• Sectors we work in banner(2)

    Quick Reads

Another furnished holiday lettings case is lost by the taxpayer...

STEP have reported the loss of another furnished holiday lettings (FHL) case by the taxpayer (Cox (Executors) v HMRC 2020 UKFTT 442 TC). It seems that unless you really do have nigh-on an hotel, as in the Graham case ((2018 UKFTT 306 TC), HMRC and the Courts will deny you Business Property Relief (BPR) on your FHL, even where you have a very high level of service.

Time and again we see clients hoping that their FHL will attract BPR, despite the run of cases saying "no" (with the notable exception of the Graham case).  This is particularly frustrating for those with just one or two FHL's, although there is some logic in HMRC's approach, ie they do not wish to see a whole new IHT-free asset class developed.

Those clients who operate FHL's as part of a farm or Landed Estate should, of course, remember that BPR can be achieved where the FHL's are part of the single overall trading undertaking, per the Balfour case.  Care, of course, needs to be taken not to over-cook such planning, particularly in light of a possible change to BPR such that undertakings need to be 'substantively' trading (ie over 80%) rather than 'wholly or mainly' trading (ie over 50%), as is the case currently.

The Office of Tax Simplification's report on IHT published last year suggested aligning the IHT treatment of FHL with Income Tax and Capital Gains Tax, which would allow for BPR to apply to them.  Given the recent Cox case, HMRC are evidently resisting such a suggestion!     

Our thinking

  • What You Need to Know About International Family Law

    William Longrigg

    Events

  • Rivals: Filming Locations and Considerations for Landed Estates

    Naomi Nettleton

    Insights

  • New food and drink ads regulation & impact on live sports broadcasts

    Sarah Johnson

    Insights

  • The Financial Times quotes Sangna Chauhan on the impact of the abolition of UK non-dom status on her workload

    Sangna Chauhan

    In the Press

  • Charles Russell Speechlys advises Puma Growth Partners on its lead investment as part of a $4.3 million funding round for finance-focused legal AI specialist, Semeris

    David Coates

    News

  • A Digital Pound: The Bank of England January 2025 Update

    Racheal Muldoon

    Insights

  • VAT Zero-rating: Dwellings or RRP – which is best for student accommodation?

    Elizabeth Hughes

    Insights

  • Navigating the Future: Key trends for Creative and Digital Agencies in 2025

    Rebecca Steer

    Quick Reads

  • Government consultation on implementation of the DMCC Act’s subscription contracts regime

    Dillon Ravikumar

    Insights

  • Charles Russell Speechlys finds that over half of Gen Z say the Bank of Mum and Dad comes with strings attached

    Sally Ashford

    News

  • The Financial Times reports on our independent survey of Gen Z adults and quotes Sally Ashford on the influence of the Bank of Mum and Dad and potential strings attached

    Sally Ashford

    In the Press

  • Charles Russell Speechlys bolsters Real Estate and Construction offering with Senior Consultant hire

    Kevin Gibbs

    News

  • Consultation on further changes to compulsory purchase process and compensation: making compulsory acquisition easier

    Claire Fallows

    Insights

  • Revised NPPF – the Green Belt, Grey Belt and the Golden Rules

    Titilope Hassan

    Quick Reads

  • Key Planning Decisions in 2024

    Sophie Willis

    Insights

  • The Independent quotes Dominic Lawrance on the ‘watering down’ of Labour’s non-dom tax reforms

    Dominic Lawrance

    In the Press

  • MiCA: The Fundamentals

    Racheal Muldoon

    Insights

  • Howells v Newport City Council: beware not to lose the private key to your cryptocurrency wallet

    Sonia Kenawy

    Insights

  • Briony Richards writes for People Management on navigating pre-termination negotiations

    Briony Richards

    In the Press

  • Jenny from (her agreed share of) the Block: Jennifer Lopez and Ben Affleck’s mediation settlement

    Sarah Anticoni

    Quick Reads

Back to top