Disclosing Settlement Agreements in Due Diligence: Navigating Confidentiality and Risk
min readIntroduction
All company acquisitions involve a degree of due diligence and disclosure, crucial processes undertaken by the purchaser and the seller on the target company before entering into a corporate transaction such as a merger, acquisition or investment. Its purpose is to allow the purchaser to identify the assets, liabilities and potential risks and opportunities associated with the merger, acquisition or investment assess whether it aligns with the purchaser’s strategic aims and objectives and support an informed decision about whether to proceed given the target company’s price and risk profile. Identifying potential liabilities and risks early can help purchasers avoid costly mistakes, appropriately mitigate any risks and maximise transaction value.
As part of this due diligence process, a seller is generally required to disclose disputes and/or settlements entered into with the target company’s employees or other third parties. A seller will often be required to give warranties to the purchaser on the state of affairs of the target company and be required to formally disclose to the purchaser any exceptions to those warranties, including any previous or settled disputes Tension can arise between the purchaser’s expectations and the seller and target companies’ obligations where the relevant settlement agreement contains a stringent confidentiality clause, as is often the case in standard employer-employee settlement agreements. Typically, settlement agreements contain a provision requiring the parties to keep the existence and terms of the settlement confidential, subject to disclosures required by law or to the parties’ respective auditors, insurers and solicitors on terms that preserve confidentiality. Some agreements also contain helpful carve-out provisions — for example, permitting disclosure to any person who owes the selling entity a duty of confidentiality — but these provisions are less common and tend to depart from the wording used in standard settlement agreements.
Balancing Risk
In a due diligence context, this can leave a seller in a difficult position. Failing to disclose material information at the due diligence stage can expose the selling entity to significant legal and commercial risks, including breach of contract, misrepresentation and, in some circumstances, fraudulent concealment claims. From a commercial perspective, the consequences may extend to a price reduction, loss of trust and, ultimately, termination of the transaction. Conversely, disclosing a settlement agreement to third parties in breach of an express confidentiality provision may expose the seller to a breach of contract claim.
Some confidentiality clauses provide that disclosure can be granted, but written consent must be obtained from the counterparty beforehand. Whilst this seems sensible in principle, seeking consent may be unattractive where the transaction is commercially sensitive, particularly if the seller does not want a former employee or other interested party to learn that a potential deal is under consideration.
How Should a Seller Proceed?
Given the clear risks outlined above, disclosure is often considered as non-negotiable, irrespective of wording of the confidentiality provisions. Instead, most selling entities shift the focus to assessing the real (instead of hypothetical) risk of disclosing such agreements. Whilst doing so may amount to a technical breach, the relevant questions are (1) what loss or damage the counterparty to the settlement agreement would suffer as a result of the unauthorised disclosure and (2) what remedies would be available.
Quantifying Loss & Damage
In terms of assessing loss and/or damage, it is not immediately apparent what loss a counterparty could claim to have suffered from disclosure of a historic settlement agreement. The ordinary compensatory measure of damages may have limited application: in the majority of cases, it is unlikely to involve a conventional loss-of-profits claim, and the confidential information is unlikely to have an exploitable market value, subject to the facts. In other contexts, the absence of an adequate damages remedy might support an application for an injunction. Here, however, the practical and time-based limitations make that risk remote. An injunction is unlikely to provide meaningful protection in this context because disclosure is likely to have occurred before the counterparty becomes aware of it.
The more remote possibility is a claim for Wrotham Park damages where the usual compensatory measure is unavailable. This principle is derived from the case of Wrotham Park Estate Co v Parkside Homes Ltd [1974] 1 WLR 789, in which the Court of Appeal held that so called ‘Wrotham Park’ damages could be awarded where it is difficult for the claimant to establish identifiable financial loss and there were no exceptional circumstances. For Wrotham Park damages to be awarded, the following three conditions must be met:
- The defendant has deliberately breached its contractual obligations for its own reward;
- It will be difficult for the claimant to establish its financial loss; and
- The claimant has a legitimate interest in preventing the defendant’s profit-making activity in breach of contract.
The remedy is assessed under a hypothetical bargain test: the court determines the price the parties would have agreed for the release of one party from its obligations. In principle, it may strip a defendant of gains attributable to the breach. That said, these claims are difficult to predict and, subject to the background facts, are difficult to satisfy. For example, the likely award for disclosing the existence and terms of a settlement agreement which could be several years old in a due diligence data room are likely to be nominal, if any.
Even if such a claim were viable, causation may also present a substantial hurdle: it would be difficult to link the disclosure of a single document, among hundreds or thousands reviewed in due diligence, to any alleged gain, such as consideration from a completed sale, given the intervening events. Accordingly, subject to the facts of each particular case, success appears unlikely and, whether or not a breach has occurred, the overall litigation risk is likely to be, in reality, low. It is worth noting that in the Wrotham Park case, the court emphasised that this was not a typical case due to the level of secrecy and subterfuge involved, which effectively deprived the claimant of an opportunity to obtain an interim injunction.
Risk Mitigation Strategies
Whilst it seems unlikely that a claim arising from the unauthorised disclosure of a settlement agreement would succeed, for the reasons set out above, a risk undoubtedly remains. In light of this, sellers can take several practical steps to mitigate this risk further:
- At the outset of the transaction, ensure any NDAs entered into with the purchaser and other relevant recipients contains clear restrictions on:
- further disclosure to internal or third parties;
- contact by the purchaser with any former colleagues in relation to the matter;
- any obligations under UK GDPR to be adhered to by the purchaser,
- and are on terms that preserve any wider disclosure than is strictly necessary for the prospective sale.
- Apply data-room access controls, including need-to-know view, download and print permissions and audit trails.
- Redact information that could identify the counterparty in any documents or responses disclosed to the purchaser. If concerns remain for the transaction proceeding, consider delaying disclosure of the settlement agreement until the transaction is more certain to proceed or initially providing the purchaser with a summary that omits the counterparty’s identity (by using initials or otherwise). All communication between the purchaser and seller on the matter should omit the counterparty’s identity. The full agreement with any appropriate redactions can then be disclosed once the transaction is more likely to proceed.
- Use a “clean team” where the purchaser’s independent lawyers, who are not otherwise involved in the transaction, review commercially sensitive or highly confidential documents and report material risks without disclosing the underlying information to the purchaser.
Conclusion
Settlement agreements therefore create a genuine tension between contractual confidentiality obligations and the seller’s duty to provide sufficient disclosure for due diligence. Although the litigation risk arising from disclosure is generally low, sellers should manage it through carefully drafted NDAs, controlled data-room access, targeted redaction and, where appropriate, clean-team review. Careful management of these safeguards will enable sellers to navigate the process while protecting confidentiality and preserving transaction momentum.