• news-banner

    Expert Insights

The Right to Work expansion – why employment status matters more than ever

min read

Introduction

From 1 October 2026, the government is making sweeping changes to one of the most familiar recruitment hurdles for HR professionals; the right to work regime. This article explores what is changing, why employers need to be confident of the employment status of any individuals they engage and what they can do to minimise risk.

What is the right to work regime?

Whether someone can legally work in the UK depends on their immigration status. All employers should be familiar with the requirement to check a prospective employee’s right to work before their employment begins, and to carry out repeat checks as necessary where the employee’s right to work is time-limited (eg before their UK work visa expires).

The right to work regime as we currently know it has been in place since 2008 and only applies where there is a direct employer and employee relationship. Other employment arrangements have traditionally been outside of the scope of the regime. The only caveat is that employers who hold a licence to sponsor migrant workers are also required to carry out checks on all their sponsored workers as part of their licence compliance obligations, irrespective of employment status.

What’s changing?

From 1 October 2026 the right to work regime will be significantly expanded in two ways:

  1. Employers will have to do right to work checks on all individuals they engage directly as employees, workers or individual sub-contractors. This means many more businesses will need to do checks on many more people. Online matching platforms will also have to do checks on individual service providers registered on their platform.
  2. Liability will also be extended beyond a direct contractual relationship with an individual worker in the following circumstances:
    • Contracting chains where there is subcontracting or outsourcing of delivery of services
    • Where a direct contract with a worker includes a substitution clause
    • Where an online matching platform matches a business with a customer and the business then contracts with that customer.

In all three of these scenarios, a business may be treated as the employer of any individual actually performing the work or services, even if it has not contracted with the individual directly. Note that this extended definition of ‘employer’ is for right to work purposes only, it does not create any other kind of employment relationship or affect any rights of the individual under employment law.

Why is employment status important?

Employment status is key because genuinely self-employed individuals are out of scope of the regime and employers will not need to carry out checks on them.

Whether someone is an employee or worker will determine many of their rights and obligations under employment law but for right to work purposes they will essentially be treated the same.

It’s worth noting here that, at least as far as employment law is concerned, there is not much difference between a ‘worker’ and an ‘individual sub-contractor’. The latter is a concept only used within the right to work regime, and under employment law would likely be classified as a type of worker. The term is probably specifically included in the right to work legislation because the expansion is particularly aimed at capturing the gig economy and more casual labour arrangements (although its application is much wider than that).

Worker or genuinely self-employed?

Self-employment has long been a slippery concept in law. For a start, there is no statutory definition of self-employment and the distinction between employees, workers and the genuinely self-employed has been developed over years through case law.  Courts look at a range of factors including personal service (whether the individual must perform the work themselves or whether they can send a substitute), the degree of control the engager exercises over the individual and whether there is mutuality of obligation (to offer and accept work).  No single factor is determinative and whether someone is truly self-employed will often be very fact specific. Cases such as Uber BV V Aslam and Pimlico Plumbers Ltd v Smith have shown that even sophisticated employers can get it wrong with the courts looking behind the label applied to a particular contract to find that those who are held out to be self-employed are in fact ‘workers’ with the statutory protections which go with that status.

It will be even more important now to pin down exactly who is self-employed and who is not, because the stakes are even higher. If illegal working is discovered the consequences are serious and can include civil penalties of up to £60,000 per illegal worker, criminal prosecution and imprisonment, loss of any sponsor licences, forced business closure and disqualification as a director, as well as reputational damage.

So how can an employer be sure that someone will be considered genuinely self-employed? Everything depends on the nature of the arrangements and how they work in practice, rather than the label the parties may put on it. So just because a contract states that an individual will be self-employed, it does not mean they will be.

Hallmarks of genuine self-employment include:

  • Operating in own name or through a personal service company
  • Getting work from multiple sources
  • Advertising services directly to customers or clients
  • Bearing any financial risk – if they can’t do the work, they don’t get paid

The Home Office’s key guidance document, Employer’s Guide to Right to Work checks, indicates that personal service companies (PSCs) are out of scope of the regime. So, if a business engages a contractor, consultant or freelancer through that individual’s PSC, and their services will be used for the business’ own benefit or for use in its own operations, then it is highly likely that the arrangement will be out of scope and right to works checks on the individual freelancer will not be necessary.

However, the situation is more uncertain if a business subcontracts with an individual through a PSC as part of a contracting chain. If the business is under a contractual obligation to provide work or services to a third party and outsources part of that to the PSC, the extended liability provisions relating to contracting chains may kick in.  If so, the business would need to have specific terms in its contract with the PSC which would effectively require the owner of the PSC to do a right to work check on themselves. This is a rather odd and artificial result and it is not yet clear if that’s something the Home Office intended. We expect this to be ironed out in due course as the new regime beds in, but in the meantime it may be best to err on the side of caution.

Substitution

One traditional hallmark of self-employment is the right to send a substitute to do the work. However, employers increasingly don’t like these clauses to be included in their freelancer or consultant contracts as they want personal service from the person they have chosen.

Substitution sits uneasily in the new right to work regime. Where there is a contract between an employer and a worker which contains a substitution clause, the employer must ensure they comply with prescribed ‘substitution controls’ in order to have a statutory defence against a civil penalty if a substitute turns out to be working illegally.

This is slightly odd given that substitution clauses are more commonly found in self-employment contracts, and genuine self-employment is outside the scope of the regime. The wording of the Home Office Code of Practice on preventing illegal working and the accompanying guidance implies that the need to comply with substitution controls would not arise in a contract between a business and someone genuinely self-employed. However, that is not explicitly confirmed anywhere.

