• news-banner

    Expert Insights

Unknown future claims cannot be settled

The EAT has confirmed in Bathgate v Technip that provisions in the Equality Act 2010 mean that unknown future claims cannot be compromised in a settlement agreement. 

In January 2017, Mr Bathgate entered into a voluntary redundancy agreement which provided for enhanced redundancy, notice payments and an additional pension payment to be calculated by reference to a maritime collective agreement.  He signed a settlement agreement in full and final settlement of claims.  The agreement included a list of claims including age discrimination and a general waiver of all claims: past, present or future.   Three months later his employer concluded that under the terms of the collective agreement, as he was over 61 at time of dismissal, he was not entitled to the pension payment.  He was informed of this in June 2017, six months after he had signed his settlement agreement.  He brought a claim of age discrimination and his employer argued that he was precluded from bringing this claim because of the terms of the settlement agreement. 

The EAT held that to validly settle a claim under the Equality Act it must relate to the “particular complaint” which had to be identified in the agreement either by a generic description or by reference to the statutory provision giving rise to the claim.  However, a “particular complaint” did not include a complaint that may or may not occur at some point in the future.  In reaching this decision, the EAT took into account case law and an excerpt from Hansard which showed that the equivalent provision in the Employment Rights Act 1996 was intended only to be available in the context of a complaint that had already arisen. There was a public policy concern about the employer’s construction that future claims could be covered which would allow employees to sign away their rights without a proper understanding of what they were doing.  To decide otherwise would mean that Mr Bathgate had signed away his right to sue for age discrimination before he knew whether he had a claim. 

Practical considerations

This decision shows the importance of ensuring that the “particular complaint” is identified in any settlement agreement and confirms that it is not possible to settle future claims that are unknown at the time of signing whatever wording is included.

Employers should also ensure that the quantum of any compensation paid to the employee reflects the nature of the particular complaint(s) only, given that only the particular complaint(s) are being settled.

Our thinking

  • Mental Health Management

    Nick Hurley

    Events

  • Religious Discrimination at Work: Protecting Religion & Beliefs

    Syma Spanjers

    Insights

  • People Management quotes Briony Richards on workplace monitoring and employee privacy

    Briony Richards

    In the Press

  • Avoiding Discriminatory Dismissal Claims

    Ben Smith

    Insights

  • Charles Russell Speechlys Business School Inspire programme granted Institute Approved status by the Institute of Leadership

    Karen Stages

    News

  • Family rights changes

    Sara Wilson

    Insights

  • Syma Spanjers writes for People Management on flexibility around religious holiday requests

    Syma Spanjers

    In the Press

  • Adam Kyte and James Lamont write for Construction News on the crackdown of illegal working in the sector

    Adam Kyte

    In the Press

  • Expert Insights

    Michael Powner

    Insights

  • Sara Wilson and Izzie Beddard write for People Management on the 'right to switch off'

    Sara Wilson

    In the Press

  • Clash of Protected Rights in the Workplace

    Michael Powner

    Insights

  • Personnel Today quotes Vivienne Shirley on the Kristie Higgs religious discrimination case

    In the Press

  • Age Discrimination at work - How to promote anti discriminatory practice

    Ben Smith

    Insights

  • South West Business Insider quotes Sara Wilson on social media policies in the workplace

    Sara Wilson

    In the Press

  • Emily Chalkley writes for The Evening Standard on the Goldman Sachs equal pay settlement and potential for future claims

    Emily Chalkley

    In the Press

  • Employment Podcast: Sexual harassment in the workplace

    Sophie Rothwell

    Podcasts

  • Nick Hurley writes for City AM on the government’s plan to slash non-compete clauses

    Nick Hurley

    In the Press

  • We asked ChatGPT about harnessing AI in the workplace – this is what it said

    Michael Powner

    Insights

  • Sexual harassment in the workplace

    Sophie Rothwell

    Insights

  • The Employment (Allocation of Tips) Act receives Royal Assent – but does it fail to consider the practical realities facing employers operating within the hospitality sector?

    Michael Powner

    Insights

  • Dubai announces its plan to streamline the enforcement of civil judgments and arbitral awards

    Peter Smith

    Quick Reads

  • UK Government announces consultation on calculating holiday entitlement for part-year and irregular hours workers

    Francesca Charlton

    Quick Reads

  • Right to work checks – an issue for both immigration and employment law and practice.

    Charlotte O'Connor

    Quick Reads

  • New industry group aims to build sustainability skills in the construction sector

    Carolyn Davies

    Quick Reads

  • Are workers entitled to the Bank Holiday off for the Queen’s Jubilee? Don’t bank on it!

    Sophie Clark

    Quick Reads

  • How to tackle a large Gender Pay Gap

    Emily Chalkley

    Quick Reads

  • New Employer and Landlord Digital ID Checks – A Good IDea?

    Paul McCarthy

    Quick Reads

  • Out of Office – 5 tips for employers considering a more flexible approach to where we work

    Sam Lawn

    Quick Reads

  • AI and HR - How can employers reduce the risks associated with using artificial intelligence to help manage their workforce?

    Briony Richards

    Quick Reads

  • The Tip of the Iceberg of Changes to a Modern Hospitality Industry? Hospitality staff entitled to keep all tips under new rules

    Sam Lawn

    Quick Reads

  • Flexible working requests: 5 tips for employers

    Quick Reads

  • Covid passports - are they workable or just a shambles?

    Harriet Lucas

    Quick Reads

  • Brace yourselves: dentists could be liable for actions of self-employed staff

    Quick Reads

  • Government to introduce duty on employers to prevent sexual harassment

    Nick Hurley

    Quick Reads

  • Do You Believe?

    Briony Richards

    Quick Reads

  • It’s all about the data…why has the government delayed hospitality reopening again?

    Michael Powner

    Quick Reads

  • Restaurants must keep innovating to survive the impact of another lockdown

    Anna Rogers

    Quick Reads

  • UK Government considering a crackdown on unfair employment contract clauses

    Quick Reads

  • Towards a new RPI - good news or bad?

    Quick Reads

  • Feeling fine? New Covid-19 regulations impose financial sanctions on employers not following the rules.

    Quick Reads

Back to top