• news-banner

    Expert Insights

Court of Appeal rules against the taxpayer in company tax residence dispute

Under UK law, a company is “resident” in the UK for corporation tax purposes if it is either incorporated in the UK or “centrally managed and controlled” in the UK, the latter point being a question of fact.

The Court of Appeal yesterday released its decision in Revenue & Customs v Development Securities plc and others [2020] EWCA Civ 1705, which concerns the question of when a non-UK incorporated company is centrally managed and controlled from the UK such that it becomes UK tax resident.  It represents a victory for HMRC, but the scope of the judgment is limited.

The decision allows HMRC’s appeal and affirms the decision of the First-tier Tribunal (FTT). The FTT decision was that the board of directors of a number of Jersey incorporated companies did not exercise central management and control, but had instead followed the instructions of the UK parent company. 

The transactions entered into by the Jersey companies (which involved the acquisition of assets at an overvalue) were part of a wider tax planning arrangement and the FTT found from the evidence presented that the directors in Jersey were in reality agreeing to implement transactions on the instruction of the parent company (based in the UK). The finding of fact was that the directors in Jersey had not acted improperly, but had not engaged with the substantive decision (which involved a transaction that was uncommercial from the perspective of the Jersey companies). That was insufficient for the directors be exercising central management and control from Jersey.

The Upper Tribunal determined that the FTT had erred in law and was not entitled to reach the conclusion it did on the basis of the facts found by the FTT, because the directors had applied their minds to the transaction and did not abdicate their decision making responsibilities.

The Court of Appeal considered that the Upper Tribunal had mischaracterised the basis of the FTT decision and therefore allowed the appeal. However, there was no Respondent’s notice seeking to uphold the Upper Tribunal’s decision on an alternative basis and so the usefulness of the decision in assessing the question of residence is limited. There appeared to be a disagreement between the judges on the substantive issues considered by the FTT. Nugee LJ expressed “very considerable reservations about the FTT’s reasoning”, while Richards LJ did “not have any concerns about the decision of the FTT or their reasons” and Newey LJ declined to express a view on the point.

The decision illustrates the difficulties that can arise in considering where a company is resident for tax purposes, but unfortunately offers little clarity as to how the Tribunal should approach this question if a case came before it with similar facts. Nugee LJ  referred to the observation of Mr Grodzinski (acting for the taxpayer) “…the FTT's decision was the first time in any case where the local board of directors of a company had actually met, had understood what they were being asked to do, had understood why they were being asked to do it, had decided it was lawful, had reviewed for itself the transactional documents, had been found not to have acted mindlessly, but had nevertheless been found not to have exercised CMC.” This shows that there may be a high bar in future to establish that central management and control is exercised outside the UK.

This article was written by Helen Coward. For more information, please contact Helen on +44 (0)20 7427 6766 or at helen.coward@crsblaw.com.

Our thinking

  • Mental Health Management

    Nick Hurley

    Events

  • Doing business in the UAE & Israel

    William Reichert

    Events

  • Calculating Social Value in BTR

    Francis Ho

    Events

  • Dangers of trusts

    Mark Summers

    Events

  • The Evening Standard quotes Rose Carey on the increase in visa fees

    Rose Carey

    In the Press

  • Charles Russell Speechlys advises Zenzero’s management team on its majority acquisition by Macquarie Capital

    Mark Howard

    News

  • Updates and points to note in relation to buy-to-let residential properties

    Twiggy Ho

    Insights

  • Felicity Chapman writes for Insider Media on alternatives to court for divorcing business owners

    Felicity Chapman

    In the Press

  • Investment Week quotes Julia Cox on the proposed scrapping of inheritance tax

    Julia Cox

    In the Press

  • Charles Russell Speechlys expands commercial offering with the appointment of Rebecca Steer

    Rebecca Steer

    News

  • The Times quotes Gareth Mills on the CMA’s preliminary approval of the Activision Blizzard-Microsoft deal

    Gareth Mills

    In the Press

  • Heritage property and conditional exemption

    Sarah Wray

    Insights

  • The Financial Times quotes Emma Humphreys on UK rental costs

    Emma Humphreys

    In the Press

  • City AM quotes Gareth Mills on the CMA’s new set of principles for regulating AI

    Gareth Mills

    In the Press

  • Hamish Perry and Mike Barrington write for The Evening Standard on whether a merger between the CBI and Make UK can work

    Hamish Perry

    In the Press

  • Silicon quotes Gareth Mills on the UK consumer lawsuit against Google

    Gareth Mills

    In the Press

  • Property Week quotes Louise Ward on the additional support required by aspiring UK life sciences operators

    Louise Ward

    In the Press

  • Sarah Higgins and David Wells-Cole write for Wealth Briefing on the pitfalls of using unregulated legal services

    Sarah Higgins

    In the Press

  • Charles Russell Speechlys Luxembourg strengthens tax practice with the recruitment of David Cordova Flores

    Yacine Diallo

    News

  • Office to Lab Conversions: A new lease of life (sciences) for some of London’s offices?

    Georgina Muskett

    Quick Reads

  • New Governance Guidelines for family-owned businesses in the UAE

    William Reichert

    Quick Reads

  • Charles Russell Speechlys’ UK offices receive environmental certification

    Kerry Stares

    News

  • The Family Fund: Bank of Mum & Dad 2.0

    Vanessa Duff

    Quick Reads

  • The perpetual struggle between the environment, heritage and development: the M&S decision vs 55 Bishopsgate

    Sophie Willis

    Quick Reads

  • Treasury Committee endorses mandatory venture capital diversity policies from 2025

    Lia Renna

    Quick Reads

  • Oops!....I did it again - Britney's third divorce

    Charlotte Posnansky

    Quick Reads

  • Recognising financial abuse in a relationship

    Vanessa Duff

    Quick Reads

  • Has the Orpéa plan impaired shareholder's consent? - Le plan de sauvegarde d'Orpéa n'a-t-il pas vicié le consentement des actionnaires historiques ?

    Dimitri-André Sonier

    Quick Reads

  • Will the downturn in the Paris region property market lead property companies to turn to ad hoc proceedings, as they did in the 1990s?

    Dimitri-André Sonier

    Quick Reads

  • Making BitCoin a BitClearer

    Charlotte Posnansky

    Quick Reads

  • Key figures gather to discuss the future of Gloucestershire

    Jonathan Morley

    Quick Reads

  • UK CMA's blocks Microsoft's acquisition of Activision Blizzard, a potentially significant decision for SMEs in the video gaming sector

    Rebecca Burford

    Quick Reads

  • Key takeaways from the UK Government's "Green Day"

    Martha Glaser

    Quick Reads

  • From Holby City to 5 Fleet Place - David Ames shares his experience of "Behind the Lens" with CRS

    Quick Reads

  • The Domestic Abuse Act 2021 in Action

    Sophia Leeder

    Quick Reads

  • Number crunching times

    Emma Humphreys

    Quick Reads

  • This week in the news: inheritance tax interest costs rising due to Probate delays

    Sarah Wray

    Quick Reads

  • WhatsAppGate - Should businesses be reviewing their social media policies?

    Anna Rogers

    Quick Reads

  • Updates to EMI Options in the Spring Budget 2023

    Quick Reads

  • Dubai announces its plan to streamline the enforcement of civil judgments and arbitral awards

    Peter Smith

    Quick Reads

Back to top