It is fairly rare for worker contracts to include a substitution clause, although when one considers the gig economy type arrangements the regime is trying to encompass, the inclusion of this in the expanded regime may make more sense.

What do employers need to think about?

Employers need to look behind the labels on their contracts and consider how each arrangement will work in practice, especially where someone is stated to be self-employed. For example, will the person be expected to turn up at the same place at the same time every day to do work directed by the employer? Will they work for anyone else at the same time? Can they send a substitute? Is the contract with the individual directly or with a PSC?

Businesses could find themselves in an extremely risky and expensive situation if they contract with someone who is nominally self-employed when in fact the features of the arrangement suggest they are a worker, especially if the contract has a substitution clause. If that person is working illegally then not only has the business failed to do a right to work check on the individual, they will also have failed to comply with the prescribed requirements relating to any substitutes. This renders them both directly and indirectly liable under the new right to work regime.   

Tax considerations

Employers should also be aware of potential adverse tax consequences where an individual is engaged on a self-employed basis, often as a contractor, but is subsequently found not to be genuinely self-employed.

As noted above, the expanded powers under the new right to work regime for a business to be treated as an employer is limited to the purposes of that regime and does not extend to tax treatement. Accordingly, the fact that a business is treated as an employer under the right to work rules does not automatically make it an employer for tax purposes. It is worth noting that, unlike employment law, tax law does not recognise 'worker' as a separate status. Instead, where an individual is engaged directly (rather than through an intermediary, such as a personal service company), they will generally be treated as either employed by the engaging party or self-employed for tax purposes.

However, many of the factors considered when determining whether an individual is genuinely self-employed for employment law purposes, such as personal service, financial risk, substitution rights and the degree of control exercised over the individual, are also relevant when assessing employment status for tax purposes. Accordingly, a finding by the Home Office that an individual is not genuinely self-employed may increase the likelihood of HMRC scrutinising the arrangement and concluding that the individual should not be treated as self-employed for tax purposes either. 

If HMRC successfully asserts that an individual has been incorrectly treated as self-employed, the engaging business could face liabilities for unpaid PAYE income tax and National Insurance contributions, together with interest and potentially penalties. Therefore, when engaging individuals (whether directly or through an intermediary, such as a personal service company), businesses should take reasonable care to ensure that employment status has been correctly identified for tax purposes too and that all corresponding tax obligations have been complied with, noting in particular the additional compliance obligations for medium and large businesses engaging with intermediaries. 

Conclusion

If your business is going to contract with individuals on a self-employed basis, you need to be absolutely sure that they are genuinely self-employed. This has long been a thorny issue in employment law and the right to work changes have thrown it into sharp relief. Make sure you are aware of the complexities and always seek bespoke legal advice if needed.

Employers should also ensure that there is cross-business awareness of these changes. Right to work is no longer just a matter for HR teams and recruiters; legal, management, operations and procurement all need to be aware of which situations could expose the business to liability.

Our thinking

  • Getting The Most From Your People

    Megan Paul

    Events

    min read
  • London Arbitration Week: ‘Building Data Centres Without Building Disputes’

    Gareth Mills

    Events

    min read
  • Construction Market Update: Looking Forward

    Michael O'Connor

    Events

  • Should You Even Bother? Making the Case for Bringing a Case

    Caroline Greenwell

    Events

    min read
  • Britain wants nuclear: Can we build it at pace?

    Kevin Gibbs

    Events

    min read
  • After the Confetti: Why the Real Work Begins the Day After Listing

    Greg Stonefield

    Insights

    min read
  • Investors’ Chronicle quotes Tamasin Perkins on how to avoid invalidating a will

    Tamasin Perkins

    In the Press

    min read
  • Ready for 2027: Legal Developments Shaping the Living Sector in England

    Mark White

    Insights

    min read
  • Q&A: Right to manage: can a landlord object on procedural grounds?

    Lauren Fraser

    Insights

    min read
  • Investing in London Real Estate Seminar

    Chiara Del Frate

    Events

    min read
  • Beds, Meds and Sheds: the beds haven’t gone – they’ve moved into houses

    Mark White

    Insights

    min read
  • Charles Russell Speechlys advises longstanding client SaxaVord Spaceport on its £30m investment from the UK government

    Charlie Ring

    News

    min read
  • Q&A: Recovering a freehold

    Sylwia Barchus

    Insights

    min read
  • The Swiss Lump Sum Tax Series: Part 4 - The Dos and Don’ts as a Swiss Lump Sum Taxpayer

    Frédéric Ney

    Insights

    min read
  • Evidencing oral agreements: the weight of words

    Ben Moore

    Insights

    min read
  • Budget 2026: what the energy measures mean for generators, industry and investors

    Kevin Gibbs

    Insights

    min read
  • Nicola Saccardo comments on Italy’s proposed exit tax regime for wealthy individuals in The Daily Telegraph

    Nicola Saccardo

    In the Press

    min read
  • Loss of bargain on contract cancellation: no repudiatory breach required

    Mary Barrett-Jones

    Insights

    min read
  • ICLG quotes Dewdney William Drew on the High Court’s PINK trade mark ruling

    Dewdney William Drew

    In the Press

    min read
  • Amy Shuttleworth and Nicholas Wyatt write in RICS Property Journal about electric vehicle charging point leases

    Amy Shuttleworth

    In the Press

    min read
Back to top