• news-banner

    Expert Insights

Court of Appeal leaves rights of light in the dark

In October 2019 Beaumont Business Centres Limited v Florala Properties Limited came before the High Court and his honour Mr Peter Knox QC delivered his judgment some five months later, days before the first lockdown, signalling a significant shift in the approach of the courts to rights of light cases.

The Court considered Beaumont’s claim for an injunction – or damages in the alternative – against Florala in nuisance for the wrongful interference with its right of light. The claim arose as a result of Florala building an extension into a lightwell which it owned, and which adjoined Beaumont’s property, and increasing the height of one of the elevations overlooking the lightwell.

It is important to say the levels of light loss were at the lower end of the spectrum and Florala argued that Beaumont didn’t even enjoy any legal right to light over the development.  This felt like a case that could have been settled and the judgment revealed that that the parties got very close to reaching one.  However, the discussions broke down and the case went to court resulting in an injunction ordering Florala to pull down part of the development it had completed almost two years earlier. All of this was made even more noteworthy by Beaumont’s decision not to seek an interim injunction.  It had been previously thought that the failure to seek an interim injunction would weigh against the affected party but Mr Peter Knox QC didn’t see it that way.  His judgment covered all of the essential elements of any rights of light dispute and cast doubt on the accepted practice in each of them.

This was the first major rights of light decision to impose an injunction requiring demolition of part of a building since the ruling of the Supreme Court in Coventry v Lawrence.   As a result practitioners were holding their breath and hoping that the High Court might shed some much needed light on an area of law that is shrouded in darkness. Many will recall that prior to Coventry v Lawrence an injunction would be awarded for a breach of a neighbouring owner’s right to light in all but the most exceptional cases. The Supreme Court Justices in Coventry v Lawrence undertook a review of the case law and concluded that the past tendency towards injunctions had resulted from an overly rigid approach. Not everyone agreed and much debate has followed but the indication was that injunctions would be less likely in the future.  Unfortunately the Supreme Court failed to provide clear guidance as to how the courts should approach the question and it was for that reason this decision was seen as a much needed opportunity for guidance to be provided.

Many were surprised that an injunction was granted and it seemed inevitable that an appeal would follow.  Therefore, when permission to appeal was refused by the Court of Appeal earlier this year, those involved with rights of light were left disappointed to say the least.  For practitioners and developers alike, the ongoing uncertainty is far from ideal. Some will recall the Law Commission’s report on Rights to Light at the end of 2014 which included, amongst other things, a recommendation that a statutory test be established to clarify when courts may order damages to be paid rather than halting development or ordering demolition. Such certainty would completely shift the face of rights to light law and provide a framework around which developers could work in order to mitigate the injunction risk.  Unfortunately there is no sign of any legislation coming forward and so it is left with the courts to develop the law in this area.  With the Court of Appeal showing no interest in the Beaumont case we are left waiting for another case in the hope that it will shed some much needed light.

For more information on the above please contact Lauren Spark or your usual Charles Russell Speechlys contact.

Our thinking

  • Mental Health Management

    Nick Hurley

    Events

  • Calculating Social Value in BTR

    Francis Ho

    Events

  • Dangers of trusts

    Mark Summers

    Events

  • China Daily, and other titles, quote Silvia On on trends affecting Chinese HNWIs

    Silvia On

    In the Press

  • The Evening Standard quotes Rose Carey on the increase in visa fees

    Rose Carey

    In the Press

  • Charles Russell Speechlys advises Zenzero’s management team on its majority acquisition by Macquarie Capital

    Mark Howard

    News

  • What next for HS2?

    Richard Flenley

    Quick Reads

  • Updates and points to note in relation to buy-to-let residential properties

    Twiggy Ho

    Insights

  • Felicity Chapman writes for Insider Media on alternatives to court for divorcing business owners

    Felicity Chapman

    In the Press

  • Investment Week quotes Julia Cox on the proposed scrapping of inheritance tax

    Julia Cox

    In the Press

  • Charles Russell Speechlys expands commercial offering with the appointment of Rebecca Steer

    Rebecca Steer

    News

  • The Times quotes Gareth Mills on the CMA’s preliminary approval of the Activision Blizzard-Microsoft deal

    Gareth Mills

    In the Press

  • Heritage property and conditional exemption

    Sarah Wray

    Insights

  • The Financial Times quotes Emma Humphreys on UK rental costs

    Emma Humphreys

    In the Press

  • Stamp Duty Refund - New Impetus To Eligible Incoming Talents

    Ian Devereux

    Insights

  • City AM quotes Gareth Mills on the CMA’s new set of principles for regulating AI

    Gareth Mills

    In the Press

  • Hamish Perry and Mike Barrington write for The Evening Standard on whether a merger between the CBI and Make UK can work

    Hamish Perry

    In the Press

  • Silicon quotes Gareth Mills on the UK consumer lawsuit against Google

    Gareth Mills

    In the Press

  • Government Press Pause on the Renters (Reform) Bill

    Helena Taynton

    Quick Reads

  • First Remediation Order made by the Tribunal under the Building Safety Act 2022

    Bella Stuart-Bourne

    Quick Reads

  • Property Week quotes Louise Ward on the additional support required by aspiring UK life sciences operators

    Louise Ward

    In the Press

  • Sarah Higgins and David Wells-Cole write for Wealth Briefing on the pitfalls of using unregulated legal services

    Sarah Higgins

    In the Press

  • Office to Lab Conversions: A new lease of life (sciences) for some of London’s offices?

    Georgina Muskett

    Quick Reads

  • Charles Russell Speechlys’ UK offices receive environmental certification

    Kerry Stares

    News

  • Assured Shorthold Tenancies and Section 21 Notices: Should Landlords Return Tenancy Deposits by Cheque?

    Helena Taynton

    Quick Reads

  • The Family Fund: Bank of Mum & Dad 2.0

    Vanessa Duff

    Quick Reads

  • The perpetual struggle between the environment, heritage and development: the M&S decision vs 55 Bishopsgate

    Sophie Willis

    Quick Reads

  • Treasury Committee endorses mandatory venture capital diversity policies from 2025

    Lia Renna

    Quick Reads

  • MEES Update: Offices Missing the Mark

    Ben Butterworth

    Quick Reads

  • Oops!....I did it again - Britney's third divorce

    Charlotte Posnansky

    Quick Reads

  • Gove's announcement: two staircases for new high rise residential buildings over 18 metres

    Melanie Hardingham

    Quick Reads

  • Leasehold and commonhold reform: what is the latest?

    Laura Bushaway

    Quick Reads

  • The Government has announced the introduction of the “Cladding Safety Scheme”

    Lauren Kelly

    Quick Reads

  • Recognising financial abuse in a relationship

    Vanessa Duff

    Quick Reads

  • A new consultation on freight and logistics

    Sadie Pitman

    Quick Reads

  • Temperate Rainforests - A Naturally Biodiverse Habitat in the UK

    Titilope Hassan

    Quick Reads

  • Making BitCoin a BitClearer

    Charlotte Posnansky

    Quick Reads

  • Key takeaways from the UK Government's "Green Day"

    Martha Glaser

    Quick Reads

  • From Holby City to 5 Fleet Place - David Ames shares his experience of "Behind the Lens" with CRS

    Quick Reads

  • The Domestic Abuse Act 2021 in Action

    Sophia Leeder

    Quick Reads

Back to top