Too many Chiefs
min readIs the difference between Rugby Union and Rugby League enough to prevent trade mark confusion?
The Dispute
A trade mark dispute between New Zealand Rugby Union Incorporated, owner of the CHIEFS mark used by the Hamilton-based rugby union team, and the Australian Rugby League Commission, which is behind the nascent Papua New Guinea rugby league team PNG CHIEFS, came to a head on 16 October 2026. The New Zealand High Court refused an interim injunction aimed at preventing the launch of the new PNG CHIEFS logo and jersey.
How we got here
New Zealand Rugby Union Incorporated (“NZRU”) owns the Intellectual Property (“IP”) for the union team and the Australian Rugby League Commission Limited (“ARLC”) owns the IP for the new league team in Papua New Guinea.
The first skirmish arose when NZRU noticed ARLC’s trade mark application for PNG CHIEFS in Australia, and swiftly filed their own application for CHIEFS, followed by a lawyer’s letter. Subsequent correspondence did not result in a resolution.
Neither side was backing down and the flashpoint came when ARLC announced a team logo and jersey launch in Papua New Guinea, set for 21 October 2026. NZRU applied for an interim injunction in the High Court of New Zealand, aimed at stopping the launch.
Why the injunction failed
Delay is a well-known risk factor in interim injunction applications generally, and this proved to be a weakness here too:
“… having reviewed the correspondence between NZRU and ARLC, it seems clear to me that the ARLC was never going to back down and change the name of its new team in response to the NZRU’s concerns. Thus it is apparent that NZRU could have moved significantly earlier than it did. Accordingly, I take into account the lateness of the NZRU’s application as a factor that does not support an injunction”
The fact that the launch was in Papua New Guinea and not New Zealand also played a role. (“this Court cannot prevent the launch in a different jurisdiction”) and ARLC’s willingness to geo-block Internet access to parts of www.nrl.com, Facebook and the NRL app, was viewed as mitigating infringement risk in New Zealand.
Will anyone actually be confused?
However, the judge went further and expressed some views on the likelihood of confusion:
“But I have considerable doubts whether CHIEFS fans will accidently be buying PNG Chiefs rugby league jerseys, or that potential sponsors of the PNG Chiefs will be uncertain about who they are dealing with”
This is a sentiment that will no doubt resonate with both Rugby Union and Rugby League fans alike. Is this enough to prevent trade mark confusion in a legal sense though?
A different game at the Registry
Forums matter. Disputes around usage (in the courts) are different to disputes as to registration (at the trade mark registry). The former can take into account a variety of real-world factors that work to reduce a likelihood of confusion; the latter are more of a notional exercise, comparing trade mark applications and earlier trade mark registrations, as they appear on the register. In the UK Intellectual Property Office case of BADRHINO (O-390-16), clothing limited to rugby was found to be similar to clothing more broadly. NZRU may therefore have a stronger case when it comes to opposing an ARLC trade mark application for PNG CHIEFS, at least as far as merchandise is concerned.
Beyond the fan base
Fans are not the only customers. For example, someone who is not a fan might seek to purchase a gift for a friend or relative. They might quite easily be confused by a “rugby team” with the same name. In BADRHINO, the average consumer was held to be a member of the general public, a wider category than fans and sponsors.
‘Quins and Broncos
There is a precedent for a rugby union brand lending its name to rugby league. In 2005, the well known rugby union club Harlequins allowed rugby league team London Broncos, to use the name HARLEQUINS RL from 2006 to 2011. This included usage of the famous ‘Quins quartered shirt and playing home games at Harlequins’ Twickenham Stoop. At the time, this was hailed as “another proactive step in the evolution of the Harlequin brand and club” (Quins and Broncos announce partnership - ESPN). Harlequins is indeed a global rugby brand, with an affiliate network across many countries. Differences in rules and geography may not be as significant as ARLC might be hoping. NZRU could potentially point to the Harlequins example to claim that the general public (potentially including sports fans) might very well assume a connection between similarly named union and league clubs.
Looking ahead
The declining of the interim injunction is not the end of the story however. A full trial is still to follow, probably in early 2027, where the question of trade mark infringement will be considered in greater depth, as well as a further chance for an injunction. There is also the potential for opposition proceedings at the Australian trade marks office, although NZRU’s earlier registered mark is a logo, which complicates things.
While the League team may have won the initial encounter, the longer game may favour the Union side.