial sums at a time that is particularly difficult for the casual dining sector.

Before the age of social distancing, Performance Retail as freehold owner of a shopping centre (“the Landlord”) entered into a conditional Agreement for Lease (“the AFL”) with wagamama in 2015. As is usual, the AFL was to become unconditional upon the occurrence of the satisfaction date, in this case being the date upon which the relevant conditions were satisfied or waived in accordance with the various schedules. The schedules made provision for various conditions to be satisfied by notification to wagamama of (a) certain information; (b) performance of the conditions and/or (c) waiver of the conditions.

When wagamama received a letter in late 2016 (“the Notice”) purporting that the AFL had become unconditional, we were instructed to ascertain whether this was the case, and whether the notice in fact had the effect intended by the Landlord. Our view in brief was that the letter:

  1. did not comply with the terms of the AFL given that it did not communicate the requisite information to wagamama; and
  2. that therefore the AFL had not become unconditional; and
  3. wagamama was entitled to – and did - terminate the agreement.

On that basis, we served notice on behalf of wagamama terminating the AFL in June 2017 (“the Termination Notice”).

The Landlord then issued proceedings in late 2017 seeking (amongst other things) a declaration that the AFL had become unconditional by virtue of the Notice and that the Termination Notice was therefore invalid, which culminated in a High Court Trial before His Honour Judge Kramer.

The case ultimately turned upon the construction of the provisions of the AFL and upon the circumstances upon which it would become unconditional.

On a proper construction, the Judge held that the AFL requires that for the notice to be valid it must be a notice which relays the requisite information and specifies the way in which the conditions are being fulfilled, that is by way of waiver or by way of performance (where applicable). On that basis, the Notice was clearly inadequate and did not fulfil the purpose required. Consequentially, and in line with our view, wagamama successfully terminated the AFL and the declarations sought by the Landlord were refused.

As is ever the case, a broad-brush approach to the drafting of notices should not be the default position, and consideration must be had to indispensable requirements. If the satisfaction of a condition within a contract is subject to the notification of (a) information; (b) performance of a condition and/or (c) waiver of a condition, the notice given must communicate such information, in the absence of which a landlord may be left open to the risk that a tenant is able to terminate the agreement.

Our team were led by real estate disputes specialists David Haines and Richard Flenley and they instructed Leading Counsel, Christopher Heather QC of Tanfield Chambers.

Our thinking

  • London Arbitration Week: ‘Building Data Centres Without Building Disputes’

    Gareth Mills

    Events

    min read
  • Should You Even Bother? Making the Case for Bringing a Case

    Caroline Greenwell

    Events

    min read
  • CC/Devas v India: English Court of Appeal confirms that ratification of the New York Convention does not amount to a waiver of state immunity

    Thomas R. Snider

    Insights

    min read
  • Electronic evidence under European Union law

    Pierre Bydzovsky

    Insights

    min read
  • Can the SRA demand privileged documents?

    Alex Legard

    Insights

    min read
  • One-Sided, Still Binding: London Court Upholds Unilateral Arbitration Clause

    William Payne

    Insights

    min read
  • Too many Chiefs

    Dewdney William Drew

    Insights

    min read
  • Emergency Financial Crisis (EFC)

    Nicola Jackson

    Insights

    min read
  • Charles Russell Speechlys recognised in Spear’s Legal Indices 2026

    Bart Peerless

    News

    min read
  • Swiss Federal Supreme Court: No Right to Challenge the Central Authority’s Decision on Service under the Hague Service Convention

    Michael Wells-Greco

    Insights

    min read
  • Martyn’s Law updates – Don't Assume It's Someone Else's Job: Principal Use and SIA Notification

    Ben Butterworth

    Insights

    min read
  • Zurich to Launch an International Commercial Court with English-Language Proceedings

    Simon Hofstetter

    Insights

    min read
  • Darren Bailey comments on Royal Antwerp ruling in City AM

    Darren Bailey

    In the Press

    min read
  • The Crossover Between Trusts And Family Law

    Sarah Higgins

    Insights

    min read
  • All Can Be Fair In Love And War

    Emily Borrowdale

    Insights

    min read
  • Cryptocurrency fraud: the UK perspective – a pragmatic and flexible approach

    Sophia Iddon

    Insights

    min read
  • Georgina Muskett and Grace O’Leary write in Estates Gazette on restrictive covenants and obsolescence

    Georgina Muskett

    In the Press

    min read
  • Benoît Pasquier comments on athlete data and sports law in Legalcommunity.ch

    Benoît Pasquier

    In the Press

    min read
  • LCIA Publishes 2025 Case Statistics – What They Show

    Katy Ackroyd

    Insights

    min read
  • That’s what no one said: DIFC Court annuls award based on unpleaded findings

    Aishwarya Nair

    Insights

    min read
Back to top