• news-banner

    Expert Insights

Funding for Inheritance Act 1975 claims: Success (fee) or gamble?

For many individuals, pursuing litigation is an expensive and daunting process. The Court of Appeal’s recent judgment in Hirachand v Hirachand [2021] EWCA Civ 1498 highlights the issues that can arise when it comes to funding and recovery of costs in Inheritance Act 1975 disputes. While the case provides useful guidance it also leaves open many questions on recovery of costs.

Hirachand dealt with two grounds of appeal, the key ground for this article being whether the Judge at first instance had erred by including a lump sum payment in the overall award to the Respondent, by way of contribution to her liability for a CFA success fee. The Courts and Legal Services Act 1990 prevents a costs order from including provision for a success fee under a CFA. Practitioners have long advised pre Re: H (Deceased((2020) (the first instance decision from which Hirachand arises) that a success fee could not be included as part of the claim pursuant to the Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975. In Hirachand the Court of appeal by unanimous decision found the success fee could be capable of being classed as a debt by the claimant (para 58) resulting in a financial need “for which the court may in its discretion make provision” (my emphasis). Para 59 continued that it may not “always be appropriate” for such an award.

Hirachand should be viewed with caution by those advising clients on CFAs and success fee issues. It is by no means a guarantee of recovering part of the success fee. Serious considerations will need to go into what other funding may be available for the client. As with every client, other funding options may be more appropriate which should be explored.

Some firms offer legal funding through a panel of third-party specialists invited to tender for such work. Usually, these relate to higher value claims with a minimal likely value in recovery and so may not be suitable for lower value 1975 Act claims such as here. Clients could be offered a deferred fee to which interest is attached after a certain period. This may be attractive if they are already due to receive a share of the estate or have another source of funds that will be realised at a later date, but which is still less than they need for maintenance (if they are claiming other than as a spouse) and the interest may result in a lower additional sum than a success fee percentage. 

Does the client have BTE or could they obtain ATE insurance? BTE can be limited in availability for these types of claims and can also be limited in value. ATE usually requires the provision of Counsel’s opinion which the client will probably need to fund in the first instance.

DBAs or Damages Based Agreements are another more complex area of litigation funding and, given the stringent requirements surrounding them and the uncertain nature of 1975 Act claim outcomes, may be unattractive.

Ultimately funding is a decision for the client and the firm together, assessing the merits of the claim as known and the risks both are willing to take. Hirachand at paragraph 59 tells us however that the courts will view a CFA and attempts to recover a success fee as a last resort option with Lady Justice King stating an award would be unlikely “… unless the judge is satisfied that the only way in which the claimant had been able to litigate was by entering a CFA…”. This suggests that the client may have to be prepared to disclose evidence of the various funding options discussed, considered and discounted where the success fee is included as a debt and recovery sought as part of the claim from any award made from the estate.

As is often the case, the judgment ends with a salutary reminder that wherever possible, all attempts to settle such claims should be attempted!

Our thinking

  • A Labour government: what might be in store for personal taxation?

    Sarah Wray

    Quick Reads

  • Spears quotes Piers Master on the potential exodus of UHNW non-doms from the UK ahead of a potential Labour government

    Piers Master

    In the Press

  • Investment Week quotes Julia Cox on the proposed scrapping of inheritance tax

    Julia Cox

    In the Press

  • Heritage property and conditional exemption

    Sarah Wray

    Insights

  • Sarah Higgins and David Wells-Cole write for Wealth Briefing on the pitfalls of using unregulated legal services

    Sarah Higgins

    In the Press

  • 5 top tips to make estate administration easier for your executor

    Jessica Dawkins

    Quick Reads

  • First time buyers relief and trusts

    Sarah Wray

    Insights

  • Enforcement of Judgments

    Patrick Gearon FCIArb

    Insights

  • The Financial Times quotes Julia Cox on tax planning under a potential Labour government

    Julia Cox

    In the Press

  • The Times quotes Suzanne Marriott on the legal ramifications of stolen artefacts

    Suzanne Marriott

    In the Press

  • The Family Fund: Bank of Mum & Dad 2.0

    Vanessa Duff

    Quick Reads

  • The Financial Times quotes James Riby on London’s reputation as ‘divorce capital’ of the world

    James Riby

    In the Press

  • Inside Britney and Sam’s $10m prenup

    Shivi Rajput

    Quick Reads

  • The i quotes Katie Talbot on the merits of putting a life insurance policy into a trust

    Katie Talbot

    In the Press

  • Oops!....I did it again - Britney's third divorce

    Charlotte Posnansky

    Quick Reads

  • NSPCC urges Government to protect children from domestic abuse during holidays

    Shivi Rajput

    Quick Reads

  • A brief look at HMRC v A Taxpayer [2023] UKUT 00182 (TCC)

    Dominic Lawrance

    Quick Reads

  • An exceptionally harsh judgment? Exceptional circumstances revisited

    Dominic Lawrance

    Insights

  • Record success for Charles Russell Speechlys in Chambers High Net Worth 2023 directory

    Piers Master

    News

  • ATED and the farmhouse

    Sarah Wray

    Quick Reads

  • Recognising financial abuse in a relationship

    Vanessa Duff

    Quick Reads

  • eprivateclient quotes Sarah Higgins and David Wells-Cole on the CMA’s investigation into will-writing and quickie divorce legal services

    Sarah Higgins

    In the Press

  • Domestic abuse orders: worth the paper they’re written on?

    Lydia Hutchinson

    Insights

  • Parental responsibility as a form of coercive control

    Lydia Hutchinson

    Insights

  • Sally Ashford and Oliver Auld write for International Adviser on the role of a trustee in a family trust

    Sally Ashford

    In the Press

  • eprivateclient quotes Marcus Yorke-Long on on social media and family office

    Marcus Yorke-Long

    In the Press

  • Suzanne Marriott writes for The Times on predatory marriages

    Suzanne Marriott

    In the Press

  • Atonement and post separation endeavour: wife keeps £1m gift from husband after his affair and will receive a share of his business’ future profits

    Sophia Leeder

    Quick Reads

  • Pensions: change is in the air once again

    Sarah Wray

    Quick Reads

  • Pre-Settled Status to be automatically extended by two years

    Paul McCarthy

    Quick Reads

  • The Telegraph quotes William Marriott on hidden costs to consider when dealing with the death of a loved one

    William Marriott

    In the Press

  • Pandora Papers: HMRC nudge taxpayers to come out of their box

    Hugh Gunson

    Quick Reads

  • Update on Tax Reporting for Trustees of Trusts with Canadian Connections

    Francis I Rojas

    Insights

  • Making BitCoin a BitClearer

    Charlotte Posnansky

    Quick Reads

  • Can a financial claim in divorce proceed after the death of either party?

    Sarah Higgins

    Quick Reads

  • Second Time Weddings - Family Law (I) dos and don’ts

    Miranda Fisher

    Quick Reads

  • Delay could bar your probate claim

    Katelyn Silver

    Quick Reads

  • Saudi Center for Commercial Arbitration publishes new Arbitration Rules

    Peter Smith

    Quick Reads

  • UK Legacies for UK Charities?

    Verity Heath

    Quick Reads

  • The Budget’s pension changes: an opportunity for inheritance tax planning?

    Sarah Wray

    Quick Reads

Back to top