Swiss Federal Supreme Court: No Right to Challenge the Central Authority’s Decision on Service under the Hague Service Convention
min readIn brief
The Swiss Federal Supreme Court has held that the parties to foreign proceedings, including the person on whom documents are to be served, have no right to challenge a Swiss Central Authority’s decision to grant or refuse a request for service under the 1965 Hague Service Convention. They are not entitled to be heard in the judicial assistance proceedings, to be notified of the decision or to receive a reasoned, appealable decision. Any objection to service must instead be raised in the foreign main proceedings or, where relevant, in later recognition proceedings in Switzerland.
Background
The case arose from proceedings in the United Kingdom between a British company and a Swiss company based in Basel. A request to serve judicial documents on the Swiss company was sent under the Convention to the competent cantonal Central Authority, the Court of Appeal of Basel-City. The request was granted, the Civil Court of Basel-City served the documents and a certificate of service was returned to the UK.
The Swiss company challenged the service before both the Civil Court and the Court of Appeal, seeking a declaration of invalidity and a reasoned decision. It argued that the decision to execute the request had been neither notified to it nor reasoned, despite repeated requests, in breach of its right to be heard and its right of access to justice. Its applications were dismissed or returned without reasons, and it appealed to the Federal Supreme Court.
The decision
The Court first held that service itself, effected by way of judicial assistance, cannot be appealed: it is a mere factual act by which a legal act is transmitted.
The real question was whether the parties could take part in, and challenge, the Central Authority’s decision to permit service on Swiss territory. The Court had previously described such a challenge as “highly questionable” (4A_89/2025; 4A_527/2019) and doubted whether a sufficient legal interest existed (5A_305/2015). Swiss commentators, and German scholarship and case law, generally favour a remedy. The Court nonetheless reached the opposite conclusion, for four main reasons:
- The text of the 1965 Hague Service Convention: it says nothing about the validity of service or the consequences of breach, provides no remedy against the Central Authority’s decision and confers no right to an appealable decision.
- Limited protection of the recipient: the 1965 Hague Service Convention, notably through Articles 15 and 16, safeguards the rights of the defence by ensuring actual and timely notice. Those provisions bind the court of the requesting State, not the authorities of the requested State. Whether to waive sovereignty is a matter for the States alone; the parties are only indirectly affected.
- The 1965 Hague Service Convention’s purpose of expediting and simplifying service: the Central Authority’s review is confined to compliance with the Convention and whether assistance is manifestly inadmissible. Hearing the parties and allowing appeals in every case would cause considerable delay and ancillary litigation, potentially requiring further service abroad simply to obtain the claimant’s observations.
- Distinction from the 1970 Hague Evidence Convention: decisions on letters of request under that Convention are appealable because it grants the parties individual protective rights directly affected by the decision, and hearing them does not undermine its effectiveness.
The appeal was accordingly declared inadmissible.
Comment
The judgment settles a disputed question in favour of efficient judicial cooperation. The recipient loses any prior review of the regularity of judicial assistance in Switzerland, but this is consistent with the 1965 Hague Service Convention’s aim of informing the recipient promptly so that they can defend themselves abroad. A contrary ruling risked making Switzerland a “safe haven” for parties seeking to delay certain foreign proceedings.
Practical points for family practitioners
There are 84 Contracting State Parties to the 1965 Hague Service Convention. Although the case concerned commercial parties, the reasoning applies equally to service of divorce applications, financial remedy applications and other family proceedings on respondents in Switzerland:
- Applicants serving into Switzerland via the Central Authority route should not expect satellite challenges at the Swiss end to delay service.
- Respondents based in Switzerland cannot block or postpone service by challenging the Central Authority’s decision; objections must be taken before the court seised of the main proceedings, for example under Articles 15 and 16 of the 1965 Hague Service Convention, or later when recognition or enforcement is sought in Switzerland.
- The formal Central Authority route remains essential, and a defective approach may still be attacked at the recognition stage. The addressee can only challenge a defective service process within the proceedings on the merits or at the stage of enforcement.