• news-banner

    Expert Insights

The end of non-compete clauses and restrictive practices?

A non-compete clause bans an employee from joining a competitor or setting up a competing business for a certain period of time or within a specific geographical area, or both, on termination of the individual’s employment.  They are aimed at protecting the employer’s trade secrets and are often included in the employment contracts of senior executives who have access to highly confidential information.  In both the US and the UK non-compete clauses have been used for decades, although in the UK they are traditionally harder to enforce than other types of restrictive covenant.  However, there are now proposals in both countries to ban these clauses.  

Non-compete clauses in the US

The US Federal Trade Commission (FTC) is proposing to introduce a new rule that would ban non-compete clauses, the majority of which last more than two years.  It considers that these clauses hurt business innovation, harm competition and suppress wages.  In addition, these clauses have become commonplace among lower paid workers with approximately one in five American workers now bound by them.  The FTC is concerned because these workers, who don’t have access to confidential information, are unable to leave their jobs as they can’t afford to move or to wait before starting a new job.  The comment period is open to the public until 19 April 2023.

Is a ban something we’re likely to see in the UK? 

In December 2020, the UK Government launched a consultation on reforming non-compete clauses in employment contracts in order to maximise opportunities for individuals to start new businesses and find new work.      

The consultation sought views on two options:  to ban non-compete clauses altogether or to make them enforceable only where the employer provides compensation for the duration of the restriction.  In the latter case the consultation also sought views on the level of compensation, whether the employer should be required to disclose the terms of the non-compete clause before the employee started work and asked whether there should be a statutory limit on the duration of a non-compete clause. 

No poaching covenants

On 9 February 2023, the Competition & Markets Authority (CMA) published its guidance on avoiding business cartels being formed by, amongst other things, the use of no poaching agreements by businesses working with other businesses. The guidance identifies this practice as one of three areas of anti-competitive behaviour and avows to clamp down on this. Whilst the embargo only relates to businesses working with other businesses, it does seem to be an example of an incursion into the canon of law in restraint of trade. It will be interesting to see if there are more developments in this direction which go further.

Conclusion

Both the FTC and UK Government proposals and the CMA guidance are aimed at stimulating the economy post-covid by providing opportunities for entrepreneurs and competitive start-ups.      

The UK Government’s consultation closed on 26 February 2021 and over two years later the Government’s response is still awaited with no published timeframe.  In March 2022 an MP confirmed the Government is still analysing the responses.  Could there be a sea change in the established orthodoxy? Perhaps not, but we may well see more gradual erosion of some of the restrictive practices that are now no longer fashionable and in keeping with a Government keen to deregulate and free up the economy. 

Our thinking

  • France: Employment and Labour Law Comparative Guide

    Kim Campion

    Insights

  • Sex discrimination at work

    Michael Powner

    Insights

  • Charles Russell Speechlys grows its rankings in The Legal 500 EMEA directory

    Frédéric Jeannin

    News

  • Employment Podcast: Mental Health in the Workplace

    Anne-Marie Balfour

    Podcasts

  • Sara Wilson and Francesca Heath-Clarke write for People Management on new flexible working request rights

    Francesca Heath-Clarke

    In the Press

  • Race discrimination in the workplace

    Michael Powner

    Insights

  • Use of biometric data and monitoring in the employment context

    Sophie Rothwell

    Insights

  • Charles Russell Speechlys hosts international arbitration event in Dubai

    Peter Smith

    Quick Reads

  • The Daily Telegraph quotes Nick Hurley on the legalities of asking for childcare employment in lieu of rent

    Nick Hurley

    In the Press

  • Pregnancy and maternity discrimination in the workplace

    Michael Powner

    Insights

  • Syma Spanjers and Francesca Heath-Clarke write for People Management on tackling discrimination against young female workers

    Francesca Heath-Clarke

    In the Press

  • HR Magazine quotes Isobel Goodman on second jobs and HR obligations

    Isobel Goodman

    In the Press

  • The Daily Telegraph quotes Nick Hurley on the surge of unexplained absences in the workplace

    Nick Hurley

    In the Press

  • Sophie Rothwell writes for Law 360 on the Bullying and Respect at Work Bill

    Sophie Rothwell

    In the Press

  • Sexual Orientation Discrimination in the Workplace

    Michael Powner

    Insights

  • Supreme Court offers reassurance to administrators where large-scale redundancies are necessary

    Jana Billington

    Insights

  • Kelly Evans and Francesca Heath-Clarke write for People Management on the right to disconnect

    Kelly Evans

    In the Press

  • Bullying and Respect at Work Bill – a vital evolution of the employment law landscape?

    Sophie Rothwell

    Insights

  • 2024 - What's on the employment law horizon?

    Nick Hurley

    Insights

  • What a Labour Government might mean for employment law

    Nick Hurley

    Insights

  • Francesca Charlton and Kayleigh McKee write for People Management on the Worker Protection Act

    Francesca Charlton

    In the Press

  • An important reminder for employers on World Menopause Day

    Isobel Goodman

    Quick Reads

  • Dubai announces its plan to streamline the enforcement of civil judgments and arbitral awards

    Peter Smith

    Quick Reads

  • UK Government announces consultation on calculating holiday entitlement for part-year and irregular hours workers

    Francesca Charlton

    Quick Reads

  • Right to work checks – an issue for both immigration and employment law and practice.

    Quick Reads

  • New industry group aims to build sustainability skills in the construction sector

    Carolyn Davies

    Quick Reads

  • Are workers entitled to the Bank Holiday off for the Queen’s Jubilee? Don’t bank on it!

    Sophie Clark

    Quick Reads

  • How to tackle a large Gender Pay Gap

    Emily Chalkley

    Quick Reads

  • New Employer and Landlord Digital ID Checks – A Good IDea?

    Paul McCarthy

    Quick Reads

  • Out of Office – 5 tips for employers considering a more flexible approach to where we work

    Quick Reads

  • AI and HR - How can employers reduce the risks associated with using artificial intelligence to help manage their workforce?

    Briony Richards

    Quick Reads

  • The Tip of the Iceberg of Changes to a Modern Hospitality Industry? Hospitality staff entitled to keep all tips under new rules

    Quick Reads

  • Flexible working requests: 5 tips for employers

    Quick Reads

  • Covid passports - are they workable or just a shambles?

    Harriet Lucas

    Quick Reads

  • Brace yourselves: dentists could be liable for actions of self-employed staff

    Quick Reads

  • Government to introduce duty on employers to prevent sexual harassment

    Nick Hurley

    Quick Reads

  • Do You Believe?

    Briony Richards

    Quick Reads

  • It’s all about the data…why has the government delayed hospitality reopening again?

    Michael Powner

    Quick Reads

  • Restaurants must keep innovating to survive the impact of another lockdown

    Quick Reads

  • UK Government considering a crackdown on unfair employment contract clauses

    Quick Reads

Back to top