• Sectors we work in banner(2)

    Quick Reads

Grave risk of harm: child abduction case law in the time of Covid

min read

In an interesting case from earlier this year, when the country was in the grips of a full national lockdown, the High Court wrestled with a difficult question of international law: would the health risks posed by the ongoing pandemic put a child at grave risk of physical harm were they to be returned to Spain from England following a wrongful removal of the child from Spain by her mother?

The factual background of the case is as follows: the child, PT, is 12 years old. She is a Spanish national, along with both of her parents who had separated in 2009. Both now have children with new partners. PT had spent all of her life living in Spain until February 2020, when she was brought to England by her mother. Her father said the move was without his knowledge or consent: he asked for PT to be returned, and the mother refused. The father therefore brought court proceedings.

The law governing such situations can be found in the Convention on Civil Aspects of International Child Abduction 1980 (the “Hague Convention 1980”), which exists to secure the prompt return of children wrongfully removed to or retained in states which contract to the convention. Such states include the UK and Spain. In this case, the judge found PT had been wrongfully removed from Spain to England. Once that had been determined, the judge moved to consider the limited exceptions to an order for immediate return. Article 13(b) of the Hague Convention 1980 provides that the child should not be returned if it is established “there is a grave risk that his or her return would expose the child to physical or psychological harm or otherwise place the child in an intolerable situation”. This is known as the ‘grave risk of harm’ exemption.

The mother argued that a return to Spain would subject the child to ‘grave risk’ which, in effect, asked the judge to make a comparison between the provisions to suppress the pandemic in Spain as against England: an unenviable position for the judge. The defence was rejected and the judge ordered PT be returned to Spain immediately. The relevant paragraphs of his judgment are 46, 47 and 48, and a quote which summarises his finding on this particular issue is at the foot of this article. Put very simply, the judge was not in a position to conclude that one country was safer than the other.

Were the same defence to be used now in a child abduction case, it seems likely it would be similarly unsuccessful. As the world moves through the pandemic, however, vaccines become available and preventative measures more effective (it is hoped), discrepancies may develop between the prevalence and impact of the virus in different countries. As each case will turn on the facts, it cannot be said with any confidence that the ‘grave risk of harm’ defence based on Covid-19 will remain ineffective in the future. Another view of this case could also be considered: did the court wish to prevent a wrongfully removing mother benefiting from this global health crisis? The longer this pandemic lasts, the more chance there is of this line of case law developing. It will be interesting to see how the courts grapple with the issue going forward.


“Although the course of the pandemic is clearly more advanced in Spain than in the UK, I do not have any evidence from which I can draw a conclusion that either country is any more or less safe than the other. It is clear that the pandemic is a serious public health emergency in both nations and that the number of cases in the UK is expected to continue to rise in the coming weeks. Both countries have imposed significant restrictions on their citizens in an effort to contain the pandemic. I am simply not in a possession to make any findings as to the relative likelihood of contracting the virus in each country. On the material before me, all that I can conclude is that there is a genuine risk that PT could contract the virus whether she remains in England or returns to Spain.” Re PT [2020] EWHC 834 (Fam)

Our thinking

  • Charles Russell Speechlys wins Private Wealth Team of the Year at the Law Middle East Awards 2026

    Patrick Gearon FCIArb

    News

    min read
  • After the Confetti: Why the Real Work Begins the Day After Listing

    Greg Stonefield

    Insights

    min read
  • Investors’ Chronicle quotes Tamasin Perkins on how to avoid invalidating a will

    Tamasin Perkins

    In the Press

    min read
  • US tax changes for 2027: what internationally mobile families need to know

    Alistair Christopher

    Insights

    min read
  • From Financial Centres to wealth Corridors: How international families organise their wealth

    Yacine Diallo

    Insights

    min read
  • The Swiss Lump Sum Tax Series: Part 4 - The Dos and Don’ts as a Swiss Lump Sum Taxpayer

    Frédéric Ney

    Insights

    min read
  • Cristiana Felisi and Giulia Sommaruga write for We Wealth on moving to Italy as an international family

    Maria Cristiana Felisi

    In the Press

    min read
  • Budget 2026: what the energy measures mean for generators, industry and investors

    Kevin Gibbs

    Insights

    min read
  • Nicola Saccardo comments on Italy’s proposed exit tax regime for wealthy individuals in The Daily Telegraph

    Nicola Saccardo

    In the Press

    min read
  • Phillip Colasanto elected Fellow of the American College of Tax Counsel

    Phillip Colasanto

    News

    min read
  • Nicola Thorpe is featured in the latest Law UK Power List, and comments on family offices, private capital, and the importance of relationship building

    Nicola Thorpe

    In the Press

    min read
  • High Value Council Tax Surcharge: what the Government’s Budget Day response and subsequent first draft Finance Bill tells us

    Katie Talbot

    Insights

    min read
  • One-Sided, Still Binding: London Court Upholds Unilateral Arbitration Clause

    William Payne

    Insights

    min read
  • Building a practice on the ground in Africa

    Jonathan Burt

    Insights

    min read
  • Judgement Needs a Map: What Nomads and Sponsors Need to Know About Advising Family and Trust-Held Issuers

    Greg Stonefield

    Insights

    min read
  • UK Budget 2026: What does the Budget mean for US taxpayers?

    Sangna Chauhan

    Insights

    min read
  • Budget 2026 Founders' Relief: a detailed review

    Robert Birchall

    Insights

    min read
  • Budget 2026 – Changes to Tax-Advantaged Share Schemes

    Robert Birchall

    Insights

    min read
  • Bloomberg quotes Piers Master on reaction to UK Autumn Budget

    Piers Master

    In the Press

    min read
  • Harriet Betteridge and Henry Fea contribute their post-Budget reactions to Professional Adviser and Professional Pensions

    Harriet Betteridge

    In the Press

    min read
Back to top